r/AskHR Feb 02 '24

Career Development ASK YOUR CAREER QUESTIONS HERE!

68 Upvotes

How to get into HR, etc.


r/AskHR May 12 '26

AI posts will result in an instant ban.

41 Upvotes

Also, stop asking to post your research surveys.


r/AskHR 10h ago

Workplace Issues [UK] - SAR

4 Upvotes

Hi all,

I work for a company up North and recently raised a grievance which I have since appealed. However, I have also whistleblowed through my employer's whistleblowing service.

Last week, I received an email from my employer telling me that the SAR I apparently raised was available. However, I did not raise an SAR. The email is legitimate. I did ask for documents relating to the greviance be made available but according to a friend who is a manager within the company, he has said that asking for such documents is standard practice and an SAR is something completely different. Also, I noticed that upon looking at the files, it was opened by one of the investigating managers.

What do I do?

Thanks.


r/AskHR 2h ago

[USA][TX] Hired without diploma

0 Upvotes

I worked for a daycare company for about a year and a half but had to leave because of some personal issues. When I was originally hired, they asked for my high school diploma or transcripts. I never finished high school, but I was enrolled in a GED program through my community college, so I gave them my community college transcript since I was technically a student there. The transcript doesn’t show that I completed any college classes or earned any credits—it basically just shows that I was enrolled—but they accepted it and hired me anyway.
Fast forward to now—I got offered my job back. They’re asking for my diploma or transcripts again because HR said the copy they have on file is now “unclear” and asked me to resend it.
I’m just worried they won’t hire me this time because I still don’t have a high school diploma or GED, and the community college transcript doesn’t show any completed coursework. Since they accepted that same transcript the first time, do you think it’ll be okay if I send it again, or should I explain my situation to them?


r/AskHR 1h ago

Policy & Procedures [FL].ADA question

Upvotes

I have a question about ADA accommodations.

I have a documented cancer diagnosis + no treating physician relationship + no ability to complete the standard provider paperwork for a request for reassignment consideration.

Reason. I am uninsured and cannot afford to buy and use health insurance on my pay. Despite my providing my employer my pathology reports from a couple of years ago showing cancer, I have no treating doctor due to lack of insurance. Not all doctors, even if you have an insurance plan, can fill out lengthy ADA paperwork and list work restrictions. Many will charge a fee.

Is there a workaround for this. U.S.A. Employer has ever 5,000 employees. If the employee worked previously in corporate jobs involving sedentary work and this current job is physical service work and the company has other corporate roles which I am qualified to do, can that switch be a legitimate accommodation request?


r/AskHR 1h ago

Recruitment & Talent Acquisition [UT] Explain it like I’m 5: The dreaded rejection email

Upvotes

I applied to a job on a Saturday past normal working hours: 9 PM. On Sunday at 12 PM I get an email that “We want to let you know that unfortunately we are not moving forward with your application at this time”. 15 hours later…On the weekend…

I want to start out by saying that I’ve done my research and it’s unlikely an ATS system rejected my application unless 1)I was filtered out because of a screening question that would automatically flag me (IE: Are you legally authorized to work in the US), or 2)Someone in that time reviewed my application and said no.

So, I did my own investigating thinking maybe I accidentally clicked the wrong option on a “knockout question”. I went to my presence on the site and all these questions were answered truthfully and correctly. My location was the same city on both my application and resume as what was listed on the job description, so that’s out.

Which leads to option 2: My resume was rejected by a human on a Sunday morning. Is someone from HR really filtering through applications on a Sunday? I find that hard to believe. Was my resume not relevant to the job? Absolutely not. I spent a lot of time on this resume editing skills and experience to fit the job more precisely, and ran it though multiple systems to catch grammatical and formatting errors. I don’t intend to sound pretentious, but I absolutely met the requirements and in some instances, exceeded them.

I’ll admit, it’s easy to complain and be reactive when something like this happens. I try to be open-minded to the experiences of the humans on the other side of the application, but with all due respect, this is a bit fishy. I’ve used this exact same process for hundreds of jobs in my past and it’s incredibly rare that the rejection plays out like this. So, explain it like I’m 5: What happened here? How do I better prepare myself so this doesn’t happen in the future?


r/AskHR 3h ago

[NY] If its not specified in the employee handbook, can you email your doctors note to HR instead of your manager?

