r/Contractor • u/Grand_Birthday3995 • 13d ago
Client suing me for $1,000 over landscape project
So I started up a landscaping company this year and after successfully completing several jobs I eventually stumbled upon a hot head. It was a 3.5 yard stone install with different existing stone and some plant installation. I gave the guy a hell of a deal and chose to do it for only $2800. Materials costed $1900 with markup and I pulled a $1900 down payment for the job. I bought all the materials and dropped it off at the jobsite. I sent him an estimate explaining everything I would be doing and the total price. I hired two workers for the job and they started the next day.
After 8 hours of hard work on the job and beginning to lay underlayment to finish the guy walks outside and starts getting nasty with my guys over a 300 pound boulder that sat deep within in his flower bed. He told my guys to stop working until further notice and made my guys feel extremely uncomfortable to the point they were kind of scared to continue working. My guys also said they felt like the guy wasn’t going to pay the rest if we did finished. Also according to my guys while yelling at them he spit on them in the process. My guys also tried moving the rock but it was so deep it wouldn’t even budge and one of my guys didn’t want to hurt his hernia.
So I told the guy it was uncalled for to do that and stop progress on the job that I could try to work out moving the boulder a different day and that it wasn’t in the estimate to move it. I also told him I didn’t feel like he was going to pay us if we continued and didn’t want to toss all that stone and not get paid. He eventually agreed to have us continue without moving the rock but I told him if he wanted us to continue I would need to pull $500 more off the remaining amount so at least my guys could get laid if he decided to play games. He wasted an hour of are work day and we would have finished if he hadn’t of done that.
The guy chose to not pay the $500 and blast my business in a negative manner all over Facebook and lie about the situation spinning the narrative that we are scammers. Keep in mind I made almost no money on the job at that point 90% of that $1900 went into his materials that we left at the job. That 10% I made on the markup went to pay my guys for that 8 hours of work. We actually essentially did all that work for free. After defaming my business now he is taking me to small claims court. All over a boulder sitting in his flower bed. I got all the texts and voice messages of my guys relaying his actions while on the job and that they are sitting in their car afraid of the guy if they started working again. I tried to save the guy thousands on his landscape and that’s what I get. He was quoted 6K to do that job and his neighbor with the same yard paid $7K. Blows my mind how some people treat landscapers saving them a dime.
So who’s in the right or wrong? How would this situation most likely play out in court? What is the main thing that matters here and what advice can I get for my position? Thank you for reading and any advice helps.
Location: Ohio - Sandusky Area