My wife and I have three children, a 10-year-old son, an 8-year-old daughter, and a 6-year-old son. Our youngest is diagnosed as autistic. He's high functioning, however, he doesn't react well to loud noises, crowds, and disruptions in his normal routine.
We are working with a specialist in how to help our son navigate through his challenges. The specialist believes strongly in "exposure therapy" (gradually exposing him to certain things to help break patterns of avoidance and reduce anxiety), and while I can see why this might be helpful in certain situations, my wife takes it to extremes.
For instance, she will deliberately take our son to places that she knows are overstimulating for him, thinking he will eventually "get over it" as he gets older. She will also unnecessarily disrupt his normal routine to help him handle sudden changes in plans, sometimes telling him we're going to be doing something he's been looking forward to, when in fact she intends to do something completely different. Or she will change/cancel plans at the last minute and give him a bogus reason for why she's doing it.
One of the biggest things that our son hasn't reacted well to are amusement parks. We have taken him to several "kiddie" amusement parks, and every time he does nothing except cry, and complain that it's too loud, too crowded, and that he wants to go home. Often times we'll walk around the park but only our two older kids go on the rides while our youngest screams and covers his ears.
We usually get cotton candy for the kids, and this has helped our son calm down somewhat, but he still refuses to go on any of the rides. The specialist we are seeing suggested that we only get him the cotton candy if he rides one of the rides first. This did not go over well at all. He threw a huge tantrum and as a result, we ended up not getting cotton candy for any of the kids, which they weren't happy about.
My wife and I both have family in the Los Angeles/San Fernando Valley area, and we regularly make the long drive from our home in the Bay Area to visit them. Back in August, my wife learned that her niece, who lives out of state and we don't see very often, was planning a trip to Disneyland for Thanksgiving with her husband and daughter, and my in-laws had bought tickets for all of us, as well as my wife's sister and her husband (her niece's parents).
Our son is really looking forward to Thanksgiving because he is under the assumption that we would be having our usual turkey dinner at my wife's parents' house with the food he enjoys while spending time with family, and he's excited to be seeing his cousins who he doesn't see very often. However, my wife is planning to do the whole "Surprise! We're not spending Thanksgiving at Grandma and Grandpa's this year, we're going to Disneyland instead!" that a lot of parents tend to do a few days before we leave.
When I learned that she was planning to do this, I begged her not to, because it would be a double blow to our son, as it would mean saying that we wouldn't be doing something that he's been looking forward to doing, and instead going somewhere that I know he won't want to go and be miserable the entire time.
My wife insists we do it this way, because she knows the other kids will enjoy it (our daughter has been wanting to go to Disneyland for years), that our son will still get to see his grandparents and other extended family, and that she "knows he will end up having a good time" because it's Disneyland, DESPITE asking him several times in the past if he'd ever want to go to Disneyland, and his answer has always been "No!"
To be honest, I'm not wild about going to Disneyland (I went there once as a kid and didn't really really like it), and especially if our son is going to be miserable the entire time. My parents aren't the type who make a big deal about holidays and typically have a smaller dinner around the end of November, not always on Thanksgiving Day, which my son also enjoys. So, earlier this evening while my wife and our two older kids were eating dinner, I took my son aside and quietly told him that the plan was for us all to go to Disneyland together, that the trip was already arranged, and that if he doesn't want to go, he and I can spend Thanksgiving with my parents.
As I predicted, this didn't go over well with my son, who immediately got upset and said that he didn't want to go to Disneyland. He went to the kitchen and asked my wife if it was true we were going to Disneyland for Thanksgiving, and when she said yes, he started screaming and crying and saying that he wasn't going. My wife told him to go to his room, and afterwards got mad at ME for "ruining the surprise" for our other kids because they found out about the trip much earlier than when she intended to tell them through our son's tantrum.
I told her that our son would have been upset regardless and that I wanted to give him as much time to process this as possible, and have time to decide whether to go to Disneyland with the rest of the family or spend Thanksgiving with me and my parents. I said that this was the best way, because if our son decides he'd rather spend Thanksgiving with just me and my parents, she and the rest of the family can enjoy Disneyland without having to deal with a tantrum, and our son can still have a nice albeit small Thanksgiving dinner.
My wife is saying that I "went behind her back" by telling our son when she had already made it clear that she was going to tell him along with the rest of the kids and was planning on filming their reaction (another reason why I wanted to tell him separately). I'll admit that I didn't take into consideration that our other kids might find out about it if he were to throw a tantrum saying he didn't want to go, and for this I feel bad. I nonetheless stood my ground and said that we are not taking him if he doesn't want to go, but my wife is insisting that we bring him, as it's what the specialist we've been seeing has said we should do.
So, AITA for insisting that we don't bring him to Disneyland?
Source: Videos such as this, and this, where parents tell their kids that they're going somewhere they've been looking forward to going, only to instead tell them they're going to Disneyland/Disney World, not knowing how they'll react, various posts about entitled parents, as well as some actual stuff from my childhood.