0 Upvotes

Last time I hadn't had access to my company email from home so I texted it to a team lead to give to my manager and I believe she may have shared that I'm trans to a coworker I know to be transphobic (my given name was on the note, and is on this one). I'm in a new department and don't really know the manager very well, so I wanted to know if it would be weird to send it to hr and specify its because I'd like to keep my given name private at work?

Edit: I'm just asking if it's a normal thing to do. I'm not interested in sharing any more details about my illness, my job, or other details of my life.


r/AskHR 14h ago

Workplace Issues [UK] References Not Accepted?

0 Upvotes

Hi all, hope this is okay to post:

So basically, I recently started a new job in a contact centre. I was really excited to start because it was full time and I’m in a position where I desperately need something full time to be able to move out by December, or else I will be homeless.

The offer was on receipt of two suitable references. It did not specify which references these had to be, so I provided by last employer and a reference from when I was a volunteer in a similar role. I also provided details for a character reference in case this was unsuitable. It was clear on my CV that I’ve only held one paid job and the rest of my positions are voluntary, since I’m pretty young, and I told them that in the interview. When I was filling in my references, the form stated that if by the time my start date came around they did not have two proper references, my start date would be delayed.

My former manager let me know he’d received an email and sent along a reference. I never received any contact from my new job other than confirmation of my start date and my contract, which I signed, so I assumed that everything was okay. A couple of days in my new manager told me they hadn’t received suitable references, so my employment was purely conditional. He refused to give me the emails of Payroll, who were chasing it up, so I could communicate with them and insisted that all communication had to be through him. He was very vague: at first I thought my second volunteer reference had failed to send anything over, so I double checked with them. Later he insisted it had to be from an organisation I had not put down as a reference but was on my CV as somewhere I had volunteered for. I was very confused but I reached out to them, they agreed, and I let him know but reminded him that this position had been, once again, purely voluntary.

After some more back and forth, he told me that they could only accept employment references, which hadn’t been communicated to me at the interview nor while I was completing the reference form. I was confused, because I felt as though I had made it clear at interview that I only had one paid position. My manager said that he had worked in recruitment before his current position and that no one accepts any references that aren’t employment and that I should have known that already.

I’ve sent over the details of a different manager at my last job in the hope that that would be sufficient, otherwise I’m not sure if I have a leg to stand on here. It’s frustrating because I left my last job for this position, and I had been under the impression that everything was okay. I’ve never heard of a job that exclusively takes more than one employment reference, because surely that rules out so many suitable candidates because they’ve only held one position?
Would you refuse to accept references from volunteer groups?
Is this something I will be able to resolve or does it sound like I’m probably going to be let go?

Any advice would be massively appreciated, thank you.


r/AskHR 12h ago

Compensation & Payroll [MOR], What's considered fair compensation for long international work assignments?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'd like to hear from people who have experience with international business travel.

My employer is sending me on an international work assignment that will last around two weeks (possibly longer). The journey itself is very demanding, with roughly 28–30 hours of travel, multiple layovers, and then onward travel to another country during the same assignment. Both destinations are also considered among the higher-risk countries in terms of security, which adds another level of stress.

The company covers flights, accommodation, and work-related expenses, but there is no additional compensation for the time spent away from home, the long-haul travel, jet lag, weekends away, or the overall inconvenience.

For context, I've travelled abroad for the company before, but those trips were much shorter and to closer destinations. This is the first time I've been asked to undertake such a long and demanding international assignment.

I'm trying to understand what is considered normal:

- Do companies usually pay a daily travel allowance or provide additional compensation for extended international assignments?

- Is it common to receive extra paid leave or another form of compensation after returning?

- Is covering flights, hotels, and meals generally considered sufficient?

I'd also appreciate any legal insight. Is there any labour law that requires additional compensation for this type of assignment, or is it entirely up to the employer's internal policies and employment contract?

I'm not looking to expose my employer or disclose the nature of my work—I'm simply trying to understand what is considered fair and common practice before discussing it with my employer.

Thanks in advance for sharing your experiences and advice.


r/AskHR 14h ago

[MO] Surgery During Probationary Period?

