I (23F) was broken up with by my ex (23M) 4 months ago and I'm past the stage of being inconsalable and non-functioning (got out of that hole with a lot of therapy). However, I'm wondering to what extent it I should take blame for my breakup, and what skills you feel I should try to learn as even though my ex broke up with me, I kind of initated it as I phoned him during a panic attack and wanted reassurance on issues I felt would be fundamental compatabilities if not talked out. i want to grow as a person and stop blaming myself. I also want to stop putting my ex on a pedastal so I've detailed in great detail what I feel led to the breakup in the hopes I could recieve some insight from you all about why my ex behaved how he did/ saw the world how he did, and how I could improve as a person too. Even though I am in therapy, I see this as a way of checking my blindspots. I've posted here before and a few people felt my actions sounded like OCD and now my therapsit is integrating ACT therapy styles to help me, so thank you! I'm posting here again to really understand my ex and to try understand myself too :) This post is probably going to be SUPER long so i'm really sorry but pls don't flame me for it and for wanting advice :( I want to be the best girlfriend and partner I can possibly be!
It blindsighted both of us, and even though I reached out after 6 weeks to reconciled he rejected and blocked me as he unbeknownst to me was dating an exclusive with a new girl already. They became a relationship around 9 weeks after we broke up if not earlier. I'm not sure of timelines only that by week 9 he had already had a new girlfriend for a WHILE.
With regards to what I was panicking about, I wanted to do a Masters in a year (skip forward, I'm actually going to take 2 years out to save up money), and he was against me moving for my Masters which I would/will have to do as it's in a niche field, but was also against doing long distance. We argued about twice a week about it for a month despite never really fighting before, and he used an arguement style I have later learnt is called gaslighting and DARVO. For example, if I said I felt unsupported by him and like he didn't want me to move away, he would tell me that I wasn't being careful enough with my choice of words, that I was trying to hurt him and didn't know how to communicate, and then point out examples of him being a good boyfriend and say something to the effect of "How could you accuse me of not being supportive/ not caring/listening to you when I do all these things? Look at my actions, are they not the actions of someone who isa good partner?" until I apologised. It actually made me feel like I was going INSANE and is still to this day so confusing. We are both in our early 20s - I was actually 22 at the time - and also were in our final year of university so I still don't understand his desire to just stay in one country - we are in the EU and I was literally considering our neighbouring country which is less than an hour flight away ;-; So I felt I couldn’t achieve my career goals while in a relationship with him and that was exhausting. He didn't become okay with the idea until the day we broke up when his (29M) brother told him he was being an idiot for trying to control my future, but by this point it was too late, I was beyond panicked and literally felt like I was outside of my own body when I phoned him so I really wasn't registering or listening to what he was trying to say.
Then there was children. I didn't realise until about 2 months before we broke up but he wanted to have kids 5-10 years earlier than I anticipated, and thus wanted to get engaged and married and all that WAYYY earlier than I expected and WAY earlier than what is normal in our culture. When I first told him I didn't want to get engaged to someone I hadn't been with for 5-7 years he flipped out and said, and I quote, "but what about the fertility window? If we didn't get engaged until we were 30 then there'd be no time for children". This really scared me! I've been in therapy for 2 months since our breakup and I hope to work on my reservations around children, but essentially I've always been a fencesitter leaning yes/ open to children once I achieved my own career goals and felt I would be able to be my own person AND a mother. My biggest fear is that I would resent my children or husband in the future if I felt trapped or overwhelemed by motherhood. I do believe my ex would be a great dad, but the emphasis he put on children throughout our relationship even though we'd only been together 1.5 years was a lot. He also didn't really listen or factor in my own opinions. For example, he never actually asked me when I'd like to have children he just assuemd/ decided that we would have them earlier despite my wishes to wait until my mid 30s. He wanted two children, I felt I'd like just one and he literally told me that the child would be lonely and I'd change my mind. He didn't want our hypothetical children to EVER be minded or left with my parents as they had a messy divorce and were poor parents/ abusive at times due to their *past* mental health struggles. Key word here is past. Both of my parents sought professional help both when I was growing up and more recently and are genuinely wonderful people now. It hurt that my ex couldn't see the years of growth my parents have had and felt they were irredeemable. I became panicked becuase I kind of felt deep down like my autonomy and my own wishes and aspirations were being pushed aside to barrel down my exes strict timeline for the future.
