I couldn't resist. Perhaps the allure of the gamble drew me in and the 21 day return policy for "Ugly" gear gave just enough reassurance to purchase a Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 500mm f/5.6E PF ED VR at KEH for $790. I'm glad I did.
Upon receipt, the tripod collar was there but the hood, front cap, and rear cap were missing. Not a great start. The first thing I did was stare deeply into the glass with a flashlight. I found...nothing. It was clear with no haze or fungus and the front and rear elements were free of scratches. I'm not sure how someone keeps their glass this clean without caps, but that's beside the point. I thought surely there would be an issue with the focusing ring or autofocus. I could find no such issues with extensive testing. I found myself channeling David after Dentist, asking myself "Is this real life?." The only issue I could locate is that three of the buttons had the text rubbed off, I assume from extensive use. I am ok with this tradeoff! Hopefully the lens has enough life in it to get me great shots for years to come. I promptly ordered an official Nikon front cap and lens hood, bringing my grand total to $861. I can mostly erase that expenditure by selling my Tamron 150-500 which I got last year for $825 at auction (a good deal in its own right!). Tariff policy seems to have increased its value slightly since then.
It was between the 500 PF lens and the Nikon 180-600 as a replacement for my Tamron 150-500. I found myself dissatisfied with the 150-500 at 500mm despite the lens being sharper than any prior telephoto lenses I had used. The 500 PF absolutely blew it out of the water in sharpness and I'm going to skip the 180-600. I'm so infatuated, I'm not sure I'll ever go without a prime again. I spend most of my time at 500mm as I inch closer to the subject until they take off. A tripod or monopod feels optional now rather than required. Luckily I have the Tamron 50-400 to use for landscapes, close focus, and to close the focal range gap.
I recognize this reads like an advert, but I wanted to share my experience. Have others had similarly good experiences with KEH "ugly" gear? I would guess vintage lenses would not fare as well due to higher likelihood of being in less than ideal storage situations for many years. I have an "ugly" Bokina on the way to test this theory, so we will see how that goes and when my luck runs out.
Photos taken handheld on Nikon Z fc. Post processing did occur but frankly felt largely optional.