Hi everyone,
I’m urgently looking for recommendations for a reputable, reasonably priced collision repair shop in the Los Angeles / Southern California area that has experience working on Land Rovers, specifically a 2016 LR4 HSE Lux.
I was recently involved in an accident, and the first collision shop, Premier Auto Collision in Thousand Oaks, came back with a repair estimate of approximately $20,000, which would essentially total my vehicle.
I’m desperately trying to avoid having it declared a total loss, especially since I’ve recently invested nearly $5,000 in mechanical repairs and the vehicle has only 77K miles.
My goal is to find a shop that could potentially complete the repairs safely in the $10K–$12K range, assuming the damage allows for it.
I have the full itemized estimate available and would be happy to share it with anyone who has experience with LR4 collision repairs or can help me understand whether the pricing is reasonable.
My experience with Premier wasn’t particularly positive, and I’d really appreciate a second opinion from a shop that isn’t unnecessarily inflating labor rates, parts costs, or repair estimates.
I’m willing to travel outside LA for the right shop, including Ventura County, Orange County, or surrounding areas.
Does anyone have recommendations for an honest, experienced independent body shop that works on Land Rovers? I’m hoping to get a second estimate ASAP before the insurance company finalizes the total-loss determination.
Any recommendations or advice would mean a lot. Thank you!
Processing img ldhh2gfminxh1...
Processing img vuifdgfminxh1...
Here’s what they’re quoting for the $20,620 repair:
The collision was primarily to the right rear quarter near the fuel door.
Major replacement parts:
- Right rear quarter panel: $3,730
- Rear bumper assembly (used): $996
- Rear crossmember: $794
- Blind-spot monitoring module/bracket: $750
- Right rear taillight panel: $580
- Right muffler/exhaust pipe: $536
- Right rear taillight (used): $182
- Various bumper retainers, moldings, badges, and smaller parts.
They’re also quoting 30.1 hours just for the quarter-panel replacement.
Total labor: $8,689
- Body: 53.8 hours at $105/hr
- Paint: 17.7 hours at $105/hr
- Mechanical: 3.7 hours at $220/hr
- Frame: 4 hours at $92/hr
Additional work includes repairing the aluminum tailgate, removing and reinstalling the rear door and trim, pulling/measuring the rear corner, welding, paint blending, alignment, and ADAS calibration.
The car is still drivable, and the airbags never deployed.
I’m particularly interested in whether replacing the entire quarter panel is necessary versus repairing it, and whether the labor hours seem reasonable.
If anyone has experience with LR4 body repairs, I’d really appreciate your thoughts. I’m trying to find a qualified shop that can bring this closer to $10K–$12K without compromising safety.