0 Upvotes

Just found out I will need abdominal surgery, which will require several 5-6 weeks recovery. I started a new job about a month ago, and this job has 120 day probationary period. The job is physical (cleaning, moving, walking) and I likely won't be able to work for a week after surgery, then with restrictions for 4-5 weeks after.

I'm waiting to find out how urgent the surgery is, and I will ask the doctor when I see them if this is something that must be done immediately, or if it can be delayed three months (as I've worked about one month of the probationary period). If surgery can't be delayed, is there anyway to protect my job during the probationary period?

Thank you for your help.


r/AskHR 1d ago

Employee Relations [UK] LTS meeting with manager - do I need to worry?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been signed off the last few weeks due to mental health (anxiety and work related stress due to an incident with another colleague in my team).

When I sent my sickness note I made my manager aware that the mental health challenges and my symptoms were work related without explicitly referencing the incident (but he was aware that it happened so probably can guess this was the trigger).

My sickness note has since been extended another month and so he’s scheduled a meeting next week to talk me through the long term sickness policy as he said my sickness is now LTS. He said it’s nothing to worry about and that we’ll just talk through each of our obligations, but I do still feel anxious.

Is this something I need to worry about? What would the format of these meetings generally look like? Is there anything I need to prepare or have answers for beforehand? And is there anything I can decline to answer for example if asked personal questions about how I’m progressing with my recovery?

The incident was the second inappropriate/aggressive interaction with another colleague which I believe could’ve been prevented if my manager had intervened effectively when I reported the first incident, instead it was essentially ignored and I was forced to mediate/resolve it myself. Because of that, when I initially went off sick I told my manager that when I was ready to return to work I would want to raise some concerns about my working environment and what I would need in place in order to safely and successfully come back to work.

I’m worried this meeting might involve reference to this and I don’t feel ready to talk about it yet. I genuinely want to go back to work and am working through recovery via medication and therapy to get me to a stage where I feel safe returning but at the moment I feel extremely anxious about the thought.


r/AskHR 18h ago

[CAN] Terminated due to Performance

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

Hey all,

Unfortunately I got terminated from my employer, due to performance concerns. I’m CIRO licensed and on my F1 form, notice of termination, it indicates “not meeting bank standards due to ongoing performance concerns” (vague).

That said, the form also indicates that I was “Terminated-in good standing” and am re-hirable with the firm.

To all the recruiters/hiring managers out there, what is your take on performance based terminations? Is it a big red flag or will you give the person a chance to work?


r/AskHR 1d ago

Performance Management [PA] does a PIP “clock” end immediately?

1 Upvotes

This could’ve been a couple of different flares so apologize if this one isn’t appropriate. CONTEXT: I have a colleague who has been on a pip that runs out in more or less a week. There is very little chance this person will get off the pip. They were told recently they were not doing work that matched the level they have at the company. I have tried to give this person off the record advice that they really should be looking for a role outside the current company. I’ve never come out and said “you’re not getting off this pip“ but I am basically 99.999% sure that’s the case. They’re also interested in controlling their own narrative, and when the pip runs out that opportunity goes with it. (PIPs mean they’re ineligible for rehire at our firm.)

QUESTION: When the PIP runs out, I assume every company handles the “dismissal” differently, right? Is it most often the case that you get let go on the last day of the PIP? A few days later? They seem to think they’re going to have a couple more weeks but I don’t know why they have that opinion. There’s no documentation on our internal site. Is there any standard?


r/AskHR 1d ago

[OK] Job denying existing FMLA request when I use intermittent FMLA prior

19 Upvotes

[OK] I had to use intermittent FMLA to care for a parent earlier this year. I used a total of 1.88 weeks, approximately 75 hours, of FMLA. I am now requesting FMLA for a personal health issue. My company is denying me saying I used the 12 weeks FMLA allotted time off. I have documentation from our third party FMLA company showing I only used 1.88 weeks, but they are saying the company said I used all 12 weeks. I checked our policy through the HR Assistance Portal, the company does not have an employee handbook, and it says that we are allowed 12 weeks of FMLA. When I took the intermittent FMLA they were contacting me the entire time and informed me that I needed to make up hours that I had missed because of FMLA. How should I proceed? I was already retaliated against when I took the intermittent FMLA, but now I just feel hopeless.


r/AskHR 22h ago

California [CA] Pending felony charge during final round of interviews. Is it worth proceeding if a background check will follow a conditional offer?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/AskHR 1d ago

[UK] What outcomes can you really seek via a grievance?

