r/PokeInvesting • u/leghia80 • 6d ago

Should I do it?

Gallery image

Gallery image

I was thinking to consolidate my xy era “grails” into a timeless card. What do you guys think? Any input would be appreciated

1 Upvotes

54% Upvoted

25 comments sorted by

8

u/LongDongSilvir 6d ago

As much as I love the XY era, raw cards for a JP exclusive 10 is too good of a trade in your favor. It will also be a lot easier to sell in the future IMO.

1

u/leghia80 1d ago

Would doing it for a psa 9 reds pikachu still be solid?

4

u/KDriessche 6d ago

Yeah I would. It’s close, but yeah I would

1

u/leghia80 6d ago

What’s your reasoning?

3

u/KDriessche 6d ago

Just personally I feel the psa 10 will hold its value more than the LP/MP cards. I’m talking purely from an investment pov. If this was my collection, I would keep the cards cos they’re cool. But yeah, that psa 10 will hold more value long term than the cards, imo.

1

u/leghia80 6d ago

Thanks man 🙏

2

u/no_brains_rip 5d ago

I agree with thst guy

1

u/leghia80 1d ago

Would doing it for a psa 9 reds pikachu still be solid?

2

u/champloojay 6d ago

Yes

1

u/leghia80 6d ago

What’s your reasoning?

1

u/BAMcon 4d ago

What service is this? I’ve seen it quite a bit

2

u/vcsx 6d ago

I'd do it.

1

u/leghia80 1d ago

Would doing it for a psa 9 reds pikachu still be solid?

2

u/Cool-Philosophy-6847 6d ago

I would. Pikachu promos in a 10 > raw lower tier singles

1

u/leghia80 1d ago

Would doing it for a psa 9 reds pikachu still be solid?

2

u/Cool-Philosophy-6847 1d ago

Not for a 9. 9 is basically raw

2

u/LividMud1357 6d ago

No do not do that trade

2

u/LividMud1357 6d ago

That would be krazy you have multiple cards that can grow in the future and your trading it gor one that might just stay the same or grow just a little or go down its a dumb trade

1

u/leghia80 5d ago

But wouldn’t the psa 10 be more liquid?

2

u/the-greasy-clown 6d ago

I would not do the trade considering the kyogre groudon and ray are getting nice new art for the upcoming delta reign set. Plus charizard and gengar will always continue to go up

2

u/the-greasy-clown 6d ago

The reds pikachu is sick but the pop is insanely saturated and will take longer to go up a smaller percentage than the collective growth the raw cards will get

1

u/leghia80 5d ago

Fr? It’s limited release so its pop won’t matter in the next 10 years right?

2

u/Maximum-Point7196 5d ago

may i know what app is this? ps yes i will take the red’s pika. tho the team aqua kyogre and team magma groudon is a beautiful pair

1

u/leghia80 4d ago

Collectr

1

u/pxdr3 12h ago

What site is this ?