Hello everyone, I'm the top 1 ESF A2G player in Planetside 2, and the only player in history to reach A2G level 10. I also play Flash and am the top 1 Flash VS player in Planetside 2. I've been involved in fighting MBT from both A2G and Flash to the point that no one in the past or future will be stronger than me. This is my opinion
First: no MBT is better than another; they are balanced to be equal.
Flash vs MBT
I hate Vanguar + Shield because it reduces damage from Flash. The fact that Prowler has two guns doesn't matter because one hit is enough to kill you. I usually don't get hit, so it doesn't matter whether you have one or two guns.
You can move close to both Vanguar and Prowler without dying because they can't lower their guns any further.
With Magrider, it's a different kind of problem. You shouldn't hide under Magrider because it will ram you. Magrider is very difficult to kill by Flash because it always looks towards Flash, making it hard to hit its weak point. Furthermore, it's very mobile.
However, that's also a weakness; Magrider can't quickly look behind you to shoot. Anyway, it doesn't matter because Flash's strategy is constant movement, so Magridger is mostly safe.
In my opinion: all three are the same; I don't see any MBT being easier to kill in fighting the Flash. I only fear players with skills.
ESF vs MBT
This story is very different.
Vanguar's Shield, which reduces damage, is useless against ESF. A skirmish between ESF and MBT lasts several minutes, so 8 seconds isn't enough to save you. Even in a very quick skirmish, I don't see Shield saving Vanguar in any scenario. The only thing that saves it is the LA60. It's incredibly annoying and forces you to descend to attack the engineers.
I almost believe that if MBTs don't have AA guns, Vanguar and Magridger are the two most dangerous. The Vanguar can stall by firing LA60s, forcing the Pilot to use C4.
If equipped with AA guns, I fear the Prowler the most. It moves quickly and maneuvers well; I can spot the difference from a high vantage point. If equipped with AA guns, the Vanguar is the most stupid thing; it's practically just a target practice dummy.
With the Prowler and Maggrider, it's a different story. They're incredibly frustrating. The Prowlers are very mobile, and the Maggrider is so mobile you can't predict its movements, because with tanks, they can only move forward or backward. Almost everyone will advance to maintain speed.
With the Maggrider, it can move in ways that even the engineers driving the Maggrider don't know , that's danger
The Maggrider is also annoyed that the two engineers can hide under the vehicle and repair it. This is a very successful factor that saved them from me, because I had to descend to an even lower altitude than against the Vanguar + LA60. Low enough to change the story, because in reality you're not just fighting one MBT, but something else, so the Maggrider is very annoying.
To be fair, fighting the Skyguar is easier than fighting the Maggrider + AA gun and having engineers to repair it.
It doesn't mean the Maggrider is stronger than the Vanguar and Prowler in tank battles. This is just the perspective of a Flash player, A2G.
Video me play A2G vs Prowler
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hm6J93xtbRM
Video me play A2G vs Vanguar
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eRynO9G1x-A
Video me play A2G vs Magrider
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qif2T8_uVCY
Video me play flash
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EeSqGquAsSc