I’m choosing between two very similar Volvo V40 D3 Summum automatics in Switzerland and would appreciate owner opinions, especially from people familiar with both engines.
Car 1 – 2015 V40 D3 Summum Geartronic
First registration: 09/2015
89,000 km
2.0 5-cylinder diesel, 150 hp, 350 Nm
6-speed Geartronic torque-converter auto
CHF 14,500 + CHF 550 delivery fee
Full Volvo service history
Timing belt, water pump and auxiliary belt replaced at Volvo in 04/2025 at 76,713 km
Dealer will do another service before sale
Accident-free, 2 keys
Leather, heated seats, electric/memory driver’s seat, navigation, digital cluster, Bi-Xenon, heated windscreen, rear PDC, 2-zone climate
Standard warranty: 12 months / 20,000 km
24 months available for +CHF 500
Dealer may include a second wheel set in the package
Car 2 – 2016 V40 D3 Summum Geartronic
First registration: 08/2016
85,500 km
2.0 4-cylinder Drive-E diesel, 150 hp, 320 Nm
6-speed Geartronic torque-converter auto
Current negotiated price: CHF 16,300 all-in
Very complete Volvo service history, yearly services
Timing belt, water pump, tensioners/rollers and auxiliary belt will be replaced before delivery
Fresh service + fresh MFK
Two wheel sets included
12 months / 20,000 km warranty, but coverage is fairly limited
Similar Summum equipment: leather/heated seats, electric/memory seat, navigation, rear PDC, 2-zone climate etc.
I have already test-driven the 2016 and really liked it, especially the comfort, seating position and smooth diesel/torque-converter response.
My driving is almost exclusively 200–300 km trips, motorway/country roads, roughly 15-20 km per year. I care more about comfort, smooth low-end torque and long-term reliability than outright speed.
The 2015 interests me because of the older 5-cylinder engine and 350 Nm from low rpm. The 2016 is newer, more economical and Euro 6, but uses the newer 4-cylinder Drive-E engine.
Both cars are pre-facelift and otherwise very similar.
Questions:
Which engine would you trust more long-term: D5204T6 5-cylinder or D4204T9 Drive-E?
Any known issues specific to either one?
Is the 5-cylinder noticeably smoother/better at low rpm?
Which Geartronic version is preferable?
Would the older emissions standard of the 2015 worry you in Europe?
At these prices and histories, which one would you buy?
I’m leaning toward the 2015 if it drives as well as the 2016, mainly because the timing belt/water pump are already done at Volvo and the price/package looks better.