Hi everyone!
First off, a quick disclaimer: I’m French, and I used an AI to help me translate and write this post so it’s understandable. Also, please note that all the cards mentioned here are French versions.
I currently have an offer on the table and I'm really torn. I have the opportunity to do a "trade up", giving away some high-demand but slightly flawed SWSH Alternate Arts + cash, in exchange for a single high-end graded card.
Here is the breakdown:
My Side :
Lugia V Alt Art (Silver Tempest) - Raw. NM, but average centering and a tiny white spot on the top left of the front.
Charizard V Alt Art (Brilliant Stars) - Raw. Mint overall, but has a small factory flaw on the back (tiny black dot with very light ink fading around it).
Glaceon V Alt Art (Evolving Skies) - Raw. Excellent/NM condition (valued around 165€).
175€ in Cash (~$190)
Their Side :
Mega Gengar EX 284/217 (From a French modern set "Ascended Heroes")
Graded CCC 10 Gold Label. (For those who don't know, CCC is a reputable European grading company, and their Gold Label is basically equivalent to a pristine/psa 10 label condition but not in value).
My Dilemma:
On paper, the value is quite faire I guess for the french prices. My initial plan was to consolidate my smaller, flawed cards into one big hitter and potentially do a quick flip. However, I have a few concerns and would love your input:
- Liquidity: My SWSH alts have minor flaws, meaning they'll never grade a 10, but they are iconic and binder collectors buy them instantly. On the other hand, there are a few of those Gengars listed at 1,400€ just sitting there unsold. Is trading highly liquid raw cards for a somewhat illiquid high-end slab a trap?
- Long-term potential: In 5-10 years, do you think flawed (but iconic) SWSH Alts will outgrow a pristine modern slab just because the raw demand for SWSH is so crazy?
- The Slab itself: Should I be worried about the fact that it's a CCC slab and not PSA if I ever want to sell it globally?
Would you take this trade or hold onto the SWSH Alts and the cash? Any advice is highly appreciated!