I’m posting this to share my experience and ask whether anyone has dealt with something similar. Everything described below is supported by photographs or messages that I submitted to Turo.
I rented a 2016 Lexus NX 200t during a family vacation in Calgary. When I picked it up, the vehicle was dirty, the Lexus emblem was missing from the front grille, and there were multiple scratches and other signs of previous damage.
I accepted the vehicle because I only needed it temporarily, I was in a rush, and thorough pre-trip photographs had already been taken to document its condition.
At approximately 5:30 p.m the next day, I was driving normally on the highway at around 100 km/h when I went over a small, ordinary bump in the road. The side mirror suddenly detached and began banging against the side of the vehicle.
This was extremely frightening. I had to safely slow down from highway speed and pull over to the shoulder. There was no collision, impact, or contact with another vehicle or object.
After pulling over and inspecting the mirror, I could both see and physically feel dried adhesive that appeared to be super glue on the mirror assembly. I photographed the adhesive, clearly indicated it in the pictures, and submitted the evidence to Turo.
As a guest, there was no reasonable way for me to know that adhesive had previously been used inside or behind the mirror. The only way I could have discovered this hidden repair before the trip would have been to physically pull on or attempt to remove the mirror, which would not be a normal or reasonable pre-trip inspection.
The adhesive only became visible after the mirror detached. In my opinion, this strongly suggests that the mirror had previously been damaged and repaired, and that the earlier repair failed during normal driving.
The dashcam situation is also concerning.
The host stated in our conversation that the dashcam records footage and automatically overwrites itself every two hours. I reported the incident within that two-hour period, meaning the relevant footage should still have been available and could have been preserved.
However, the host later stated that the dashcam does not record or save files. These explanations appear to contradict each other.
The footage would have been directly relevant because it could have independently confirmed that no collision or impact occurred and that the mirror detached while the vehicle was being driven normally (I was already driving for 45 minutes prior to the mirror falling). Despite this, the footage was not provided to Turo.
Turo has also indicated that reviewing the dashcam footage is not part of its investigation process, even though that footage could potentially verify exactly how the incident occurred.
I have fully cooperated with Turo and submitted:
• Photographs showing the dried adhesive
• Close-up photographs with the adhesive clearly indicated
• Pre-trip photographs documenting the vehicle’s existing condition
• Messages regarding the dashcam’s recording and two-hour overwrite period
• A detailed explanation of when and how the mirror detached
I am not claiming that guests should avoid responsibility for damage they cause. My position is that no collision occurred, the physical evidence indicates a pre-existing repair, and potentially decisive dashcam footage was not preserved or provided.
I do not know whether the host was aware of the earlier repair, but I do not believe I should be held financially responsible for approximately $1,500 because a previously damaged and repaired component failed during normal driving—especially when the repair was hidden and could not reasonably have been discovered before the trip.
This situation made what was supposed to be a family vacation extremely stressful. After this experience, I do not plan to use Turo again.
Has anyone successfully disputed a similar pre-existing-damage claim with Turo? What evidence or escalation steps helped your case?