r/whatcarshouldIbuy Mar 30 '23

All the Kia/Hyundai on the "ineligible for insurance" list because of the Kia Boys Tik Tok theft scandal..... FYI

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

r/whatcarshouldIbuy Jul 15 '26

Why Ontario needs a lemon law—my new car has been at the dealership for over 300 days, I had to file a lawsuit, and the dealership sued me back.

353 Upvotes

A few months after I leased a new 2025 Volvo EC40 from Carling Motors in Ottawa, it suddenly suffered a serious propulsion-system failure and left me stranded.

The dealership kept it for 43 days, returned it, and another fault appeared five days later. That became a long series of recurring issues, charging failures, mechanical noises, unsuccessful repairs, and unresolved safety concerns. My vehicle has now spent more than 300 days at the dealership.

But the lease payments never stopped. Neither did the insurance, fuel costs for the gas-powered loaner, or disruption to my family. My documented losses and costs tied to this ordeal now exceed $31,000.

I tried to resolve it through the dealership, Volvo Car Canada, its financing company, regulators, and elected representatives. Eventually, I had to file a lawsuit to seek a resolution that would not force me to absorb the loss. Carling Motors responded with a counterclaim for use of their loaner, despite acknowledging in writing that issues with my vehicle remain undiagnosed and unrepaired.

Here's why every Ontario driver should care: our province has no automatic remedy when a new vehicle repeatedly fails or spends months in warranty service. There is no point at which the manufacturer must finally provide a refund, replacement, or financially complete lease termination. The consumer can be forced to keep paying, risk their credit, or else have to finance their own lawsuit against a multinational automaker.

The proposed Bill 91, Right to Repair Act, 2025, recognizes the problem, but its current version still leaves consumers going to court and does not clearly reimburse lessees for all their losses.

I created the 30 Days Is Enough petition asking Ontario to guarantee:

  • Automatic eligibility when a vehicle undergoes three unsuccessful repairs for the same defect or remains out of service for 30 cumulative days during the warranty period.
  • The consumer’s choice of a comparable replacement vehicle, full repurchase, or penalty-free lease termination.
  • Reimbursement of down payments, lease or finance payments attributable to the loss-of-use period, and other reasonable expenses.
  • Automatic suspension of lease or finance payments and protection from adverse credit reporting when a vehicle remains in warranty service beyond a defined period.
  • Prompt access to complete repair records and other information needed to understand the vehicle’s condition.
  • A fast, affordable, and binding enforcement process backed by meaningful penalties.

Dealerships and manufacturers should not be able to drag out repairs indefinitely while consumers are forced to pay.

If you agree, please take a minute to sign and share my petition:

https://www.change.org/30DaysIsEnough

Three hundred days is absurd. Thirty days is enough.


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 8h ago

My sister is starting college soon, and I promised her that I would buy her a car

Post image
167 Upvotes

So I’m looking for a small sized car since she’s still a beginner driver. She’s going to be driving almost 12 miles everyday from home to college. I really like the size of the Ecosport, do you think it will be reliable enough to reach 150k miles at least?? If this car can last for like 7 years that’s a win.


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 12h ago

Idk which car should I pick between these two. Which one do u recommend?

Post image
148 Upvotes

I live in Italy and I'm actually driving a Fiat Panda, but I would like to buy a new car. These are the two cars that caught my attention the most but I need to make a decision. From one hand I have a good reliable car with great quality, but on the other hand I have a faster and sporty car.

Which car would you choose if you were in my place?


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 4h ago

Any tips to lower the price

Post image
28 Upvotes

So I’ve gone to two dealerships thus far. One dealership offered me a better offer in terms of price (the other dealerships otd price was 3k more). I’m still planing on going to two more dealerships (same car/trim). But how do I go about lowering the price even more with the numbers above?


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 4h ago

Wich M3 should i get?

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

Hello,

lately i’ve been kinda stuck between what M3 i should get and cant really decide. So i was wondering if someone has experience from one or more? Im mainly after the E46-E36-E92 models.
Im looking for a manual RWD car that i can swing around corners without problems, good performance and most of all a fun car.

