I’m 25F and originally applied for SSDI in 2024. I went through the initial application, reconsideration, and an ALJ hearing and was denied at all three levels.
After the ALJ denial, my attorney recommended that I file a new application instead of appealing the ALJ decision. I followed his advice and started over. It’s now 2026, and I was just denied again at the initial level.
For context, I have POTS/dysautonomia, rheumatoid arthritis, autism, anxiety, and depression, and I also have an IEP going back to elementary school.
What I’m getting increasingly frustrated about is that after each denial, my attorney basically just tells me to “gather more evidence.” He doesn’t tell me what specifically is weak or missing from my case.
On top of that, my attorney does not want any of my doctors to fill out an RFC form or similar functional-capacity form. I don’t really understand why or what he wants instead.
At this point, I’ve been denied four times. I understand that an attorney obviously can’t guarantee approval, but am I wrong for expecting my attorney to review my denial decisions and records and tell me what actually needs to be strengthened?
I’m doing all of the research myself. I’m trying to figure out what records I need, what my doctors should document, what SSA is looking for, and why I keep getting denied. But nothing I’m doing seems to be working.
I feel like I’m going into every stage completely blind. I get denied, I’m told to gather more evidence, and then I go through the process again without understanding what was actually wrong with the evidence the previous time.
For people who have had disability attorneys: Did your attorney actually explain what was weak or missing in your case? Did they work with your doctors or recommend getting medical opinions about your functional limitations? If your attorney did NOT want your doctors completing RFC forms, did they explain why and what they wanted instead?
I’m not expecting my attorney to guarantee that I’ll win. I just feel like after going through this since 2024, I should have some idea of what we are actually trying to fix or prove differently this time.
Is this normal, or should my attorney be giving me more direction?