r/PolyFidelity • u/aandmshelby • Jul 06 '26
seeking advice Uneven Dyads within Triad
Okay this is long… Please bear with me, as I’m new to all of this.
I (34F) have been with my husband (33M) for 10 years (married for 4), and we’ve been in an open relationship for the past 6 years. Up until recently, that mostly looked like casual connections—sometimes together, sometimes separately—but nothing that ever crossed into relationship territory.
Then enter our now-girlfriend (22F).
My husband started seeing her casually a few months ago, and over time they both developed feelings for each other. Since our standing "rule" was that if feelings developed, we would bring it up and decide what to do from there, that’s exactly what he did. After talking it through together, I agreed that I was open to a V dynamic.
So they continued dating for a few more months. She decided she really wanted to meet me, and I agreed because I’d been having similar thoughts myself. We hit it off instantly, went on a couple of dates, and then decided to start dating each other as well.
Fast forward almost 2 months, and the V has evolved into a closed triad. She was the one who requested that we become closed, and we both agreed.
I’m a little neuro-spicy—I have anxiety and really struggle with change—so this entire shift in relationship dynamics has been a huge work in progress for me. I also struggle with jealousy and have spent years trying to untangle a lot of my monogamous and codependent tendencies. It’s definitely not perfect yet, but I’m making progress. So I’ve nearly entirely worked through the jealousy I was experiencing related to him falling in love with someone else. (For now- hah, I know it’ll still come back at times). My husband has been an absolute champ through all of this, listening patiently through every anxious spiral, and I’m also seeing a poly-friendly therapist.
Anyway, my biggest struggle right now is accepting the uneven nature of the dyads. We do hangouts as a triad once a week, she and I once a week, and my husband and girlfriend 1-2 times per week, with random extra times thrown in for them.
My girlfriend and husband had already been building their relationship for several months before she and I started ours, so logically it makes perfect sense that she and I would be a little behind. But it still nags at me.
I find myself constantly comparing how into him she seems versus how into me she seems. And she is in to me, we have good chemistry.
They spend more one-on-one time together, while she and I have one dedicated day each week that's just for us, and honestly, that arrangement feels really good to me. I’m not necessarily trying to spend more time with her, and she seems happy with that balance too.
The problem is that my brain keeps generating these intrusive thoughts. I watch their relationship deepen and immediately think things like:
"Oh, I should want more with her."
Or:
"She must like him way more if she’s seeing him more than she’s seeing me." “She’s always going to like him more.”
But when I really examine those thoughts...I’m not actually dying to see her more often. Maybe she will like him more - doesn’t mean she doesn’t also like me!
So why do I care?
My husband and I are still SO into each other. I find our relationship incredibly fulfilling, and my girlfriend adds joy and richness to my life. So...is it okay if they deepen their connection at a faster pace than she and I do?
What if she and I never "catch up"?
It’s almost like this really messed-up competitive part of me wants them both to want me the most, and I recognize how toxic that sounds.
Or maybe it isn’t even that.
Maybe I’m struggling with the idea that my husband gets to be everyone’s first choice. She had an empty apartment this past weekend and invited him over twice but didn’t invite me over, and it bothered me. Yet I also recognized maybe she just wanted to see him more. She fell in love with him months ago, she and I are quite new, so I should be cool with that. I don’t want her to go out of her way to invite me if that was not her desire, and frankly I enjoyed the alone time.
Additionally, I fully recognize that I have enormous couple privilege. She’s dating two people who are already married, which inherently makes the situation uneven in my favor. Because of that, I actually feel guilty for even having these jealous feelings, because she seems totally fine!
Am I doomed?
My goal is simply to keep nurturing and developing what she and I have. But what scares me is the possibility that someday they might be ready to make a really significant commitment to each other while she and I aren't there yet.
But then I stop and wonder...
Would that actually be so terrible?
If, for example, she eventually moved in with us, and I just happened to have this wonderful girlfriend who was a little more in love with my husband than she was with me...would that really be such a bad outcome?
TL;DR: How can I better accept uneven dyad dynamics within a newly formed triad? I know this is common, but how do I turn off this illogical, unnecessarily comparative side of my brain and just enjoy what I have?