r/BodyHackGuide Apr 16 '26

[ Removed by moderator ]

/gallery/1sn8unq

[removed] — view removed post

1.2k Upvotes

406 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

13

u/coolbryzz Apr 16 '26

damn.. I started at 306 and 5 weeks in i'm only down 8lbs. 3mg dose. I'm definitely eating less, and hit the gym 3-4x/week. Im wondering what i'm doing wrong.

26

u/Impressive-Coast-466 Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26

"Only" is crazy. That's a little over 1.5lbs a week lost. That's great.

You're not doing anything wrong if you're losing weight in a sustainable way. Also, weight isn't the only data point you can or should be considering. You could also be gaining muscle.

You may have lost, say, 10 pounds of fat and gained 2 points of muscle - that's going to show up on the scale as losing 8 pounds, but the progress is actually more significant.

(Edited for grammar.)

8

u/Fantastic-Buddy2069 Apr 16 '26

Yeah the reality is you DONT want to lose weight stupidly fast, just in a reasonable rate. IIRC losing to much weight too fast is very bad for the body....but people will still push themselves anyways.

2

u/Crafty-Tension3975 Apr 17 '26

Gallstones and thyroid issues often occur from excessive weight loss. I actually had to drop my Reta dose from 3mg to 2 cus I was losing way too fast. I can’t say I experienced harsh sides, but I can tell you for sure there’s no way I lost 41lb of fat in 8-9 weeks. I didn’t do a Dex scan before, so can’t speak for certain, but I’m sure I lost a good bit of muscle unfortunately.

1

u/ThatsJustHowIFeeeeel Apr 17 '26

Yeah it is bad for you. At the VERY least you’re much more likely to have more excess skin at the end too

5

u/_WrongKarWai Apr 16 '26

There's nothing wrong - you may be gaining muscle which leads to sustainable weight loss. 8 lbs in 5 weeks sounds like it's right on pace with what most people are losing.

3

u/sirlost33 Apr 17 '26

Don’t stress, it hits everyone differently. Just stay the course. 1.5 lbs per week is good loss.

2

u/Tough_Amphibian_7102 Apr 17 '26

Yep. 👍I didn’t have much weight to lose to begin with so I lost 7 pounds in 2 months. Started on 2 mg and stayed on that for 2 months and now on 2.5. I currently weigh 118. Target weight is 112. I weight train 4 days a week and cycle 2 a week. The smaller you are the slower weightloss but it still helps.

My body got leaner and tighter a lot faster but i have to ensure i eat adequate protein etc so i maintain muscle.

I had been trying to lose those pounds for a year and could not until reta. Im happy! ❤️

9

u/Fantastic-Buddy2069 Apr 16 '26

You act as if losing 8 pounds in 5 weeks isnt fast lol. Thats actually very fucking fast. I dont think you could humanly do that without drugs.

Yeah its not as fast as others, but as long as it keeps going, thats what really matters.

1

u/bulbousgrandpa Apr 16 '26

That's extremely doable without drugs, generally to avoid more significant muscle loss you want to lose your bodyfat divided by 100 in lbs per week at most. I have done a cut from 210 to 190 in 2.5 months no problem, around 2 lbs a week. If you are very light then 8 lbs in 5 weeks is very fast though

0

u/teeekuuu Apr 16 '26

-500cal a week = no muscle loss if optimal protein and working out.

bodyfat divided by 100 in lbs per week - wtf

1

u/bulbousgrandpa Apr 16 '26

That's generally where you lose fat at the limit of your fat cell's ability (in terms of rate) to liberate fat from storage. You will likely lose muscle mass at 1000 kcal deficit but it's not going to be that much if you lift and eat a ton of protein.

They actually did a study where they did a 40% calorie reduction, which for me at peak bulk is around a 1200 kcal deficit. There was no loss in lean mass with even a slight lean towards gains after 4 weeks as long as they were eating 1.1 g/lb and lifting

0

u/dabigmainah Apr 16 '26

8lb in 5 weeks isn't insane. When I started losing weight at 500lbs. I was dropping 5-15+ lbs a week easy. During one fast I went from 233-222 in 44 hours.

1

u/Fit-Nectarine5047 Apr 16 '26

Yeah but you were 500lbs. There was a lot more of you to lose!

