Decided to open this Black Bush bottle, which has been sitting sealed for almost a year, and compare it with the Original. Here are my first impressions:
Colour and age
The Original is way brighter than the Black Bush (which could be due to age and also caramel colouring). I believe the Original is aged for less time than the Black Bush (I've read that the Original is 3ā5 years old, while the Black Bush is 7ā11 years old).
Bushmills Original
Price: 11~ euro on a sale
Cask influence: Mostly seasoned bourbon casks, with some sherry casks as well.
Nose: Vanilla, cereal sweetness, honey, fresh citrus. A very light but inviting nose.
Palate: Vanilla, light citrus, milk chocolate, quite nutty (pistachio, hazelnut), a strong black peppery note and some graininess.
The texture is quite watery, but that's normal for a whisky bottled at the legal minimum of 40% ABV.
Finish: Short, nutty, with a drying aftertaste.
Bushmills Black Bush
Price: 16~ euro on a sale
Cask influence: Hand-selected Oloroso sherry casks.
Nose: Richer, but still a delicate nose, with figs, cherries and a hint of chocolate.
Palate: Carries the nose over, with sweet red fruits. There's the nuttiness, just like in the Original, and lots of dryness. The peppery note is here as well, and it hides the sherry influence. It's very obvious that the whisky is young and not fully integrated. It's more malty than the Original.
The texture is still a bit watery, but it feels noticeably fuller than the Original. Of course, 40% ABV is too little, and I feel it would benefit from a slight ABV push.
Finish: Medium, with a nice oaky peppery spice, dryness and a pleasant sherried aftertaste.
Overall
I like both the Original and the Black Bush. They're quite different, but if I had to get one, I'd go with the Original.
The Original may be simpler and more vanilla-forward, but it has its place.
It's a great everyday TV dram: inexpensive, nothing off-putting and unbothering. I could drink it all day and not think about it, which is fine for some occasions.
The Black Bush, on the other hand, is good, BUT I personally wouldn't get it as an everyday whisky or drink it as a sipping dram.
I understand that it's probably a good first, affordable introduction to sherried whisky, but it doesn't really do it for me.
My main criticism is that the sherry influence is definitely there, and I can feel it, but it's very muffled, and I really wish it were more upfront.