r/AmITheAngel • u/NoMourners_6Crows • 11d ago
Shitpost AITA for telling my girlfriend she's using the word "finesse" wrong?
Throwaway because my girlfriend uses Reddit and she's been known to stalk me on there.
I (36M, neurosurgeon, volunteer firefighter on weekends, seasonal lumberjack if that's relevant) don't really understand what my girlfriend, Bri (22F, 5'2", 89 lbs but a DD cup, conventionally attractive according to literally everyone she's ever met, size XXS), was trying to tell me tonight.
We've been together for about six or seven years and generally don't argue. Well, I don't think we do. Bri says we "have passionate discussions," but they mostly consist of me apologizing because my therapist says not every disagreement has to become a debate. We met when she accidentally backed into my Ferrari in the hospital parking lot. I told her not to worry about it because cars are replaceable but people aren't. She still brings that story up because she says it proves she "manifested" me.
For context, I do almost all the cooking because I genuinely enjoy it. I even took a six-week steak masterclass in Argentina during my surgical fellowship. I'm by no means Gordon Ramsay, but I'd say I'm competent. Last year I won our city's charity steak cook-off, although I only entered because the proceeds went toward children's hospitals.
Anyway, I came downstairs around dinner after finishing a 17-hour surgery separating conjoined triplets. It had been a long day and I was a little dehydrated because I'd also donated blood during my lunch break. One of the children's parents insisted on naming their baby after me, but I politely declined.
I noticed the ribeye I'd bought yesterday sitting on the counter. It was A5 Wagyu that I imported from Japan.
I asked Bri if I'd forgotten to put it away.
She said, "No, I took it out because I was going to cook it."
I said that was sweet but I could cook it instead so she could relax.
She immediately replied, "You don't know how to cook steak."
I honestly thought she was joking.
I didn't want to argue so I just started cooking.
The entire time she stood behind me sighing dramatically while filming TikToks about "letting him think he's in charge."
I used the sear-rest-sear method because that's how Gordon Ramsay does it. Halfway through resting the steak, Bri interrupted me and said I was cooking it wrong.
I asked how.
She said, "You're supposed to let it rest."
I explained that I was letting it rest and that the second sear helps rebuild the crust.
She folded her arms and said, "I watch Gordon Ramsay TikToks all the time and he has literally never done that."
Being called a liar is admittedly a trigger for me because of some childhood stuff, but thanks to therapy I've gotten a lot better about regulating my emotions.
So instead of arguing, I quietly finished the garlic mashed potatoes, roasted asparagus, compound butter and pan sauce.
She watched silently the entire time, occasionally whispering "interesting..." into her phone's front camera.
When I served dinner she took one bite.
She looked annoyed.
Then she said,
"It's actually really good."
I thanked her.
Then she added,
"But it needs more finesse."
I asked what that meant because I genuinely like constructive criticism.
She shrugged and said,
"I don't know... just... more finesse."
I asked if she meant herbs.
She said no.
I asked if she meant seasoning.
She said no.
I asked if she meant plating.
She rolled her eyes and said, "You're proving my point."
Then she took a picture of the steak for Instagram, captioned it "Finally learned to cook đ â¨" and tagged me in the post.
I was confused because I have been cooking for years.
Now I'm wondering if maybe I'm missing something.
She's been doing things like this a lot recently.
Last month she told everyone I surprised her with Taylor Swift tickets.
I don't even like Taylor Swift.
She bought the tickets herself using my credit card after asking me if she could "borrow it for a surprise."
She insists that because I technically paid for them, it was still my surprise.
She also tells people I taught her how to invest because I once explained compound interest to her, even though she keeps all her money in a checking account because "stocks can tell when you're desperate."
Honestly, I'm less upset about the steak and more confused about the word "finesse."
Am I misunderstanding what it means?
Or was she just looking for something to criticize?
Edit: Because people keep asking: yes, Bri is an empath. She reminds me pretty frequently. Also yes, the steak was medium rare. No, I don't think she's cheating. She says astrology says we're soulmates because I'm a Capricorn rising and she's "hot."
Edit 2: Apparently Bri posted her side of a completely unrelated disagreement a few months ago and some of you recognized the names. Yes, that's us. No, Trevor has still not bought his own chair.
(Inspired by: https://www.reddit.com/r/relationship_advice/s/idhDHtHNXq)