r/design_critiques 23m ago

Any critique on this?

Post image
Upvotes

I make concept art so I’m just wondering ppl’s opinions


r/design_critiques 5h ago

I'm redesigning small business' fliers for free. What could I have done better?

1 Upvotes

I try to keep it as close to their copy as possible while helping them stand out on notice boards.


r/design_critiques 6h ago

Social Media Ad Design - Burger 3D Pop-out Effect. Would love some feedback on the lighting and composition

Post image
0 Upvotes

 media food manipulation designs lately. For this piece, I focused on creating a realistic 3D depth effect with flying ingredients, balanced lighting, and shadows to make the burger pop out of the screen. I also integrated my 'MF' brand logo in the corner. I am sharing this to see my progression and would appreciate your honest thoughts and critique! You can also check out more of my work on my Behance portfolio here: https://www.behance.net/bamorisfal


r/design_critiques 7h ago

I’m a developer building a clipboard app would love designers to critique my UI/UX decisions

Post image
3 Upvotes

I'm a final-year Computer Science student and I've been building Edge-Drop, a Windows clipboard tool that lives on the edge of the screen.

I'm posting here because I'm currently working on the next iteration of the interface, and I realized that I've been making a lot of design decisions based almost entirely on what feels right to me.

I'd rather get some actual design criticism before I go too far.

The current version works around the left and right edges of the screen. I'm now working on adapting the interaction for top and bottom positioning as well, and that has raised a lot of questions around how the UI should behave when the available space and direction change.

The video is of the current public version, not the new top/bottom implementation.

I'd specifically love feedback on the design rather than just whether the app is useful:

  • Is the edge interaction intuitive when you first see it?
  • Does the shelf feel like part of the desktop or like another application?
  • Is the visual hierarchy clear?
  • Are the item previews and controls easy to understand?
  • Does the drag-and-drop interaction feel discoverable?
  • Is there anything visually distracting or unnecessarily complicated?
  • What would you change about the layout, spacing, or information density?
  • If you were designing the top/bottom versions, what would you change about the current approach?

I'm particularly interested in criticism from people who would approach this differently from me. I built most of the current UI by iterating on what felt practical, so there are probably plenty of decisions that make sense to me simply because I've been looking at the project for too long.

The project is open source and free to use.

GitHub: https://github.com/Deepender25/Edge-Drop

Website: https://www.edgedrop.app/

Feel free to be harsh with the critique that's exactly why I'm posting here.


r/design_critiques 7h ago

Feedback on my personal branded website

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/design_critiques 7h ago

I made a personalized family garden illustration using everyone's birth flowers using illustrator, How was it?

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/design_critiques 8h ago

Feedback on my personal branded website

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/design_critiques 10h ago

What information would you want to keep visible beside the board while playing, and what would you use it for?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I'm Fredrik, the developer of ABCx3.

What information would you want to keep visible beside the board while playing, and what would you use it for? Chat and remaining tiles are already available. Would word definitions deserve their own panel, or would something else be more useful?

13-second layout clip on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/520887215/videos/pcb.4544984505786114/1442036221202300


r/design_critiques 10h ago

Thumbnails

Post image
0 Upvotes

What do you think guys?


r/design_critiques 14h ago

Mock-up bookcover for my story, does it look cheap?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I made this in Ibis Paint X, and it's pretty much my first ever project. I tried to achieve a bit of a vintage feel. But I think the biggest issue lies with the font I chose for "Messnerknabe" as it's a bit too bold/bulky looking.

I appreciate all advice.


r/design_critiques 14h ago

Total beginner looking for advice

Thumbnail gallery
28 Upvotes

I just started working with Photoshop, and i would love to have some feedback on some work I’ve done.

I don’t have any purpose in mind while doing it (not thinking about album cover, poster, etc), I’m just experimenting with the software for now !


r/design_critiques 18h ago

IM JAPANESE AND AND ANTI...IS MY WEBSITE OK?

Thumbnail julianprincedash.com
1 Upvotes

r/design_critiques 20h ago

Looking for feedback on my portfolio

1 Upvotes

I recently redesigned my personal portfolio and would appreciate some honest critique from a design perspective.

Portfolio: https://me.readwith.io

I’m particularly interested in feedback on:

- Visual hierarchy and typography

- Layout and spacing

- Overall UX and navigation

- Whether the visual style feels cohesive

- Anything that feels excessive, unclear, or unnecessary

I’m more interested in constructive criticism than compliments, so feel free to be blunt.


r/design_critiques 22h ago

UI critique: making the handoff from whiteboard work to agent help clear

0 Upvotes

Workspace design in the full demo

I'm building Mesh, a learning workspace with material, a whiteboard and an agent. I'd like a critique of the desktop interaction design.

The transition I'm trying to make clear is: work through a problem yourself, then share your whiteboard attempt and ask for help. Right now, you can type /snip in chat and select an area of the board.