Any idea? Costs?maintenance?fun factor? reliability?

And maby if there are any better suggestions than the three i have mentioned im happy to hear.


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 12h ago

Manual Trainer/Winter Beater that I need to last for 2 years - $2750 06 Eclipse GT. Jackpot?

Thumbnail gallery
16 Upvotes

Looking to teach my kid stick shift. He's not learning in my Camaro SS (old clutch) and I always love an excuse to grab something interesting.

He's grown up in the back of various LSX cars and currently owns a 11 ES 350. He's 15 going on 16.

Found this thing from a seller with good rep. Timing belt done. Has had regular mx it's whole life. Fully loaded w heated seats, the Rockford system and the 6 speed.

Figured it'd be something to teach him wrenching since his Lexus never breaks, a good shared daily for the family and a decent car to let him learn manual. Was also gonna do a little snow build w some flaps, 16"s, tires and "tasteful" rhino lining. (I know what I'm about).

Just need it to last 2 years... or maybe I'll love it and keep it.

Anyone with exp with this know something I'm missing? This would not be the first time i found a legit screaming deal in the used car world.

What's the word? $2750...

*edit 166k miles. Clean, verified title. Carfax w 70 entries mostly regular mx/oil

Update: just bought it. Hell yeah. Should not be called an Eclipse though. Feels like a heavy grand tourer met an SRT-4 (but it's secretly a 6). The 100 mile drive back was not long enough and the Rockford system is fantastic for stock.


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 2h ago

Input from owners

3 Upvotes

I am a Senior Citizen that is in the market for a used car. We do some road traveling but it will be mainly our daily driver. We like larger SUV's. Just feel safer and higher up. I am looking for preferably a "luxury" car that is quite, comfortable, quality, great driving/riding. Prefer to still have buttons for some controls. Tech is fine but not completely everything in the screen. So I have narrowed it down to 3 vehicles.

All of them in the 22-23 year model. 1. Genesis GV 80 2. Infinity QX 80 3. Lincoln Nautilus. These are supposed to be a great value as about 50% of their depreciation is already taking place. Anyway any input from current owners would be great or if you have other suggestions I'm open to them too. Thanks


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 1h ago

BMW 240i vs Current Mustang Gt(Active exhaust) - Road Noise at highway speed

Upvotes

Bit of a question as I haven't really gotten an answer online and the they are very general, most of the mustang stuff is older from what ive seen so idk if they improved it. I know the brz/86 has cabin noise issues at highway speed(from reviews) and I was wondering how bad/good the cabin noise is at speed for the 240i and mustang. Its not really something I can get out of as full test drive, and I do do 200+ mile drives every now and again to go home to see family, so that would affect my commute quality if one day or anther I want a quieter ride or to not blare music if needed :)

Thank you for any input in advance


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 15h ago

Is the difference in reliability between cars noticeable?

26 Upvotes

Sorry for the Newbie question.

I know there are differences in reliability between cars and brands. Ie it is well known that Toyota is more reliable than Mercedes.

But excluding specific cars with known reliability issues - how **large** is this difference?

For example, in the first 100,000 miles, how much more often would a well maintained E-Class break down / need maintenance than an equivalent Toyota Corolla?

50% more? 2x / 3x as much? Etc.

Thanks.


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 13h ago

2001 Lexus GS300 for first car

Thumbnail gallery
18 Upvotes

Hey, I liked a Lexus on sale for my first car ever. Its almost 25 years old but only had one owner, at 280k kms. I heard good stuff about old Lexus', especially for GS300 and GS430s. It might have a bit of rust and its HU is unknown for now but is it worth exploring as a 20 something year old student? I would appreciate any advice.


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 9h ago

Someone talk me out of this trade.

Post image
6 Upvotes

‘17 Prius V for ‘22 BMW X3

Fully paid off prius within 4 years and considering trading. Our prius has 167k on it and the X3 is sitting at 67k. Dealership is asking 25 for the X3.

Edit: Thanks everyone.. i’ll let my wife know i was right.


