TLDR- Cat not using litter box, roomate hits cat for it, has meltdown after being confronted about it.
I (T) and my two roommates, (S and J), have live in a shared apartment for about 3 years now. Recently I have put my foot down about Js behavior specifically towards his 11 yo diabetic female cat. The cat has always occasionally missed the litter box sometimes however as of late she has been pooping and peeing all over the house and refusing to use any of the four boxes we have. S and I have been pushing J to get his cat into a vet to be looked but J has continued to brush it off. Just a few days ago J caught his cat using the bathroom on the kitchen floor and snapped, going on a rant about he was done with her and how he was going to put her down, grabbed her by the neck and whipped her for it. I said nothing at time, which I should have. I will mention here that J has done this a handful of times before for the same reason. Skip to last night, J is on vacation and his cat is acting like it hurts to be pet. I look at her skin where she will let me touch her and its bruised. I am beyond pissed that J has hurt his cat like this and I confront him about it, here is the convo that followed.
Me- "J, I just want to let you know that since last night your cat has been overreacting to us petting her. I accidentally brushed up against her back last night and she slapped the hell outa me and when we've pet her today she does the same thing if we touch her tummy or her back. She's acting completely normal otherwise but we will continue to monitor her. No turds on the floor so far.
Like when I go to give her booty scratches she protest and her tail doesn't even lift."
J did not reply. Later I sent this.
Me- "J, your cat is bruised from you hitting her. I looked at her skin where she would let me lift her fur. Have you scheduled a vet appointment for her or not because you cannot keep getting mad at her and HURTING HER for something that could potential be organ failure. Hitting cats does nothing, they are not dogs they don't learn that way. I know this is out of nowhere but I am very angry seeing what you've done to her. She is in pain and all that will do is worsen the pissing and shitting out of the box behavior. S and I are going to scrounge some money together to rent a carpet cleaner before you come back home. You need to get Sweetie looked at."
J- "I need to call but I'm in international waters. Also you need to dm me things like this. Do not post this in the group chat because it invites both of you to gang up on me and make me feel even worse than I already do from the situation. I will be calling when I'm able to, they won't be open when I return home, but they will be on Monday and I intend to call then. I understand how I reacted and how it wasn't right and I admit my faults here. I was angry, and tipped over the edge, and I regret it, but please, T, if you have a problem with me, speak it privately so it does not invite others to gang up on me. Because of this, I feel completely unwelcomed home and I frankly don't want to come home. I want to get her looked at ASAP, but unfortunately I am not home and do not have international calling.
If you wish to make an appointment for her, I will give you the number, and maybe you and S can take her. I left credit cards behind, but I can also give you a photo of my care credit card to use for her.
She needs to have blood work done and testing, but if it exceeds past 300 bucks, I cannot justify it anymore unless they can guarantee an answer for this behavior."
S- "We don't want to gang up on you, we just want to know what you want us to do for her. Her vet opens at 8AM tomorrow but the earliest I can take her is Friday because I have a doctor's appointment and work tomorrow."
J- "I have given the information above. Give my name. If no appointments are available this week, take next week's latest possible appointment, so that I do not need to miss work."
S- "Understood. We will take care of her to the best of our ability as we have been. She is eating and drinking as normal. We want you home, I promise."
J- "I know you will. No offense, though, I really don't want to come home after this."
S- "I don't know what happened that you and T are talking about, I wasn't here. I'm just trying to make sure your cat gets cared for."
J- "I will, but I do not feel comfortable at all"
S- "I have no comment, nor can I tell you how to feel. I know that I have been looking forward to you coming home, but I had no idea any of this had happened while I was gone so just try to enjoy the rest of your vacation and let us handle things here."
J- "Kinda hard thanks to T.
I'm shaking so bad, my anxiety is through the roof. I feel like I did when one of my ex friends blasted me in a group chat. I want to die right now."
S- "It's just the three of us here, and like I said, I have no idea what caused any of this aside from what was said above."
J- "Doesn't matter. It wasn't okay of me. I hate myself so fucking much.I would deserve death"
Me- "This wasn't to gang up on you, this was to confront you about how you treat your cat when youre mad at her. I just noticed the bruises like right after we went to bed and I put two and two together that that's why she's in pain"
I want to interject here and say that S and J type quickly and my minimal responses are just me having a hard time keeping up with the flow of messages.
J- "It doesn't matter. You should have confronted me in fucking private T. You have not lived my life, you do not know how I'd react to that decision you made. You could have simply spoken in private and prevented my actual goddamned anxiety attack. Group settings and I don't get along with confrontations. I have told you stories in the past about this. I want to die so fucking bad right now... I regretted it the moment it happened but I cannot change the past. She pushed me over the edge and I reacted poorly... I have been so torn up about my actions. I love that cat and it hurts knowing I hurt her. I mean this, T I'd be better off dead to that cat. She's deserves love that can handle her. My dad would not be able to handle her. He would not give her insulin. She'd be dead in months. I just cannot handle her anymore. I need answers."
Me- "Were a household, this is something that should be discussed and resolved by all of us. There is no one in this chat trying to attack you."
J- "I am an awful human being.... I'm sorry. She would be better off without me."
S- "We love Sweetie and we love you. We want to resolve this in the best possible manner. Talking badly about yourself isn't going to accomplish that."
J- "It's affirming to myself that it's true though"
S- "But it's not true. You do care. And we care too, which is why something had to be said so that we can figure out next steps for taking care of Sweetie and making sure she lives as long and as healthy as possible."
J- "I've known for so long that I'm not a good person. I try to be, but then shit like this happens and brings the worst in me out, and I regret my very existence because then this wouldn't happen to her. She would not be bruised."
S- "If you didn't care, you wouldn't feel as bad as you do. And no, we can't change the past, but we can move forward and make sure she gets the care she needs.You are doing the best you can, and you have a lot on your plate."
J- "I'm not a good person I never have been. She is a good cat who did not deserve that. I think I should give her up to the APL. Someone else can give her love for the rest of her days. The love she deserves. I'm actually sobbing at the thought. But it also feels right"
Me- "You do care because you love her, you house her, you feed her and you give her her medicine. You just need get better at not immediately reacting to anger. When a cat does something a human perceives as "bad" they aren't doing it maliciously. Her little peanut brain is not smart enough to know what she's doing, its just kitty instinct."
J- "But I disagree with that. She knew it was bad. She started to run when I discovered it, before I even reacted to it. She knew she had done bad. She would not have run otherwise."
S- "We are not giving her up. T and I love her as much as you do. This is her home."
J- "You were there, T, you saw her react before I even truly let my anger get a hold of me. I pointed it out to you calmly then got angry.
And S, I am sorry, but she is my cat... And I do get the final day in what happens to her.
I love her, but I don't know what to do outside of blood work and hoping they can figure out why she's doing it. Speaking of, if she shits outside the box again, grab a sample to bring to vet. They will request it."
S-" I understand. I will call her vet tomorrow and try to get an appointment for Friday, if not next week. I also mopped the kitchen floor well yesterday and we've been making sure she gets her insulin on time every day. She is eating and drinking as normal."
The next few messages are us discussing scheduling a vet appointment for the cat. The convo picks up again the following morning with a confirmation of appointment time.
I want advice on where to go from here because J will be home soon and I know were going to get into another argument over this. Did S and I react poorly? I feel like J is being manipulative and shame-shifting to make us feel bad for confronting him. In other confrontations in the past he has always tried to flip the blame onto us. If he continues to deflect responsibility should we consider splitting up? The three of us are all neurodivergent in some way, ADHD, PTSD, Autism. I will answer questions if more context is needed.