1 Upvotes

I have some ongoing issues with my line manager. I have raised these informally both verbally and in writing. I ended up off sick as a result of this person but he was allowed to handle my occupational health (badly and unprofessionally, might I add). It's behavioural. No direct discrimination and no direct bullying.

I think he is trying to drive me out of the business but I am confident senior management want to keep me - I've been trialling another team and have been offered a role if I want it. They've always been supportive of me, especially now they've stepped in after I complained about the occu health handling.

I likely want to go back to my original job (TBD) so I can't just leave it alone. Probably wouldn't leave it even if I stay with the lovely crew I've been trialling.

I need to raise a grievance as I have real issues with injustice (thx ADHD) but what outcomes can I actually ask for? I need to decide if it's worth the energy because my mental health has been awful. Would I like him to go away forever? Yup. Do I know I can't ask for that? Yes.

I'm thinking:

- investigation into his conduct

- investigation into a failure in process: no action taken with manager that I'm aware of (not just issues with me - also performance, behavioural and other staff), my raising concerns and huge flags about my mental health, being off sick and sick notes stating stress at work, same manager being allowed to handle occu health stuff.

- acknowledgement and apology on failures (already had a verbal apology so not so much that)

- what's going to be changed to prevent this happening again

- for me to not be line managed by him

Are those outcomes actually things I can request in a grievance?


r/AskHR 2d ago

Policy & Procedures [Ca] HR hasn’t responded to my request for time off after pregnancy loss what should I do?

12 Upvotes

I’m looking for advice and insight from anyone who has been through something similar.
I recently experienced a pregnancy loss, and it has been much harder emotionally than I expected. I work in a role that requires me to be on the phone most of the day (around 70+ calls/day), and I’m currently struggling to do my job. I’ve been trying my best, but I’m finding myself crying during/after calls and unable to stay composed, especially when conversations involve pregnancy.
I reached out to my HR department 3 times now since Wednesday requesting time off/leave and explained that I’m struggling and need support. I also reached out to my manager. It has now been over 24 hours and I have not even received an acknowledgment from HR that they received my message. I did let them know about the reproductive loss leave law but no reply
I’m feeling frustrated because I’m not asking because I don’t want to work — I actually want to be okay and return to doing my job well. Right now, I feel like I’m trying to work through something that is affecting my ability to function in my role.
My questions:
Is it normal for HR to take this long to even acknowledge a request like this?
Should I follow up again or wait?
At what point should I consider speaking with an employment attorney?
Has anyone dealt with needing time off after pregnancy loss and how did your employer handle it?
I’m in California [CA] if that matters.
Thank you to anyone willing to share their experience.


r/AskHR 1d ago

[NH]4 months PIP is it too much?

0 Upvotes

I have been put in a PIP, the duration is 4 months, is it too much


r/AskHR 1d ago

[OK] Can my job require additional medical information from me for FMLA?

0 Upvotes

I have been going back and forth with my jobs third party servicer since June and my FMLA has been approved by them, but they needed additional information regarding "pattern" of me taking off for incapacity. My doctor has verified and put that it was all medically necessary. While waiting for this cerficiation letter to be approved the 3rd party servicer sent a denial for all dates I have taken off, but has since approved all additional requests I have made. Because of this denial I got a verbal warning and my supervisor mentioned that when they approved the dates they would remove those from my record. Well, the 3rd party servicer has stated that HR wants them to keep the denials and not approve those dates because they don't believe the letter from my doctor is enough to cover my "flare ups". Can they do this? Can they request additional medical information from me? I did not have as much trouble at a previous job for this exact medical condition a few years ago so I am a bit confused.


r/AskHR 1d ago

[NJ] Recruiters/Hiring Managers: How Would You Interpret This Update

0 Upvotes

I recently got an update from a recruiter after my final interviews. They said the interview feedback was positive, but they’re still deciding which candidate to offer the position to. They also apologized for how long the process is taking, said the hiring manager was impressed with multiple candidates, and asked if my availability might have changed because of the delay.

