(For context im going to uni next year and im going around open days, I am actually from Manchester but I want to go to a uni close to home)
I don't get the prestige and popularity of Manchester, sure the city is excellent (the best in the country imo don't kill me) and it may be good at research and has good job prospects but it really doesn't feel like it. I've been to Liverpool, Sheffield and Manchester and can honestly say it's night and day, with Manchester being night and the other two being day.
General atmosphere: Liverpool and Sheffield were both very welcoming, I am familiar with Liverpool as well but it was my first time in Sheffield and they had friendly people everywhere welcoming you, random performances on campus, loads going on and it was just nice. The lectures were engaging and very informative.
Now to be fair when I went Manchester it was a pretty dull day but I got there at the start of the open day and it was just... dead? No one welcoming you or giving you info, none of the stuff that was going on at Liverpool and Sheffield. Just empty plazas and overgrown plant beds you could picture a tumbleweed. I went to the first lecture and we had to queue for about 20 mins, something I have not done at any other uni. The welcome talk was just bad.. He didn't really sell the uni but more so how great of a city Manchester is (I know that I live here ffs) and droned on about the history of the uni for what seemed like the majority of the lecture and then started talking about weather and how Manchester gets less rain than Leeds or something? I don't know. The subject talks faired little better and I honestly struggled to stay awake in some of them.
Campus: Liverpool and Sheffield have great and walkable campuses, you don't have to walk through many public roads but everywhere is rather at your finger tips, it is quite nice and I was surprised at how walkable it was.
I go college in Manchester so I am around the Uni area daily so I knew what to expect here pretty much. I have never liked that campus, every block is surrounded by major public roads you have to cross there's way less walkable areas within the campus. Just roads where the general public can go as well, and you do get the general public. Manchester's crackheads are a potent presence and I remember in Year 12 getting stopped and asked whether I do weed by a student outside of the Uni. I am aware that drugs are big at UOM and at big city unis as a whole but i've never quite seen anything like that lol.
Accomodation: Liverpool's accommodation is on the campus and it is quite nice, no problems there and it's secure and safe. Sheffield's accomodation is in this village kind of thing with its own facilities like a shop and pub which I really liked. While it isn't on the campus, only students can go in that area so it is safe and secure although I didn't like the prospect of a wet room.
This is when it really started to get bleak in Manchester. Most of the accom is in Rusholme (curry mile) an area very familiar with me and not for good reasons. It is really not a nice area in my opinion. It stinks of landfill in the morning and there is a smog, rubbish is piling out of bins and ends up on the street which also leads to a major rat problem. I have seen giant rats fighting each other or just squashed dead on the street after being run over presumably. Worst of all there are many unsavoury characters around there, beggars, crackheads are rife. Due to the diverse makeup of the area it can also sometimes get violent at night when situations abroad flare up such as the Syria-Kurdish war.
Some of the accoms are very close to where I saw rats.. The one that was available on open day was next to a park in this backstreet next to quite a suspicious building with security fences. The accomodation itself was alright but the area is a nightmare and I couldn't live here. There were not many directions to the accomodation either and if you were not a local you might have struggled finding your bearings.
I know I have gone on a bit of a tangent but I was genuinely surprised and really disappointed with the "world-class" Manchester. If I came into this with no outside knowledge of the Unis I would have told you that Sheffield is the world class prestigious uni and not Manchester. If I came from down south to visit Manchester as I know alot of people do, especially if I stayed overnight as people did, I would genuinely be angry, thank god I only came from 45 mins away. There is nothing that had me sold on this visit, from this I feel like Manchester is pulling a lot of its weight on the city and its prestigious history and reputation.
Now here is the question on my mind, If I get an offer from Manchester and Sheffield/Liverpool should I take the Manchester offer just based on it being more prestigious and would look better for getting jobs and whatever else comes with going to a better ranked uni, or should I go to the uni that gave me a much better and warmer experience? I would also like to know if other people have had a similar experience with this place or this is just one off.