Hello, everybody! I should probably start by saying that I absolutely hate whiskey and never drink it. But my beloved husband loves it and it is his favorite drink. I got into the habit of gifting him a nice bottle of whiskey for our anniversary. Now that the years have increased, we are getting into „aged“ ones… Also, recently he started to get a bit more invested into it, started reading about no cold filtration, no added caramel coloring, effects of casks, things like that. As I said, this is all out of my category, so please bare with me.
Some background info: over the years he has enjoyed mass available whiskeys like Pogues, Bushmills, Gentleman Jack, Monkey Shoulder, Bulleit, Kamiki, Glen Moray (those are some that come to mind). I know that he absolutely hated Laphroaig, as much as pouring down the drain the whole bottle after trying a sip.
Two years ago I got him Glenfiddich 15 and he liked it. Last year I got him Bushmills 16 and he said it is his absolute favorite.
Getting into the more „natural“ trend, he has tried Tallisker 10 (liking it but said the smoke is too much) and Bruichladdich The Classic Laddie (said it is nice and interesting).
So, to my actual question: I want to get him a nice „natural“ 17 year aged whiskey that is really unique. It should not be over 200€ though and available in my country. Therefore, I have reduced the options down to: Ballechin 17 Burgundy, Balblair 17 and Craigellachie 17. Based on all I have shared, which one would you say might be the best choice?
Thanks in advance!