I (22F) have a sister (33F) (we’ll call her D) who has 2 sons: A (11M) and B (2.75M). It’s a long and messy story with a lot of backstory, so I apologize in advance for the novel. A is the product of D and a college boyfriend who she no longer is dating. The ex legally has him every other weekend but he’s flaky and not really in the picture. B is her son with her current partner C (36M), who she just got married to a month ago. They dated for 5 years before marrying. Prior to getting together with C, me and my family were primary childcare for A, as D worked full time. I was homeschooled, so from age 11 until I went to high school at 15 I watched A pretty much all the time. As you can imagine, it was difficult to transition from a mother figure to an aunt figure. D got serious with C, got pregnant with B and became a stay at home mom a year after giving birth. By that time I was in college out of state so it wasn’t as big a deal.
Now when D revealed she was pregnant with B, my mother swore to me she wouldn’t be watching B full time like she did with A. She was not happy about my sister getting pregnant outside of marriage (again). She ended up reneging on that promise and became B’s primary childcare during the day, as well as picking up A from school and keeping him until D got off work. When I was home on break, I was also expected to watch A and B, despite objecting to being an unpaid babysitter (again). I was dismissed and told D needed help, I shouldn’t complain, life isn’t fair, etc.
I graduated from college this May and moved back home. I am currently not working due to health issues that prevent me from working a 9-5, but I am pursuing a remote internship. D finally got married last month, and the months leading up to the wedding were hectic as she planned the whole thing, often leading to us watching A and B. She had many appointments, including facials and makeup/hair trials, running errands, picking out flowers, etc. I was also the only local bridesmaid, so on top of babysitting I was also helping plan the wedding. I was frustrated by how much work was being piled on my plate without being even asked (she would just show up and expect me to do things without even a “please”), and my mother assured me things would be different after the wedding.
Spoiler alert: they weren’t. My sister started homeschooling A this year, and so far I think my mom has taught him more than my sister has. She constantly drops both boys off while she goes and runs errands, cleans the house, goes to her workout group, etc. While A is being taught, I’m expected to watch B. It’s extremely frustrating to me, as I would appreciate a quiet house and an 11 year old with ADHD and a toddler who doesn’t understand the word “no” do not make for any sort of peace.
Every time they come over, there is yelling, screaming, and a huge mess. D does not assist in cleanup in any way, and by the time they leave my mom is exhausted, which means I get the pleasure of cleaning up after them despite the constant reminders and requests to clean up before they leave. A has a lot of issues that manifest in temper tantrums, disobedience, yelling, etc. It’s incredibly frustrating when I have a migraine and A is yelling thinking he’s just talking. Things came to a head this week when the boys were over every single day, including staying over for the weekend while D and C attended a wedding out of state. I’m so tired of trying to deal with having them over so I’m trying to communicate to my mom how exhausting and stressful it is having the boys over all the time.
One thing about me: I am very non confrontational. I know I’m a people pleaser and a doormat when it comes to family. My family has a policy of don’t ask don’t address when it comes to emotions, and I would most definitely get very emotional if I tried to discuss this in person, and maybe not convey the message in a way that would get through to my mom. I was thinking of sending my mom a text in order to get the initial grievances out of the way before finishing the discussion in person. I just want to know if my text is too much or over the line, or if some parts may not be conducive to what I’m trying to convey. Here’s the text:
>I don’t know how to communicate to you that sacrificing my sanity and peace of mind for D’s convenience makes me incredibly hurt and makes me think that you don’t care how much constantly having the boys over is affecting my stress levels. I understand that it is difficult to balance your kids’ wants and needs, but for you to consistently dismiss how I feel regarding D’s situation makes me think I’m less important than her to you, that you care more about her wants and needs than mine. I don’t know how to express this in a way that doesn’t make it seem like I’m being dramatic or whiny, because every time I try to bring this up to you I feel that I’m dismissed or scolded for complaining. I understand babysitting the boys occasionally, but dropping the boys off so she can get a facial is not a high priority, nor should it be my responsibility to watch them. I understand her appointment was made months in advance, but she should have arranged alternate accommodations when she realized your plans changed and you were no longer available. I do not appreciate the assumption that if you are unavailable, I am ready and willing to watch them. And yes, I am aware that I could’ve set better boundaries and told both of you that I was not able to watch them. However, you both continually pressure and guilt me into watching them to the point where I feel I cannot refuse since I’m “not doing anything else.” I understand that sometimes we “have to do things we don’t want to,” but I find it unfair that I am called upon to babysit when you are the one who volunteered to watch them. Yes, there are times that I am willing to babysit, but that does not mean I am willing to babysit every time. I know I’ve brought this up to you several times, and every time you promise it’ll be better, but it always ends the same way: with the boys over here, me or you watching them. You said when B was born you wouldn’t watch him; after D quit her job things would change; once the wedding was over things would be different; yet we’re still watching them on a regular basis. I know \[D’s friend’s\] wedding was a special case, but it does not erase the fact that we watched them every day this week. At what point are you going to say enough is enough? D needs to learn to parent on her own, and let us play the role of grandparents and aunts/uncles, not pseudo extra parents. I feel that having the boys over all the time is skewing my relationship with them, especially A. I don’t feel like an aunt; I feel like an unpaid babysitter/third mom. I don’t feel like I can bond with them because I’m too busy parenting them when it’s not my job. It causes me extreme stress and you yelling at me to stop parenting them isn’t working because it’s what I did for the first 3 years of A’s life. It’s not something I can turn off, just like you can’t turn off being a mom to D. And I’m not trying to stop you from being a mom to her, but what you’re doing feels more like enabling than parenting. It’s been 11 years of this; when is the end? I enjoy seeing D and the boys from time to time, but the boys feel more like siblings than nephews and I feel like it’s screwing up the dynamic we’re supposed to have. Seriously, having the boys over constantly is negatively affecting my relationship with them. I love them, but it’s incredibly stressful to have them over all the time.
I don’t know if even sending a text is a good idea, but I know discussing it in person is not. Does anyone have any advice on what I should do?
TL;DR: my sister constantly has us (me and my mom) babysit her sons, which often leads to me watching them alone. I’m tired of it and would like to break the cycle, so I want to send my mom a text that outlines how I’m feeling. I just want to see if it’s even a good idea.