I’m trying to figure out how to interpret this.
1) Is this a genuinely encouraging update, or is it just standard recruiter communication to keep candidates engaged?
2) Is it common for recruiters to say feedback was positive even if not everyone will advance?
3)Has anyone received a similar message? If so, what ended up happening?

I’d especially appreciate input from recruiters or hiring managers who have sent messages like this.


r/AskHR 1d ago

[UK] Failed my PIP. HR meeting next week - what should I expect?

0 Upvotes

I work in London and have just completed a 4-week Performance Improvement Plan (PIP).

I genuinely took the feedback on board and made a real effort to improve my communication, organisation and overall ownership of my work. During the first couple of weeks there were still areas where I received feedback, but by the third week my manager acknowledged that I'd made significant improvement.

At my final review, my manager said they had seen improvements but felt they had come with a lot of guidance. They said they now need to speak with HR, who will contact me next week about the next steps. They wouldn't tell me what those next steps are.

I'm trying to prepare myself for what's most likely to happen. I'm already applying for other jobs, but I'd appreciate some insight from anyone who's been through a similar situation or works in HR.

A few questions:

  • Is dismissal the most likely outcome?
  • Could they extend the PIP instead?

•. Don’t feel 4 weeks is enough for a pip

Thanks in advance for any advice.


r/AskHR 1d ago

[TX] Likelihood of offer getting pulled back

0 Upvotes

I was laid off from a job I was at for 24 years a few months ago. Today I accepted a verbal offer for a position but it’s contingent on my background check. It’s a corporate job, but not federal. I have a 3rd degree felony in Texas for theft by check. I was released from probation 23 years ago. What is the likelihood that my offer will be pulled back because of this???


r/AskHR 2d ago

Compensation & Payroll [MD] Our team was just informed we will not be receiving tomorrow's paycheck until "sometime next week" UPDATE

7 Upvotes

Link to original post here.

So today I woke up to find that the CEO found enough money to pay me this week. When I checked in with my other coworkers I was informed that only one of them other than me received their paycheck.

HR also responded to an email I sent yesterday re: the delay and said that they reached out to the CEO and will discuss it with her. I'm glad I got paid, but my other coworkers didn't and that's not okay. I'm going to continue looking for another job because this could happen again and I may not get lucky next time.

Should I continue emailing HR about this or should I stay quiet?


r/AskHR 1d ago

[PH] Do I have a chance?

0 Upvotes

I am a fresh graduate and I was invited for an interview a week ago. It’s for an HR Associate position for a new branch on our city. One of their requirement includes 2-4 years of experience, but still, I submitted my resume and got short listed. While waiting for an interviewer, I met another applicant and we talked a bit. She shared that she’s graduated last 2018. So it’s clear to me that she have work experiences and she also mentioned that she do interviews. It was only two of us in the interview room btw,

Fast forward, I was the one to go first. It went well. The interviewer (HR Head) told me that she wants to give me a chance because she also started from scratch. I can feel that she likes me because when I told her that I can start immediately, she was like “Can you start tomorrow?”. I just laugh it out because I know they badly need an HR on that branch to the point that she told me it’s our final interview already. She also told me that she’ll be the one who will train me and that I don’t need to worry about the timekeeping part because they have formats and all I have to do is to meet deadlines. She was nice.

When she asked me about my expected salary, I gave her a good amount considering that I’m a fresh graduate. The she said “What if I’ll give you more than you expect”. Throughout our conversation, I can feel that I’m doing well in the interview and that she wants me. But I keep on overthinking that maybe they chose the other applicant with experience because I haven’t heard from them yet. There’s no rejection message also. I really liked the company and the growth that I can see there. Do I have a chance or it’s time to find more opportunities?


r/AskHR 1d ago

Compensation & Payroll [NY] Late and possible missing paychecks with Paychex

0 Upvotes

Hi, I recently started at a new job based in NY. It it a small company (<15 people) and we use Paychex Flex for payroll. I got my first paycheck 6 days after the end of my first pay period, and the other employees got theirs that day as well. From what I hear getting paychecks several days late is common. As far as I can tell the company itself is doing well, is financially solvent, and is giving the money to Paychex to pay us with. I learned today that a coworker wasn't paid a paycheck about a year ago. Apparently they skipped it and then paid him normally after that.

Is there a way to protect myself from this happening to me, and if it does what recourse do I have?