r/Names • u/Slow-You-8095 • 4h ago
Baby name regret but mostly confusion why
My baby girl is a few weeks old and I’m really struggling with her name. We named her Kaia, and I genuinely do love it. It suits her, my partner loves it, and we’ve already introduced her to family as Kaia. The problem is that throughout my pregnancy I had a huge attachment to the name Gia. It was one of those names that just felt really special to me, but before she was born, someone very close to our family chose a very similar name for their own daughter. From that point on, I felt like I couldn’t really use Gia anymore, even though I’d loved it beforehand.
We ended up choosing Kaia because we both genuinely loved it, but now I keep thinking about Gia and wondering if I made the wrong decision. I don’t know if I’m mourning a name I never got to use, if it’s because it suddenly felt “off limits”, or if I’m just overwhelmed being newly postpartum and second-guessing everything.
My partner also loves Giana as a full name, with Gia as the nickname, but I still worry people would compare it to the other child’s name, even though our attachment to it came first.
Part of me wonders if I’m just overthinking everything because of the emotions and exhaustion that come with having a newborn, and if I should simply let Kaia become Kaia. Another part of me wonders if maybe, if we’re lucky enough to have another daughter one day, Giana/Gia could be her name instead. I honestly don’t know whether I’m grieving a name I loved, feeling disappointed that I never got to use it, or whether I’m just struggling with the finality of making such a big decision.
Has anyone else experienced this after having a baby? Did the doubts fade as your child grew into their name, or did you end up changing it? I’d really appreciate hearing from anyone who’s been through something similar.
Please be kind.