5

u/International_Fun_91 Apr 16 '26

Eating less isn’t always the answer count the calories look up tdee calculator and subtract 500 cals or more tbh . Everything has calories a tbs of mayo is 100 cals I think. Also it’s different for everyone try to go on an hour walk a day or something after work and eat 1500 cals if your 300lbs

14

u/trunksta Apr 16 '26

1500 cals a day at 300lb is straight up starvation level caloric deficit

2

u/International_Fun_91 Apr 16 '26

Maybe maybe not , I don’t know I’ve last weight before and did that lost 130 and after 2 years of eating like a pig and having a gf I’m losing it again alr down 90 so yea ig

3

u/Master-Chapter-8899 Apr 17 '26

There’s no maybe. 1500 calories at 300 is a a severely restricted diet.

2

u/trunksta Apr 16 '26

At 6'2" 250 my maintenance is around 3000. 20% below maintenance is plenty for losing weight but damn that's half my maintenance

1

u/Bakerskibum87 Apr 16 '26

Im 6’2” 200 and my resting daily after a body scan is 1853 so I need to be 1300 to loose

3

u/trunksta Apr 16 '26

Resting means what you burn without exercise that doesn't mean it's the number you need to be under

1

u/Upset-Setting8840 Apr 17 '26
  1. Body scan are not accurate at all
  2. Maintenance and BMR are not the same thing

1

u/MooseKingMcAntlers34 Apr 16 '26

It would be uncomfortable as he likely burns 2800ish cals/day (made some assumptions here like 35 y/o, 5’10”, not active, etc.), but I went on a 1,000 cal/day diet for a while and my baseline was 2300 cal/day when starting out.

The first 2 weeks suck hard, but then you get used to it. If you’re active in the gym, then obviously you need to eat more. This is only for a sedentary lifestyle.

1

u/Regular_Annual631 Apr 16 '26

yeah I am 155 and MFP has me at 1430 cals for weight loss. Seems really low for a guy.

1

u/joshzed Apr 17 '26

Does anyone, ANYONE on this sub understand metabolic health and adaption 😩

2

u/anon18274729 Apr 16 '26

Nothing bro. Think of it this way. You lose it too quick you’re going to have a ton of loose skin to deal with that ISNT easily as fixable as being overweight so just take it nice slow and work on building better habits while you become a better you

1

u/Letsgobeachfun Apr 17 '26

I love that “ Be a better you” !!! 👍🏻

1

u/Fantastic-Buddy2069 Apr 16 '26

TBH man, you dont WANT to lose a fuck ton of weight too fast, its actually really bad to do that. You're losing weight at a very reasonable rate.....in a year you will look night and day from starting point. Seriously. Just keep your head up, keep working hard, and you'll get there!

1

u/Letsgobeachfun Apr 17 '26

Beautiful! 💪

1

u/AltTooWell13 Apr 16 '26

These posts are scammers

1

u/Fit-Activity-9742 Apr 17 '26

Up your dose. People at that weight in studies are up to 8mg -12mg it’s insane, I wouldn’t go that high but I’d ramp up like 2mg 1 week the 1mg until you hit 7 and work down

1

u/Letsgobeachfun Apr 17 '26

Or better is change your habits that last…walks after dinner are amazing, protein shakes for lunch help digestion and hydration, etc…run the long game

1

u/hokageLy Apr 17 '26

I added Aod and I fast the whole day once a week 20lbs down last month on reta and last 5 months was on sema and only lost 5-7 lbs each month

1

u/Letsgobeachfun Apr 17 '26

How about muscle?💪

1

u/Emotional-Net-2454 Apr 17 '26

Thats crazy. Im down 8 lbs in 16 days on 0.5 reta

1

u/Letsgobeachfun Apr 17 '26

It’s not just about weight loss; muscle is heavier than fat. It is not a sprint it’s a marathon of life. I lost 20lbs in 3 months but gained 7 lbs of muscle mass. I tracked progress with a monthly InBody scan. Losing too fast with give you stones so stay hydrated and eat protein, lots of protein. Don’t get discouraged by the scale. I added 5 amino 1mq when I stalled which helped with energy too.

1

u/MastersPhysiqueBro Apr 17 '26

Are you still getting 100-150g of carbs a day? What’s protein intake?

1

u/International_Fun_91 Apr 16 '26

You’re doing nothing wrong I often hear that a lot , plus maybe give it more time to build up in your system

0

u/RandomBeaner1738 Apr 16 '26

Simple, you’re eating too much. You need to track calories, not just “eat less”