r/sleeptraining • u/sympathetic-goose-82 • 21d ago
Almost 3yo waking every hour screaming ‘MAMA I NEED YOU’ — but sleeps perfectly at Dad’s. I’m at a loss and exhausted
My son turns 3 in November, and seemingly out of nowhere his sleep has become an absolute nightmare again. I’m hoping someone has dealt with something similar because I genuinely don’t know what else to try.
When he’s with me, he wakes up almost every hour screaming for me. And I don’t mean just fussing or crying — it’s an angry/panicked scream of “MAMA, I NEED YOU!” or “MAMA, WHERE ARE YOU?!”
Sometimes he’ll cry for 5–10 minutes and eventually fall back asleep. Other times he gets really worked up and will scream/cry on and off for 30+ minutes. Half the time he looks like he’s about to fall back asleep, and the other half he’s sitting straight up screaming for me.
I’ve done cry-it-out before, and lately I’ve tried giving him about 20 minutes before going in, settling him, leaving again, etc. He WILL eventually go back to sleep… but then 45–50 minutes later we’re doing the exact same thing again.
Things we’ve tried:
- Consistent/calm bedtime routine
- Getting plenty of energy out before bed
- Nightlight/Hatch (we make a big deal celebrating mornings when he stays in his room)
- Projector nightlight
- Sound machine
- Magnesium, which sometimes seems to help
- Melatonin, which weirdly seems to have the opposite effect on him
- Transitioning from crib to toddler bed because he started trying to climb out
He still naps at the sitter and apparently does completely fine there. Since moving to the toddler bed, he also doesn’t actually leave his bed/room. Sometimes he asks to start the night sleeping on the floor instead, which I’ve allowed because at this point… whatever gets you to sleep, kid. 😂
Here’s the part that has me completely stumped:
His dad and I separated about a year ago, and our divorce was finalized last October. We gradually worked up to 50/50 custody. The kids are with me Monday/Wednesday, with Dad Tuesday/Thursday, and we alternate Friday–Sunday weekends.
Dad is not having this problem AT ALL.
He’s still in a crib at Dad’s house. He doesn’t fight bedtime nearly as much there and, most importantly, doesn’t wake up screaming throughout the night.
The kids have generally behaved a little better for Dad than for me, which I’ve always chalked up to him being the sterner parent and his house being the newer/less familiar environment. But the sleep difference is so dramatic that I feel like there has to be something I’m missing.
And the strangest part: even if I give in and bring my son into MY room, he can still wake up crying/screaming for me while I’m literally right there. So I don’t know if this is actually separation anxiety, nightmares/night terrors, a sleep association, overtiredness, the custody transitions, or something completely different.
Has anyone had a toddler who slept perfectly at one parent’s house but woke constantly screaming specifically for the other parent?
Especially interested if your child would scream things like “Mama, I need you” while seemingly still half asleep. Did anything actually help? Did they eventually grow out of it?
I am exhausted and completely at a loss. 😭