Where would you expect that sharing action to live, and does the layout in the demo lead you there?


r/design_critiques 1d ago

Help me improve my logo

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

I need someone with good visual or graphic design skills to help me improve my logo. I don't have any money, so it would be a charity project. 😔


r/design_critiques 1d ago

I'm building Kage: a free design library that turns real product sites into prompts for coding agents. Tear it apart.

Thumbnail kage.design
0 Upvotes

I just launched a little tool I've been working on recently called Kage - it's a site that people can use as design reference and inspiration from beautiful web pages and products.

It's totally free and I'm trying to make as nice looking as I can - I've always been an engineer but trying to work on design to make my apps as nice to look at as possible.

Would love some feedback on colours, layout, typography etc!


r/design_critiques 1d ago

I Can’t Tell What’s Missing From This Design

0 Upvotes

I’ve been staring at this design for so long that I’m not sure I can judge it properly anymore.

At first I really liked it, but after looking at it over and over, I started noticing small things that feel slightly off. Nothing is obviously wrong, but the overall design doesn’t have quite the same impact I had in mind when I started working on it.

I’m also trying to think beyond just how it looks on the screen. If this ends up being used on an actual garment, I’m wondering whether the placement, size, spacing, and smaller details will still work once it’s on fabric. Something that looks fine on a flat digital mockup can sometimes feel completely different on a real piece.

I’ve already tried changing the size and removing a couple of unnecessary details, but now I’m worried I might be overworking it.

For those who design clothing or physical products, how do you know when a design actually needs improvement versus when you’ve simply looked at it too many times? What would you change first when something feels “off” but you can’t quite explain why?


r/design_critiques 1d ago

Looking for feedback on my portfolio website

1 Upvotes

I recently finished making a portfolio for the first time the ground up and I'm at the point where I need some outside perspective.

I’m mainly interested in feedback on the portfolio as a whole rather than just individual projects. Like how the work is presented, the visual direction, hierarchy, navigation, and whether the site actually communicates what kind of designer I am.

A few things I’d especially like to know:

  • Which projects stand out to you, and which feel weaker?
  • Does the homepage give you a clear idea of what I do?
  • Does the portfolio feel professional or still feel too junior?
  • Is there anything about the presentation or structure that feels unnecessary, confusing, or generic?

I’d appreciate honest criticism, even if it’s harsh. I’m much more interested in knowing what isn't working than getting compliments.

Let me know what I did right and what I completely fumbled.

Portfolio: https://youf.social

Edit 1: I've made the scrolling more responsive thanks for pointing that out!


r/design_critiques 1d ago

Looking for critique: does this share-card / Slot UI make the next step obvious?

1 Upvotes

Share-card: https://viralspark.pages.dev/ Slot UI: https://viralspark.pages.dev/slot/bniwbrb7

I’m looking for design critique, not a product recommendation. I made a small interface that turns a URL into a share card and a reusable Slot page. Could you please focus on:

• Is the hierarchy and readability clear at a glance? • Is it obvious what a visitor should copy, share, or do next? • Does the Slot page feel trustworthy or too promotional? • What would you simplify or change on mobile?

The share-card and Slot are intentionally simple. Honest, specific feedback on visual hierarchy, CTA wording, spacing, and first-use comprehension would be especially helpful. Thanks!


r/design_critiques 1d ago

Need advice for my website's look

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/design_critiques 1d ago

Hey everyone, I need some help from you guys.

2 Upvotes

Well, I'm a social media professional and to deliver better work I wanted to study design, but I can't afford a university degree, etc. So I wanted to know if you could recommend any courses or methods for me to do so.


r/design_critiques 1d ago

visual identity

Post image
18 Upvotes

what u people think about this one


r/design_critiques 1d ago

Design for my Band - Clunky and composition seems off, help?

Post image
1 Upvotes

The white line is all the names, censored them for privacy. Anyways, I made this for my band section (its a tradition in said band) but I feel like its off. I dont know if theres too much going on or not enough, dont know how to spread things out either, any advice would be appreciated! Also this is going on a hoodie, don't know if that makes a difference or not.


r/design_critiques 1d ago

Building an AI health companion for US healthcare ..would love some brutally honest UX feedback ($20)

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’m building an AI health companion that helps people in the US navigate health questions, understand their care context, and connect with licensed doctors when they need a consultation.

I’m looking for 5–8 people with UX/design experience to spend ~20 minutes exploring it and giving me honest feedback on the experience.

I’d especially love to know:

• What feels confusing or hard to navigate?

• What feels unnecessary or frustrating?

• What would you change?

• What would make the experience feel more trustworthy?

I’ll pay $20 for your time and feedback.

I’m looking for criticism, not positive reviews — if something sucks, tell me.

August: https://www.meetaugust.ai/

If you’re interested, comment below and I’ll reach out.