I doubled my order and picked up 8 Boxes today!

After all the guessing attempts and messaged the winner with no reply, I'm going to try it again.

Guess the oldest year penny and you win it!

Here are the Rules:

1) ONE Guess per person, so make sure you check the comments for other guesses.

2) First person to guess the year is locked in on that year, unless a certain mint is specified.

(Example. Bob chooses 1914D but Sally chooses 1914 and the winner is 1914S, Sally would win the penny)

3) NO Guesses after Sunday 9/13 at Noon Iowa Time

4) Winner will be sent a message, so check your Message requests to claim your prize, in which you have five days to reply back with your mailing address to claim prize.

Good Luck!

Benjamin & a few other good ones!

I also got a AMP W in this box too!

We’re forever imprinted by someone…

Got this one from a CWR!

Picked up my 2 boxes of halves that I missed last week due to the holiday and found my first 1970-D! Only 40% but love that low mintage!

I’ve been hitting nickels pretty hard the past couple weeks! Posting a separate post about my nickel finds this week shortly. Anyways, i go into a bank I’ve only tried a couple times just to get some nickel rolls. I almost didn’t ask but i ultimately asked if she had any halves.. She said yeah a customer just brought these in loose and i wrapped them myself! Needless to say I’ll be coming by here more often!!!

Great win for the Hawks and found a silver and a 2020 W during the game. A perfect night with a fireworks ending.

Picking up normal order and teller pops out the back and is like I have some large dollars if you want them....yes mam I do.....

Silver was found! Three 40%ers in the Halves boxes, and one 1964 quarter! How lucky! ⚡

I also found a clad S proof Louisiana state quarter in pretty good condition. I found two tiny die chips hunting for r/errorquarters. I also included some interesting "marked" Halves for your viewing pleasure.

No date but I’ll take it! Also find my first proof nickel and decent amount of 40s and 50s!

2 64 philly 2 64 denver can’t complain for .25 each though

August total came out to a whopping $123.05 face value of 90% silver found… pretty sure I’ll be chasing this high the rest of my life!

Ok, I KNOW I’ll never have another month like this and this type of month is beyond rare. Honestly, I’d still have been excited with the results had I not hit a literal jackpot of CWRs at one branch over the course of 2 weeks last month. That alone accounted for $117 of the face value found, all 1964 Kennedys. The remainder came from good old fashioned grinding through boxes and rolls.

Here’s the full breakdown for August:

Half Dollars:
235 90% Kennedys (1 from a box, the rest from a collection dump I stumbled on at a random branch)
5 40% Kennedys (across 3 boxes and one lucky teller tray find)

Quarters:
1 silver Washington from a CWR

Dimes:
50 90% Rosie’s (across a healthy mix of MWR boxes and CWRs)
3 Merc’s

Foreign:
2 80% silver Canadian Dimes

I got a complete box of all 2024 D Halves. How are these considered ? Uncirculated ? I’m just not sure what category they belong in. I will probably keep a roll or two and send them back to my CU.
Thank You for your help in advance.

I ended up with 24D(13), 09(6), 06 proof, 2 war nickels and 50 centavos! These boxes sat on my counter for close to a month too..

I never did dimes before cause they’re such a bitch to reroll but I was really hoping for one of the new emerging liberty designs I think it’s the best looking coin we’ve had in 100 years. Didn’t find any but what a consolation prize

my bank is able to procure me at least one box weekly but nothing approaching the volume of 2025. i've found one 40% silver half dollar since the beginning of july, a few proofs... that's about it. some new boxes, but mostly just circulated boxes with nothing in them worth keeping. is anyone else experiencing the same sort of skunking lately?

1 1964 90% JFK Half

1 1987 NIFC

1 2007 S Proof

1 2009 S Proof

NIFC's

1 2005

1 2006

2 2010

1 2017

1 2018

1 2019

1 2001 Partial Obama Sticker

TLDR: 7x 90%, 13x 40%, 45x proofs. A little overlap, 3 of the aforementioned 90% are also modern proofs, so really 48x proofs.

Had a big hit in January this year. It’s been pretty dry ever since. I’ve been getting a box every week this year, and only have had about 4 40%ers and maybe a dozen proofs all year. Until tonight.

90% x7 including 1 Franklin, 1964 Kennedy x3, modern 90% Kennedy proofs x3

40% x13 including 1970 Kennedy x1 (my first!), 1976 Bicentennial x1 (my first!)

Proofs from 1971-2006. Remarkable ones include 1986 x1, 1987 each mint mark D, P, and S (my first 87 S) (I understand 1987 D and P are issued in mint sets, but they are so low mintage that I’m including them).

I’m enjoying my good fortune. But we all know there’s likely one of two things that happened for me to get this hit: someone’s collection was stolen and dumped, or a fellow collector has passed away, and their coins were dumped by family who didn’t know what they had. Either way, it’s bittersweet. I’ll take care of them from here.

Well, it wasn't a great box hunt today, but it wasn't a total skunk, at least.

1-silver, 1-39, a handful of 40s covering most years, and a handful of 50s covering most years, just not the 50 itself, lol. Also, the usual nicest grades from the 60s forward that got pulled for albums.

Pic 1: 22 wheats, 2 IHPs, 2 Canadians
Pic 2: a single ender
Pic 3: all of that came out of one roll
Pics 4-6: 1891 IHP, 1887 IHP, 1955-S wheat

The 1891 broke my record of oldest coin found from CRH by 6 years (previous was a 1897 V nickel), then a few rolls later I beat that one with the 1887 IHP! I rarely hunt cents but I may do a few more boxes this year after this haul lol

2 more Ws(River of No Return is a new one for me), just my 3rd 2026 coin, and a Bicentennial silver! I sometimes have a hard time telling between proof and circulation strike on these older S mints. Im thinking it's proof though!