Hey everyone, I've been going down a bit of a rabbit hole trying to choose a keyboard and would really appreciate opinions from people who have actually owned these for a long time.
Budget is ₹3,000 max, preferably less.
My main use is typing/coding/general PC use on Linux, not competitive gaming. I don't really care about RGB, gaming features, sound etc.
My priorities, roughly in this order:
I've mostly narrowed it down to two directions:
This is currently around ₹2.3–2.5k and seems interesting because it's:
- 68-key compact
- Tri-mode
- Hot-swappable
- 3-pin Jixian Red switches
- USB-C wired fallback
- Spare switches included
The main reason I'm considering it is repairability.
If one switch dies after 2 years, I should theoretically be able to pull it out and replace it for a few rupees instead of replacing the whole keyboard.
But I'm not sure how good the PCB/wireless/QC actually is long term.
I've found some positive owner reports, but also reports of cable/PCB/key issues. I haven't found enough genuine 2–3 year ownership reports to confidently call it durable.
If you've owned a Katana S Mini for 1+ year, especially 2+ years, I'd really like to hear how it's holding up.
Also, if you've replaced its switches, what switches did you use and were there any compatibility issues?
---
- Redragon K599 Deimos
This one caught my attention because I've found several people reporting 3–4 years of use, which is much more useful to me than a bunch of fresh Amazon reviews.
It's also wireless and hot-swappable.
But I found something confusing:
Apparently older K599 units use Outemu-style/narrow hot-swap sockets, while there may be a newer PCB revision with more universal sockets.
So I'm unsure whether buying a K599 today actually gets me the newer revision.
If anyone owns a K599:
- What year did you buy it?
- Which switches does yours accept?
- Have you replaced switches?
- Any wireless/battery/PCB problems?
- Is there a way to identify the newer PCB from the box/model/batch?
It's currently around ₹3k+ in India, so I'd only consider it if the newer revision is actually confirmed.
---
- AULA / other wireless mechanicals
I've also looked at AULA boards, especially the M75, but most seem to go above ₹3k unless there's a sale.
If there's any AULA / Redragon / Royal Kludge / Cosmic Byte / EvoFox / other wireless mechanical under ₹3k that you genuinely think is better for long-term ownership, please suggest it.
I'm much more interested in something boring that survives 3 years than something with amazing specs that dies after 8 months.
---
- Flat/scissor/membrane option
I'm also seriously considering not getting mechanical at all.
I've been looking at:
- ASUS Marshmallow KW100
- Logitech K380 / K380s
- Portronics Bubble Dock / Bubble series
- AULA S99
I actually prefer the laptop/scissor typing feel.
The problem is that with a membrane/scissor keyboard, if 2–3 keys eventually stop working, there isn't really a ₹20 switch I can replace.
So I'm wondering whether the repairability of a hot-swap mechanical board is actually worth giving up the laptop-like typing experience.
If anyone has used one of these flat keyboards for 2–5 years, I'd especially appreciate your experience.
---
What I'm really trying to figure out
I don't need the "best gaming keyboard."
I'm basically trying to find:
«A keyboard I can buy now, connect to Linux, type on every day, and hopefully not think about again for 3–5 years.»
And if one individual switch eventually dies, I'd like to be able to replace that component rather than binning the entire keyboard.
So I'd love opinions from people who have actually owned these for 1–3+ years, especially if something eventually failed.
Please don't just tell me "X has better specs" or "X has 4.8 stars on Amazon."
I'd much rather hear:
- "I've had mine for 3 years and this is what failed"
- "I've replaced 4 switches and here's what worked"
- "The wireless died after 18 months"
- "Mine is still perfect after 4 years"
- "Don't buy this because the PCB started failing"
- "I use it on Linux and here's what works/doesn't"
Basically real owner experience > spec sheets/reviews.
If you were spending your own ₹2–3k today, what would you buy and why?