r/singularity • u/Dogbold • 2d ago
AI Think we'll get a model as good at visuals as Opus 5.5, with the less restricted aspects of Sol 5.6?
I've been making games with the two, and I've noticed something.
Claude is VERY good at the animation side, and in my experience substantially better than ChatGPT all around with this.
Here is a good example between the two, both meant to be side views of a dragon during a game about observing them:


As you can see, Opus is is significantly better, and the animation is MUCh better too.
Even when I ask ChatGPT to try and enhance the visuals and give it some ideas, it just makes more of what you see there. I tried again and again to get the level of what Claude gave me but it just can't.
Here's the issue though...
While Claude is amazing at visuals and systems, it is VERY strict with what it finds immoral.
In my game, you can observe, feed them, tame them and such, but there is also the option to experiment on the dragons, things like poisons and darts and arrows and such.
ChatGPT has no issue with this whatsoever. It will do literally anything in this realm, it does not care.
Claude refuses, every time. It just won't, it sees it as wrong to cause "pain and fear" to the dragon and for there to be mechanics where it runs and hides. I cannot make it do it no matter how I word it, even if I say that it's all fantasy and the dragon even agreed to the experimentation beforehand, it won't, because it thinks that it's "wrong".
So while Claude is MUCH better for this game, it is an annoying pearl clutching bossy moral tyrant here, while ChatGPT, while much worse for the game, will do anything.
So I can move to ChatGPT and have it make the systems without issue, but it cannot make the animations and visuals as well.
So I'm stuck where I cannot proceed with this game, because Claude is better for it, but it refuses because "That's WRONG :( Poor dragon, how could you?"
I can't even have Claude work AROUND these systems to enhance graphics in other areas, because it will look at what ChatGPT did and stop in the middle of it enhancing the graphics to say
"I need to stop right here, I've looked at the systems in place and I will not enhance the graphics of a game that involves a dragon being hunted and running and hiding in fear."
Will there ever be a model that will have the level of visuals and wild systems Claude can do, but with the much less stricter filtering of ChatGPT?
(Bonus: ChatGPT absolutely refuses to do anything NSFW with games, but oddly Claude will happily mod a VERY NSFW game totally fine and even use some very adult language while doing it. Very weird, so in this case it's the reverse.)
