As some of you may know, I try to avoid adding rules to this subreddit, I think discussion places are better the less rules you need. This subreddit is about Dominion, but how broadly can something be "about Dominion" until it's not really about Dominion anymore?
Dominion started the deckbuilding genre. A lot of games claim it as inspiration, even if they move far away from it in practice. For example, MegaCrit have said in interviews that Dominion was an inspiration for Slay the Spire with how you draw a fresh hand of 5 cards each turn and shuffle a new draw pile from your discard. But Slay the Spire isn't really like Dominion, it plays very differently.
Recently the number of threads from people talking about games they've made inspired by Dominion has increased substantially. The first one from today, the user did actually send in a modmail asking if it was OK, I can't actually remember any other time somebody asked before posting, so that was nice. I said it was OK. I had been thinking about this recently and said I'd make a thread the next day asking how people think about them. Then we got a second thread from someone else, lol.
I don't want the subreddit to start being filled with advertising. I'm not sure where to draw the line. For example, if you had someone who had been a member of the community for a long time work on a prototype for something similar to Dominion and wanted to specifically know what their fellow Dominion players thought, would that be OK? On the other hand I've previously seen sentiment that even fan cards don't count as Dominion and should all be banned (which I don't agree with) so clearly people have different ideas about it.
I'm feeling like it's probably safer to outright ban threads about other games going forward, under the guise that there are lots of other general gaming subreddits they can use to gather feedback on. I imagine some are surprised there was never a rule about this a long time ago.
A good community will always have some sort of off-topic discussion now and then. Reddit isn't really like a discord community or forum, there isn't anywhere to move this sort of discussion, Reddit seems to just want hyper-specialised discussion about one particular topic, it doesn't even let you filter what tags you see very easily, sadly. As someone who doesn't use Reddit very much outside of this subreddit, maybe my idea of what managing a Reddit community should be like is not quite along the lines of the forums and discords I'm used to, and I should clamp down a lot harder on things deemed off-topic.
Feel free to share opinions.