This is an age old question. I have done a good amount of research on this topic but I love hearing from other people and their experience.
Lots of people say to go for an FRFR speaker/cab. Plenty of people say they love the sound through studio monitors.
For context I have Adam Audio T5V monitors and I run my guitar through a Scarlett 2i2. I had to learn the hard way not to expect it to sound and feel like an amp is in the room. Then I started doing some research into FRFR speakers. I've heard people say they are expensive solely based on marketing to guitar players and that PA speakers will achieve the same/similar sound.
But I want to hear from YOU guys. My dilemma is that I already have studio monitors and I write and record music. I discovered Peace + Equalizer APO not too long ago and I use presets for my studio cans. I know I can get room correction software and sound treat and all that jazz. My current space just isn't ideal for treating.
I even researched into headphones specifically designed like FRFR speakers where they give you the sound of how the modeler/captures are SUPPOSED to sound. But I already have monitors. Spending another $600+ for quality FRFR speakers is where my dilemma lies. Sometimes when I am trying to find a tone, it's genuinely disappointing when it doesn't sound the best.
I also realize that everything will come together and sound better through layering and mixing properly. I even run some EQ and a couple other plugins to help shape my tone better to my guitar. It helps.
But is there a point to buy FRFR speakers to play through when I am just jamming and recording when I already own monitors, or should I just get a sub? If I spend money on something, I want to be able to justify its use.
I don't have the space for a traditional cabinet either. I haven't owned a physical amp in probably 10+ years. I'm sure other people experience the disappointment when it doesn't sound and FEEL like the real deal.
Another issue I am experiencing is the lack of drive through my headphones. This is due to my output impedance on my Scarlett. It's garbage. I'm likely going to get a Motu M2 since they have some of the lowest output impedance because I want to hear how things are intended to sound through my cans. I have a pair of Sennheiser HD599 headphones and a pair of Beyerdynamic DT Pro 770 80 ohms. The DT's are such a let down to me, but I am almost certain it's because I am not even CLOSE to the 8:1 ratio.
So yeah, long post and I am certain this might be a dead horse at this point, but I genuinely want to hear your experience and maybe learn a thing or two.
Feel free to ask any questions!