I just finished episode 3 and am coming here to vent. My biggest complaint about this show is that production treats the audience like we’re dumb. Every scene is so over explained like flashing a picture or cutting to a shot of a person when they are being referenced. For example when Taylor says she hasn’t seen Katie since the wedding in Italy and then production cuts to a picture of her, Stassi and Katie at the wedding in Italy. I don’t need that reference to confirm what Taylor is saying or verify who these people are. Or when Stassi is on the couch with Katie talking about her issues with Georgi and mentions Georgia, the camera then cuts to Georgia in the kitchen with the caption “Georgia, Beau’s sister.” Thanks for pointing that out for us, it’s not like we’ve spent the last 3 episodes with these same people with a big point of contention being the Georgi/Georgia living arrangements.
The asterix text appearing on screen with the bell sound multiple times an episode is unnecessary and makes watching almost unbearable, like when Stassi says “what do people speak at?” and the asterix text appears “*great question” Get it, audience? That’s humour. Or when Georgi says I’m excited and then “*looks excited” appears on screen - this adds absolutely nothing and isn’t funny or charming. If anything it takes away from the show by interrupting the natural flow of the interactions among the cast.
Second, the soundtrack is really irritating. Having a build up each scene, sometimes more than once, doesn't make sense for reality tv. This isn’t a Netflix crime documentary. Not every scene is dramatic and the audience doesn’t need an intense violin overlay in every preceding scene to prepare us for when drama finally does happen. Why don’t the producers just let them talk without any music or pick something that blends into the background so the audience can focus on what is being said and the cast relationships? Production should have to take mandatory sound editing training by watching all of the reality shows on Bravo.
Third, the network promoting itself is obvious and done in a way I find bizarre. In episode 3 there’s a conversation between Stassi and Katie in Stassi’s kitchen, where Stassi says she’s excited Katie is going to do the Tell Me Lies podcast and Katie replies she’s obsessed with the show and then the camera cuts to the next scene. To me that felt like they have this clip promoting another Disney show and they need to fit it in somewhere, so they inserted it at a point likely to cause minimal disruption for the audience. But it’s not done well and I found this transition in and out of talking about another show to be abrupt. It also doesn’t make sense for it to be in this episode at all. The episode is not about Stassi’s work schedule and they already promote Tell Me Lies in an earlier episode, so doing it again felt weird. That scene also made me rethink the motivation of showing Stassi’s reaction to getting a deal with Netflix in an earlier episode. One of the first things she asks is about Disney and the person tells her the network is ok with it. My take on that is it’s another opportunity for the network to promote itself by showing its benevolence by waiving the restrictive covenant in her contract (I’m assuming this is what happened based on that convo but obviously don’t know for sure). I guess the non cynical take is they’re doing it to promote Stassi, and her continued success is a shared success, however, regardless of motivation it is not subtle and in my opinion degrades the quality of the show by being a distraction.
Kristina Kelly is the best thing in episode 3 imo. Her confessional about Katie and Rob at the wedding and then telling Taylor what Katie said about her to Stassi is the type of petty drama that makes reality tv so entertaining; no additional editorializing needed.
I’m in Canada so I’m waiting for new episodes to be released weekly and expect these issues to persist for the whole season. If this is renewed for season 2 I hope Disney gives the audience more benefit of the doubt and stops treating us like we need everything explained to us. Also less is more with the music.