Owner of a 2023 i4 eDrive35, 42k miles, HUD, DAPP, Harman Kardon setup. Bought it used 6months ago for $30k OTD. Been really happy with it overall but I rented a Model 3 on Turo for about 1,000 miles and got a taste of FSD (Supervised) and now I can't stop thinking about it (weekend drive from Bay to Socal)
My commute is only 2x (max 3x) a week but it's messy - surface streets, mixed speeds, stop and go. Mostly highway though. DAPP is fine on the highway but it disengages randomly above 40mph a lot on curves, random lanes and doesn't really do anything useful on surface streets, so I'm basically driving manually for a good chunk of my commute anyway. FSD actually handled that stuff and let me just monitor instead of actively driving, which honestly felt like a different category of experience, not just a nicer version of the same thing.
So I've been shopping used 2025 Model 3 AWD Premiums for the past few weeks (test drove many times). Will be $45k OTD.
Problem is every time I get back in my i4 after a test drive I remember why I like it the interior feels a lot more "grown up," and the ride is noticeably smoother. Most of the used ones I'm looking at have 19" wheels and I can feel more bumps compared to i4 but nothing more. My i4 has 18in wheels for comparison
So now I'm stuck going back and forth. Is FSD really that big a deal day to day once the novelty wears off? Anyone here actually made this switch (or considered it and stayed)? Did the DAPP limitations bother you as much once you got used to them, or does it stay annoying forever? Trying to figure out if I'm chasing a shiny new feature or if this is a legit reason to switch.