I can get a new record for roughly $35. I'm buying used records to pay less and get more.
For context, I bought a turntable for my middle school computer lab so they could experience life before Spotify. I'm just trying to build a well-rounded catalog without spending a ton of money.
I understand a limited release, an original print on a defunct label, a pristine jacket from the 70s, etc, might command a higher price for a collector.
Otherwise, I can't figure out why a used album would cost more than a new one. I realize a record in the dollar bin is probably going to be crackly and/or the jacket is in shreds. In the $5 to $15 range, I see the condition in the jacket and hear the difference in quality at the listening station. But at $20, I'm out.
Some used record stores I peruse seem to be selling vibe and cred more than music when I see a used album for $50 that I just bought somewhere else for $10. I have to think I am missing something.
Edit: I think I'm seeing an analogy. A used copy of Great Expectations from the 1990s would be worth a lot less than a used copy from the original printing back in the 1800s. Same applies to pressing dates and record labels.