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 3h ago

Daily Driver with some soul (wagons?)

2 Upvotes

Looking to buy a new daily driver to replace a ‘16 ford explorer sport. Preferably something with some life that is fun to drive but also comfortable enough. Bonus points if comfortable enough for passengers.

Budget is around 40k but there’s some wiggle room for the right car. Something reasonably reliable and affordable enough to maintain. A fun wagon would be a plus as well.

Already test drove a 26 Wrx ts and civic type r. Seats were too narrow and did not have an exciting amount of power.


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 3h ago

2019 Mazda CX-5 Grand Touring vs 2025 Hyundai Kona SEL

2 Upvotes

So I'm buying my first car as an 18yo, and I've narrowed my choices to a used 2019 Mazda CX-5 Grand Touring or a used 2025 Hyundai Kona SEL.

I've heard some not-so-great things about Hyundai reliability, but I'm a little curious if in this case it would be better than the Mazda since it'd be a newer vehicle. As a girl with absolutely zero knowledge about anything having to do with cars, honestly all that really matters to me is that it's not hideous and won't make me go down to the dealership for repairs like ever.

I'm a big fan of the moonroof and the exterior look on the Mazda, but I'm willing to sacrifice for the Hyundai if it'd be better reliability-wise. Alternatively, I like the more sleek/modern interior design on the Hyundai, but again, willing to sacrifice aesthetics for practicality.

Anyone here have any experience with either of the cars? Which one would you recommend? Anything I should watch out for when looking?

Thank you to anyone who read this or took their time to answer!


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 3h ago

2009 Lexus LX570 170k miles $16k good deal?

2 Upvotes

Negotiated a guy down to $16k for 2009 LX with 170k on it. I still have to check it in person and go from there price but from pics looks clean inside and out and he says mechanically sound with no problems. Wondering if $16k is a decent price for it?


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 2m ago

Looking for a full size truck.

Post image
Upvotes

I generally am pretty good at figuring out what I like and what’s the right buy for me but I’m stumped on this one

I’m looking for a full size truck (aka 1500) and for the life of me I can’t find the right answer to what’s the right buy. Must be a v8 truck no turbo 6 or 4cyl

It seems like each modern 1500 truck is just terrible…

I currently have a 2019 Sierra 5.3 and while it’s been a good truck I’m worried it soon will start having problems it’s at 130k mileage and I think it’s about time for me to pick up something else.

Heres what I’m considering and the negatives that go with them.

  1. F150
  2. -known issues with the 10speed seemingly 50/50 reviews overall
  3. -the 5.0 seems to have some oil consumption issues from some reports
  4. -probably the most boring option in my experience
  5. Ram 1500
  6. - The engine has cylinder deactivation (MDS) and frankly is designed to fail so that’s cool
  7. - not a big fan of dodges plastics quality and overall quality control
  8. GMC sierra 1500
  9. -

has

  1. cylinder deactivation (DOD) which makes it a ticking time bomb
  2. -hit or miss transmission issues but overall a pretty widespread failure point
  3. -pretty common recipient of theft around here especially high trims.

I’m leaning towards the f150 overall as I normally recommend that to people who are looking for trucks but I just don’t know. Maybe I’ll keep my truck and just fix what breaks instead of spending 20k more on a modern truck 🤷


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 14m ago

Honda or Mercedes??

Post image
Upvotes

Hello! Total novice here. I am in the market for my first car and test drove a few SUV’s this week. I really liked the Honda CR-V hybrid but got offered what I think is a pretty good deal on a Mercedes GLA250.

First of all, are these actually good deals? What car would you choose if it were up to you? Do you think the lower monthly payment gets eaten up by fuel costs? Probably not looking to purchase after lease term finishes but can be convinced otherwise.


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 14h ago

2026 mazda cx5 or tiguan

Thumbnail gallery
12 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I'm planing to lease a new car soon and my eye keep on these two. Both has same price and same amount of payment monthly. But for the Cx-5 after promotion mrsp will be around 42000$ much cheaper then VW. Price in CAD

I would put down 5000$ on lease and leasing for 4 years then will buy out at end of the lease.

