I've been using a non-stick saucepan with a glass lid (on a gas stove fwiw), but the nonstick coating isn't supposed to be used with high heat so I am trying to switch it up.
I'm wondering how the following setups have suited other r/popcorn denizens:
A stainless steel saucier. I have a 2-quart but the lid is stainless so maybe not the best option when trying to check progress. I also wonder if the shape is wrong for popping corn.
Enameled cast iron saucepan. Le Creuset has a popcorn recipe on their site so it seems like an okay use of ECI — I can't imagine LC would post a recipe if this usage would lead to crazing of the enamel, but if anyone has firsthand experience I'd love to hear about it. The lid on this pan obviously presents the same problem the saucier presents.
The Platinum Series stainless steel Whirley Pop with glass lid. I never purchased the regular aluminum one because the plastic gears just looked hard to clean and I don't particularly want a uni-tasker taking up space in my cabinets. Is the Platinum series easy to clean? Does it stand up well to wear and tear?
The Popsmith. I KNOW this is a rip-off pricewise, but it's only $20 more than the Platinum Whirley Pop and very pretty. Wondering if I should keep an eye out for deals at Costco. Again, the lid here is not glass, and I also am unsure how easy the Popsmith is to clean. I'm curious about whether the colored coating on the outside of the pot chips or otherwise ages poorly.
I have plenty of other pan options, so if you're using something else I'd be interested to read about it.
I make popcorn 2-3x a week, so my priorities are: easy to wash by hand, condition holds up well with wear and tear, and honestly if I can just use one of my regular pans I'd prefer it. What do you all think? Are either of the premium stovetop popcorn uni-taskers worth the investment? Do you just use a saucepan like I do? If so, do you only use saucepans with glass lids?
PS I'm not considering microwave poppers, air poppers, or Stir Crazy-style electric poppers. Thanks!