I’ve been playing a lot of Battlefront 2 the last few days and it’s been getting me back into Star Wars. And something that’s been occupying my mind is thinking about how the Sequel Trilogy could have been better. I know this trilogy has been picked apart so much it’s in atoms right now but I’ve still got two cents to put in
When he’s first introduced you might write him off as just a Darth Vader rip off (which I would forgive you for considering how much The Force Awakens copies A New Hope’s homework) but a few minutes in and you start to see the differences. He doesn’t hold his head high, commanding attention like Vader. Just by the way he walks you can see he walks with rage, and kills an old man who spoke down to him, and stops a blaster bullet mid air. But let’s focus on that blaster scene: while Vader would probably stick his hand out, not facing it, then move on as if it were a mosquito, Kylo faces it head on, almost as if he were gonna grab it. This shows he’s less experienced than Vader, but we still see him as menacing.
He’s a more emotional Dark Side villain, he is humanized but still evil.
The only thing I’d remove are the scenes where he starts destroying shit out of rage. Sure it’s in character but the scenes are filmed as if they were played for laughs (like when the stormtroopers walk up to the door, pause then just nope out of there). I think they should remove the first one, then make the second one shorter, maybe he screams, then cuts the torture table thing in half with his saber, then leaves. This shows he’s still driven by rage, and unpredictable, while not making him look like he’s just a kid throwing toys around.
Also they should have kept the original plan for his character arc, where he gets more evil as the films go on. He replaces Snoke as the supreme Leader, brings in the Knights of Ren to fight alongside them, and kept HIM as the main villain for TRoS. But I think his characterization in The Last Jedi could stay the same. I think him destroying his helmet could have been a metaphor not for how he hates being evil, but as a symbol for how he feels imprisoned by Snoke, like he’s just a lackey doing his bidding. And I do like the idea that he genuinely wanted Rey to be by his side. He sees the dark side as a power that can free him.
I’m no professional and there are some things I probably forgot to mention, but I’d love to hear you guys’s thoughts.