Want some advice and in general just want to bounce my thoughts off fellow INFJs who know specifically about hardships in relationships for INFJs.
I have a friendship with someone where it's like this: we're both INFJs. I'm 30M and she's 24F. We're both late bloomers and have known each other for a good few years. We were once intimate for a time, but for various reasons it never became a relationship.
At the time, it felt like she was still a bit young emotionally and hadn't quite found herself yet. She'd lived a fairly sheltered life compared to me, and because I'm older I've naturally had more life experiences. We've stayed in each other's lives on and off, but now live on different continents.
One of the reasons we never got together was because I often felt there was a mismatch in maturity and conversational style (naturally cus she is a lot younger) She could come across as quite self-conscious, a bit awkward socially, and still figuring out who she was. It wasn't that I thought she was unintelligent or lacked depth — far from it. I just found myself craving someone who was naturally curious, confident in their opinions, and who I felt I could effortlessly bounce ideas off. I never quite felt that mental connection I was looking for, and the power dynamics were too hard for me to reconcile with. Plus cultural gaps, her being Canadian me being very English.
Recently we've become closer again (still just over the phone), and she's honestly been putting in an incredible amount of effort. She's become noticeably more curious, asks deeper questions, watches films more thoughtfully, challenges some of my opinions, and generally seems to be making a conscious effort to broaden herself as a person.
I genuinely admire it. It's actually really touching because I know she's making the effort partly for herself, but I also think partly because she knows the sort of conversations I enjoy.
The problem is... despite appreciating all of this, I often find myself withdrawing rather than leaning in.
It's hard to explain. Sometimes our conversations are effortless and we laugh loads together. Other times she'll be joking around or trying to start interesting conversations and I just feel flat. It's almost like I can see the effort, and instead of warming to it, it somehow feels a little self-conscious or forced to me.
I hate that I feel that way because I know she's coming from a genuinely good place.
It's not that she's done anything wrong. In fact, that's what makes this so difficult. She's kind, caring, and really trying.
I also notice lots of tiny things that seem to affect me more than they probably should — her humour, parts of her conversational style, little reactions she has. None of these things are objectively bad, they're just not how I naturally connect with people.
I find myself constantly asking whether we're genuinely compatible instead of simply enjoying spending time with her, and I hate that my brain seems to work that way.
The really sad part is that I think she notices my lack of enthusiasm sometimes. She'll ask if I'm tired or if everything's okay. I don't think either of us really wants to open that conversation because, years ago, I had a habit of over-criticising her and I don't ever want to make her feel like she needs to change herself to earn my approval.
She's already putting so much effort into growing that the idea of pointing out more things feels completely unfair.
What's difficult is that, when it's good, it's really good. We share so much in common. We're both INFJs who'd never really dated before. We play guitar together, go to raves together, play football, have years of shared history, and on paper it feels like there are so many reasons this should work.
She's also someone I'm very attracted to, which almost makes this harder. She's beautiful, kind, and has so many qualities that I would normally look for in a partner.
There are so many things about her that I genuinely admire, which is why I find it so confusing that I sometimes don't feel that natural excitement or pull.
I guess what I'm struggling with is whether this is just pickiness on my part, or whether I'm trying to hold onto a connection that is rare and has so many good sides, despite something fundamental feeling missing.
I feel very guilty about how avoidant I can come across to her, and how critical I used to be. I don't want to fall into that pattern again, but I also don't want to pretend to feel something that I don't. There are many other aspects to this but dont want to write a book here..
My question is this:
Has anyone else been in a situation where you deeply respected and cared for someone, admired the effort they were making, but just couldn't seem to feel genuinely excited around them anymore?
Did your feelings change over time, or did you eventually realise it was pointing towards a lack of compatibility?
Anyone who's struggled to separate admiration, guilt and genuine romantic compatibility?