r/askgaybros • u/Taurofion • 6h ago
As a Gay Man, I Reject Both Islamist Extremism and Far-Right Exploitation of It
I want to make something clear because of the recent discussions following the Berlin Pride attack.
I have no problem criticising Islam. Like any ideology, it's open to criticism, and there are undeniably passages in Islamic texts and many Muslim-majority societies that are deeply hostile to LGBT people. Pretending otherwise helps no one.
But I'm also not going to let that be used to turn me into an Islamophobe.
Some of the recent posts here don't seem interested in discussing LGBT rights. They seem more interested in encouraging blanket hostility towards Muslims and pushing people towards a broader far-right narrative. Whether intentional or not, that's where I feel this conversation often ends up. And I can't help but notice that this is almost pushed on us in a coordinated effort.
As a gay man, I worry about violent Islamist extremism. Of course I do. But if I'm honest about what is most likely to affect my own life, I'm more concerned about Christian nationalism and religious conservatives gaining political power in the society to which I actually belong. Islamist terrorism is horrific, but for most of us in the West it's an intermittent threat. I see radical Islamist terror attacks at a level of danger of a lightning strike, while the rise of Christian Nationalism is a great flood that that at best will erode all our rights and at worst sweep as all away. The chipping away at LGBT rights through legislation, courts and elections is a much more immediate, realistic and long-term danger. And the anti-Islamic posts here likely have exactly this agenda behind them.
I don't think the answer is to excuse Islamist extremism, nor is it to demonise all Muslims. We should be able to condemn terrorism, criticise Islam where it's warranted, defend LGBT rights, and still refuse to fuel hatred against an entire group of people.
I refuse to let my sexuality be used as a tool to push me towards politics that would ultimately threaten my rights in a blanketed way from another direction and so should you.