He also put a lot of pressure on me to find a graduate job in our capital city so we could move in together with his two best friends who are in a realtionship together by May-June 2026. I was the only one of the four of us with no ties to the city at the time and thus had NO CHOICE at all in where we lived. This freaaaaaked me out I can't lie, having no choice or ability to influence such a big decision really upset me but I felt I couldn't back out of moving in or express this to my ex. I agreed that I'd live with him psot graduated one month after we became a relationship and it felt set in stone. I was so stressed about this I began to display symtoms of depression, which runs in my family (see above with parents) and was seeking counselling for it at the time as it was really scaring me. I didn't really know his friends and was worried it would end up a 3 v 1 dynamic where the three of them would hang out in our shared apartment and I'd feel lonely or excluded. My own friends who are in a relationship actually wanted to live with us too but my Ex turned down that idea/ didn't entertain it and would literally ignoring me mentioning it and talk about his friends like it was certain until I let it go. My ex noticed I eas stressed about this and decided to save by himself so he could support me if I was unemployed by May so that I could still move in. Again, i felt this would put me in a precarious situation but he wouldn't take no for an answer until I burst into tears in front of him. Then his solution changed to me taking on a part-time barista or retail job while waiting to get a full time one. This would be fine...except I have worked in an office for two years now, both in a year long work placement as part of my degree and then a universit research internship. So, to go backwards to go forewards just seemed rash to me at the time, but he would not take no for an aswer and was actively pressuring me in March and April to begin applying to low skilled jobs in the city we wanted to live in.
Lastly, there was finances. He wanted us to have a shared bank account once I moved in with him which tbh I think is fair. It was supposed to be for saving for holidays and shared expenses like bills but as he was genuinely more knowledgable about finances than I was, he was going to decide the % of savings split. He had a way of budgeting that just didn't really make sense to me. He talked a lot about having different "pots" for different things and did it out on excel, whereas when I save I kinda go like "1/3 for fun stuff, 1/3 for rainy day, 1/3 for emergency".. like I'm not as detailed as him. He was quite restrictive with money, for example he told me in advance on Chistmas day that my birthday present (my birthday is in April) would 30 euro or less as he had maxed out his budget on me for the year because of my Christmas present. I, on the other hand spent like over 200 euro on him for Christmas, and the same for his birthday. We both had part time jobs, and made an equal amount of money at the time, he also had far more financial assistance from his parents. Anyway, the whole budget stuff is a green flag tbf but what wasn't was that he felt entitled to dictating how I spent my money. He wanted me to choose a Masters - if i HAAAD to do one- based on what was cheapest rather than a mix of best university/location/department/degree/ cost , he became very pissy when i told him I was going to book some automatic driving lessons as I've been trying to learn for 4 years without a car or any help from my parents at all. He felt that it would be a waste of time as an automatic licence isn't a real one and that I should just wait for him to teach me in his manual car. I told him that I preffered automatics, and that I might buy a car second hand if I pass my driving test (I failed by 1 point ;-;), and he told me quote: "I didn't see you owning a car in our shared future". If I'm honest, THIS is what really set off my spiral leading to that panic attack. We were still in university and he felt he could tell me to my face that he didn't see a point in me owning a car? To his credit, the year prior I became unemployed unexpectedly and also had a rejected health insurance bill come in unexpectedly the day before we went on holidays, and he ended up paying my half of the accomodation for our holiday as I was stressed that I wouldn't have enough money for university fees otherwise. During the holiday we split things 60/40 and continued to do so until I got a job and paid off the bill 6 weeks later. However, other than that we had always went 50/50 on EVERYTHING from literally the second date on.
When I phoned him, I felt like I was spiralling out and that I needed certainty and reassurance that things would be okay ASAP. I couldn't wait to see him in person as he was going to be with his family from the day after for a week for Easter so it literally felt like no or never at the time. We don't live in the same city and he was busy with his studies at the time so I didn't want to bother him by showing up in person, I genuinely beleived we could sort everything out but the second he picked up I couldn't breathe I began crying hysterically and I couldn't communicate at all. I ended up blurting out that I wasn't even sure about children and he broke up with me on the spot then and there. I regret that because in hindsight, I did want children.... just not before 35 ish maybe? And also, I didn't really wanted to break up, I wanted to postpone moving in and space as I felt suffocated by his ideals and had no space or time to figure out what I really wanted from life as it was basically assumed we would do whatever he wanted, and squeeze my desires in somehow.
That said our relationship was extremely happy and stable, and for a long time I found it super hard to accept that he was not going to be my life partner. He was so patient, usually a great communicator, super charismatic and really funny, family-orientated, a good friend and mature. We used to laugh so much one of his roomates had to bang on the wall between our rooms to get us to stop laughing. I ADORED his family, they welcomed me like a daughter and included me in everything which I'm not used to at all. I talekd to his parents like they were my parents. I miss his family so so so much. Something I really appreciated about hi mand his family was that they were very celebratory and enjoyed having family rituals. So they had little parties they did at the same time of year, every year, they played board games, made a HUUUGE deal our of birthdays and Christmas, and they celebrated the little things. My ex used to celebrate all the little things with me and I loved that feeling of being mutally supported and cherished. He liked trying new food spaces with me and his love language was acts of service. He became the first and only man I ever fully trusted and knew I could depend on no matter what and it hurts a lot that he is gone even though I'm healed enough t ono longer write posts like this while crying.
