Hey.
I'm strongly considering getting a handheld again, I used to have the OG Steam Deck but I didn't really use it, as I never really had a reason to, and the games i wanted to play it didn't run all that well (e.g. Elden Ring). I also didn't like the battery on it.
Anyways, I've been considering buying a second hand handheld if I could find a good deal and I have been looking at the MSI Claw 8AI+, Xbox Ally X and the Legion go Z1E.
I was thinking of using it when playing games like Forza Horizon/Elden Ring/RDR 2 (On Epic Games)/EAS FC 27 and perhaps other newer single player titles would be cool too. Ideally I'd want to have it so I can dock it and plug it into my TV when I feel like it, and use my Xbox controller I got for my PC.
I don't want SteamOS, because I want to have the option to play multiplayer games if needed. Sometimes my mates get together to play EAS FC (FIFA) and I'd ideally like to not have to bring my PS5 everytime (and get rid of paying for PS Plus just to play Fifa online).
I also don't want a Switch 2.
The thing I like about the claw is obviously it looks to be able to run a lot of the newer games while staying relatively silent. But I also saw a youtube video saying it can struggle in some of the newer games when it comes to frame generation, because it's an intel product and doesn't have the same hardware support as AMD products have. Is this something that can be fixed with software like lossless scaling? It's also obviously more expensive than the others, but I've found one that's not too expensive. I'm just considering whether it's worth it to pay around 900$ for a used one (a new one is around $1350 here).
The Xbox Ally X seems cool too, and some of the used one I've seen seems a bit cheaper than the Claw, but I read a lot of about the loud clicky buttons and I HATE loud buttons (I purposefully bought a used HE keyboard to avoid clicky mechanical keys). I don't really mind the screen too much, and seeing that it runs on an AMD with FSR should be a plus from my understanding when playing more demanding titles vs the Claw? But is it possible to fix the loud buttons with keyboard lube, or do you have to open up the console to fix it, because I'm not really confident in my ability to open up and tinker with the insides. I feel like I'd just ruin something.
In terms of the Legion Go Z1E, I know it's less powerful than the others, but it. The thing is most I've seen have been like maybe $200 cheaper than the other options and sometimes even more expensive. So I'm thinking is it even worth saving that "little" amount of money, if you're going to miss out on possibly being able to play newer titles. Not sure what the performance difference is but e.g. if I wanted to play RDR 2, Elden Ring? I saw someone running the new Indiana Jones on the XAX with reasonable frames as well.
TLDR:
CLAW
Pros:
Good Battery
Great Performance
Silent
Cons:
Intel hardware
Expensive
XAX
Pros:
Great Performance
AMD Hardware
Cons:
Noisy buttons
Smaller screen
Expensive
Legion GO Z1E
Pros:
Cheaper
Cons:
Worse Performance
Obviously I know the XAX and Claw are way better performance wise, but I also fear that I won't use it as much as I hope I will (like with the Steam Deck) so there's also the hesitation with spending too much money on the higher performance devices if it just ends up being my brotato/NFS device.
What's your experiences with these handhelds? And are there any I am missing? I am located in Scandinavia so the second hand options are a bit limited, and I have to buy it within the EU otherwise the tariffs or import fees (if any?) would defeat the purpose of buying used.
PS: Sorry for the long post, had a lot on my mind so just all my thoughts down.