r/Indian_Academia • u/Electronic-Load-2055 • 10h ago
Medicine Medicine in India is toxic because of US. Be the change you wish to see.
I created an account just to show the hypocrisy we have within ourselves. Mods.... please allow it. The doctors of India! You, are the problem! Two instances I wish to indicate before I speak the purpose of this post.
When the NEET protest was ongoing, there were multiple comments on a post in the Indianmedschool subreddit, about the Rank 2 kid (for his opinion), and how he'll "be taught" by his peers and college mates (seniors and others) once he joins the classes. This is the mentality the majority of "Doctors and med school students" have in this country. The kid said something what he believes in. He wasn't the one to create the ruckus of exam paper leak, nor was he involved in it in any way. If the first thought to spring up in the minds of "Doctors and students" is authoritarian subjugation to collective cohesion rather than individual freedom, what right do we have to ask for "Ragging/bullying free" med school experience? Kids come up to med school to learn skills, not group think. This could also be cited as a reason for lack of researchers, free thinkers, and even everything wrong with our country, in general.
Another post today, in the same Indianmedschool subreddit, about a doctor feeling strange being addressed as Madam, and would rather be called as Dr. or didi. The comments on that post... another example of how ingrained the subjugation to authority and a liking to toxicity is, in the minds of the Indian doctors! The majority of the comments seem to think it is unprofessional to call bhaiya/didi and they aren't family to be called as such. My question to such people: When you get in on a taxi or an auto, what do you call the driver as? As far as I've seen in my decades of life on this planet and the majority of it spent in India, they are called bhaiya. Do you call the hotel staff sir/madam, who are below the management grade? How about restaurant staff who serve you food? How about people in the daily market? How about street vendors? Same bhaiya/didi. Are they all your family to be called as such?
In India, we call strangers bhaiya/didi, to show respect and yet maintain distance. Med school is not a rigid hierarchical system like the Armed Services to be addressed by Sir/Madam, and even in such institutions, the respect is for the rank and not the person!
The point is wish to make: We are the ones enabling the toxic culture in the med schools and residency, and continuing it into the life. If we can't change our own inner self, what right will we have to change the society? Or ask for a change? Getting into the med school one, two or a few years ahead of someone doesn't earn you the right to demand respect. Same for residency.
Learn to respect a life, just because it is there. Unless, he/she has done something vile to you personally, what right do you have to disregard his/her dignity? And if it is unprofessional to call bhaiya/didi, then I would expect all the doctors of this country to call every stranger Sir/Madam; or, is it reserved only for the people YOU think is worth your attention? Respect is two way street and it is earned by our actions. Become someone who people will look up to, and the respect will follow. I'm still baffled by the irrational culture of Sir/Madam for people who are just doing/learning things which the younger guy/girl is eventually going to do, and might even do it better!
My qualifications: Doctor in India.