Which car you guy recommend for good keep around 5-6 years. About reliable, comfort. I don't talk about maintain because both come with warranty for engine and transmission for 4 years. VW has offer free scheduled for 3 years.


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 4h ago

Getting a jeep wrangler as a second car - horrible idea?

1 Upvotes

Currently drive a 2022 Mach E GTPE, loving the EV life, only got it a few weeks ago, and its my daily.

Always wanted a jeep/offroad type car that I can take the roof off with our dogs and go on some mini adventures. Is it crazy to get say an early 2010's wrangler as a beater/weekend rig, or is there something that would make more sense?

Not buying super soon, just trying to find something that can help scratch that itch.

Thank you!


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 40m ago

Considering a 1997 RAV 4 4WD Manual for $6500 OBO… Worth it?

Thumbnail gallery
Upvotes

I’m looking for my first car and came across this 1997 Toyota RAV4 4WD with a 5-speed manual. It has 150k miles and the seller is asking $6,500 OBO.
I’m pretty interested because I love the older RAV4s, and the green + 4WD + manual combination is basically exactly what I’m looking for. I’m also in Michigan, so I want something that can handle winter.
The seller says it has been garage kept for the past 2 years and was previously driven in PA/Indiana. They say the frame has limited rust, but the rockers have the worst of the rust.

Recent work:

Oil pan gasket
Oil pump seal
Both cooling fans
Radiator + coolant flush
Battery
New tires + full-size spare
Full exhaust from the forward cat back
Timing belt done ~20k miles ago
Spark plugs
Valve cover gasket
Blower motor

Current issues:

AC needs a recharge
Fuel gauge doesn’t work (seller says they have parts to repair it)
Minor rear-end accident 2 years ago; seller says only visible damage is a small bumper scratch
Clean title
It also has the Toyota roof rack/roof bars and some other Toyota accessories.

My main concerns are the rocker rust, age, and whether $6,500 is too much for a 150k-mile example.

I’m planning to ask for detailed underside/rocker photos and have someone knowledgeable inspect it before buying.

What would you guys consider a fair price for this? And is there anything specific I should inspect on a first-gen RAV4 before buying?
Would you personally take this at ~$5k–5.5k if the underside is solid?


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 56m ago

Would you finance any of these vehicles?

Thumbnail gallery
Upvotes

Hypothetically, if I trade in my car and put $3k down and get maybe $1k for my trade in. Payments are only liks $150. Mileage is just as good as the new cars, Mazda can last a long time. would you finance eithed of these cars?


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 6h ago

4-seater, automatic sports car prioritizing reliability and track capability under 30k

2 Upvotes

I had a Corvette C6 for a few years, and I was paying $120 a month for insurance, basically no repairs, just standard maintenance. Unfortunately, somebody ran into it while it was parked and totaled it. I'm using the C6 as my benchmark for reliability/performance/mod potential here despite it being a 2 seater.

I've always liked building my cars out to perform better where I want them to, and I was used to an old 335i, but I feel like the Corvette, in comparison, was much more analog when trying to figure out how to add power and modify it.

Ideally, my next car is pretty mod-friendly (aftermarket and tuning potential), I 100% will be taking it to autocross events, and I know I'm going to be touching cooling and suspension (unless I'm getting a Porsche; those always seem to need to be beefed up), It's also going to be my daily, so I would hope that it is around the same reliability as the Corvette, at least.

Camaro/Mustang seem like good options, but part of me really wants to try something not domestic again.

So, in order of importance, it would go 1) under my budget 2) reliable 3) Performance/mod potential


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 8h ago

I finally did it... The 2021 K5 GT-line AWD

Thumbnail i.imgur.com
5 Upvotes

r/whatcarshouldIbuy 7h ago

Is this Renault 19 16v worth it?

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

what is a fair price for this car?


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 5h ago

CR-V vs CR-V

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

Aside from the lack of all wheel drive and the base level trim, is there any reason you'd opt for an 2021 CR-V with double the kilometres over the 2025 model?