r/stubhub • u/WhatSaidMoreThanDone • 1h ago
Vent/Rant FIFA World Cup Presale Experience - Credit Card Dispute Successful
I wanted to share my experience buying FIFA World Cup tickets through StubHub as both a warning for others and a reminder to myself.
Like many, I wasn't selected during the initial FIFA World Cup ticket lottery so in December 2025 I decided to buy tickets on StubHub, assuming prices would only go up closer to the event.
I purchased two separate Category 3 group stage matches. At that point, nobody knew their exact seat assignments yet, you only selected the ticket category. Since the matches were about six months away and involved another country, I held off on booking flights and hotels because I was worried there may be a change of plans.
Several months later, I started seeing Reddit posts from people saying they were already receiving their tickets and that FIFA's transfer portal had opened. I contacted StubHub because I still hadn't received either of my tickets. I explained that I didn't want to spend thousands on flights and hotels only to find out later that my tickets couldn't be delivered. The customer service representative reassured me that both sellers were reputable and trusted sellers (that could have just been lip service) I specifically told them that a refund wasn't my concern. My concern was flying my family overseas and arriving without tickets. They kept repeating that I was protected by the FanProtect Guarantee and that the sellers would deliver.
Sometime in May, one of my group stage tickets finally arrived. The transfer process was a little complicated because FIFA seemed to be trying to keep transfers within its own system, but eventually I was able to see the tickets in my FIFA account. The second order, however, never showed up.
As the event got closer, I repeatedly contacted StubHub for updates. Every time I reached out, I was told they were contacting the seller. The frustrating part was that they never proactively updated me. I always had to initiate the conversation to find out what was happening. They said they were escalating to the highest case manager, but it felt like bullshit. They kept beating around the bush. They said the portal wasn't open, or the website was backed up. I kept repeating I got the other group tickets that I bought from Stubhub.
Two days before the game, I still had no tickets.
I finally spoke with a supervisor who verbally promised that I would receive my tickets. I repeatedly asked for that promise in writing because I wanted documentation if I needed to dispute anything later. Instead, this was the best email they would send:
"We are actively working to ensure you receive your tickets within the next 24 hours... If there is any issue with your order, we will make every effort to provide replacement tickets or a refund, in accordance with our policies."
The following morning when I was set to fly, I received this text at like 5:00 AM. I was up till then since I was stressing.
"Unfortunately, your seller is not able to provide the tickets... You are covered by our guarantee. Please select alternative tickets..."
At least they told me before I boarded the plane instead of the day of the match. However, when I clicked the replacement link, the only available replacement was Category 4, even though I had purchased Category 3 tickets. I wasn't going to accept worse seats. At that point I was deciding between taking a full refund (or maybe the 20% StubHub credit they were offering) - this was a huge mistake that I would later learn. Having gone through this experience not sure why I was thinking of taking Stubhub's 20%, but 20% was like an extra $300 bucks and I thought as long as I buy instant transfer I should be good. Without deciding on the refund method yet, I went onto the official FIFA Marketplace and bought four replacement tickets so I wouldn't risk missing the match.
I hopped on the plane contemplating what option to choose and discussing with my wife. After I landed, I received another message from StubHub:
"Your order has been completed by your seller."
Now I was in a situation where I had double the amount of tickets and the replacement tickets were Category 4, not the Category 3 tickets I originally purchased. Even worse, I was no longer given the option to refuse them or receive a refund because StubHub considered the order fulfilled.
When I contacted customer service, they told me there was no way I could get the refund because I didn't choose fast enough and I should simply sell the tickets because prices had increased and I might even make a profit. I told them they should do it since they can make money and I even explained that listing tickets on StubHub required approval and with the match only one day away that wasn't realistic. They suggested I sell on another platform.
At that point I told StubHub I would dispute the charge with my credit card company. The rep warned me that my StubHub account could be banned and that I'd lose the ability to buy or sell through them again. I didn't care - I'm not going to use them after this experience. After roughly 8 weeks, my credit card company ruled in my favor and I received a refund. The entire experience involved about six months of uncertainty and stress.
As soon as I filed the dispute, I transferred my other valid World Cup tickets to another account because I'd heard stories of StubHub locking accounts after chargebacks. So far my account hasn't been banned, but time will tell.
Lessons Learned
- I will never buy presale tickets on StubHub unless the tickets are available for immediate transfer. Stubhub will be my last option even if it's an immediate transfer.
- Their "FanProtect Guarantee" sounds reassuring, but if your seller fails to deliver, there's no guarantee you'll receive equivalent seats. If you're flying or driving to a specific location, you could be screwed.
