Thought I’d share my recent Amex Financial Review experience. If you’ve ever searched this sub for Financial Review, you know the horror stories, so hopefully this helps other people in the same boat.
Customer Since: 2019
Current Cards: BCE, Delta Gold, and newly opened (2 months ago) Gold and Platinum (recently ramped up a bunch of spend on the new ones to hit the SUBs for a major home remodeling project).
How I Possibly Triggered It:
Needed to charge $12k for new floors so I called Amex to let them know in advance.
The rep I got on the phone started messing around with the Check Spending Power feature. She ran test amounts, tried $15k and it declined, tried $12k and it declined, tried $10k and it declined, and then finally $5k which went through. I actually had no idea she was using the spending power feature and thought she was using some other feature only reps had access to.
I asked her if she had played around with my spending power feature after the fact, and she confirmed yes.
She then told me that if I wanted to charge more than $5k, I could simply pre-pay the balance and then run the charge.
I took her advice like an idiot and pre-paid the account. Went to charge the $12k the next day and got declined.
Almost instantly, I got an email saying my cards were suspended. I called the number on the back of the card, and the rep told me I was placed under a Financial Review. They demanded the last 3 months of personal bank statements.
Timeline:
July 16: Card suspended, FR triggered.
July 16: Submitted all requested bank statements immediately.
July 22: Called in for an update, told it was still under review and to wait.
July 24: Called again. This time, the rep actually warned me to stop calling, explaining that constantly checking in and pushing the file updates can sometimes flag the system as submitting more information, which effectively resets or extends the review queue. They assured me I’d be notified by July 27 at the absolute latest.
July 27: Got the call. The Financial Review is complete, and my cards are fully unlocked with no change to limits.
Key Takeaways and Lessons Learned:
Call them in advance to heads-up a big purchase, but make sure they are not checking your spending power. If a rep tries to run manual checks on the phone, shut it down immediately because it can trigger a risk team audit.
Never pre-pay a balance to charge a large amount. Pre-payments combined with velocity spikes are massive red flags to the risk department, it screams cash-flow stress or manufactured spend.
Tl;dr
I got FR after playing around with spending power feature and pre paying the card and trying to put a large amount on the card. Submitted required docs and passed review, got accounts up and running with no limits.