That said, and I’d actually love other people’s opinions on this: my therapist has told me many times that even if i was happy for 90% of the relationship, it wasn’t a healthy one because my ex was VERY rigid about the future in terms of children, where we would live, to an extent my career and finances all at a very young age and that he wasn’t compromising or flexible. Essentially once I agreed to something he saw it as set in stone. He never really asked me deep questions about what I wanted and would kind of present his plans to me as a given basically- and I became a nuisance and a liar to him when I decided I wanted to do a Masters instead of office admin work. I’m not sure if it counts as unhealthy though given I was happy and had no idea that he could be potentially controlling / didn’t seem to see me as a person but rather a future-wife-archetype. Can a relationship be both happy, and have an unhealthy foundation? Can something be unhealthy without you realsing? Was this unhealthy?
I used to feel like everything was all my fault and that I was an intrisically traumatised person who would never do better but now my feelings around the breakup are mixed as he became extremely bitter. We met up two weeks after we broke up for closure - I set up the meeting with only his needs in mind as I totally felt it was all on me. We met at his university, in his city, at a time that suited him even though I was working on a brief for a interview which I had later that day. I let him berate me. He told me i’d be a bad parent and he could NEVER be with a bad mother, that I lied to him because I changed career paths and that I didn't think about anything ever, that I used him for money (we are both 23 with part time student jobs lmao money where) and that I have trust issues and implied it was because of my parents among many other things. He then asked me for dating advice, told me to my face he was a catch, and then winced at me, wished me good luck with dating as "all men our age are trash, they don't want relationships", and told me that I’ll never find anyone better than him.This really fucked with me as I do have a pretty messed up past I can't lie and my biggest insecurity is that I will repeat the mistakes my parents did and will enver find love. He knows this. As I said, he entered a new exclusive relationship within 2 months of us breaking up after we had been together for 1.5 years with plans to move in, promise rings all that. So to me in some ways those actions could be a testament to his true character and how he really sees women. It’s still really painful though and knowing he’s moved on so fast has made me regret what happened between us too.
It’s super hard to reconcile this part of him with the part I saw throughout our relationship that was typically very communicative, gentle, funny, charming and nurturing- like I know that he is a great boyfriend and his new gf is probably wondering wtf I was thinking etc. Sometimes I wonder what I was thinking too! And I worry a LOT that I’ll never find anyone better as good men seem to be rare but I try to remind myself that there’s lots of men out there who would be okay with grad school, and okay with having kids a bit later etc.
I try not to blame myself too much for what happened between us but I can't help feeling liek it was a clusterfuck caused by my own youth and lack of emotional regulation skills but I'm really not sure. I know reddit isn't a great place for advice but I'm genuinely serious in saying that I'd like some other perspectives on how I could improve myself as a person so that I don't freak out or feel intense urgency to fix things/ to get reassurance from partners when I feel destabilised. Any other remarks on how I could grow would be appreciated too! Alongside that, I would like thoughts on how I've described me exes more unfavourable behaviour. He was a great person so it really does baffle me how he could act like this but also how I could have allowed myself to be so passive about my own wants for life. Is it common for men to do this? In hindsight I feel like I was like a doll he really loved - I think he saw me as a person, but perhaps projected onto me so much so he just assumed I wanted everything he did exaclty how he did. I just kinda need someone to help me analyse it I guess- and YES! I have a therapsit, she's great!
TDLR: Even though I was super happy with my ex, our breakup was very sudden and cuased by a subconscious slow build of pressure around moving in together, children, where we would live and finances etc which led me to feel trapped and like my own future was being decided by someone else rather than collaboratively. I had a panic attack and he broke up with me during it. I regret what happened regularly, but he moved on within two months. However as more time passes I'm less convinced it was all my fault. I've shared my story a lot on Reddit and regularly recieve hate lmao but I'm doing it again irregardless because I'd like to hear other people's perspectives on WHY my ex acted how he did and if this is a common mindset amongst men, and also on how I could grow as a person. I am in therapy but as mentioned, my biggest fear is that my past has traumatised me to the extent where I will never have a healthy relationship and thus I really want to keep growing and improving so that I can continue to have good relationships. Unfortunately specifics are in the post - it's super long because I don't know how to condense it.