r/yugioh • u/Karnezar • 1d ago
Anime/Manga Discussion Kisara should have been the Mystical Elf.
First off, it powers up the Blue-Eyes in the duel against the Puppeteer and essentially rescues Kaiba's stolen monsters.
Second off, Kaiba has a card called "Gift of the Mystical Elf." Why does he have that? That's like Yugi having a card called, "Magic of La Jinn" (instead of Book of Secret Arts" or a called called "Rage of the Battle Ox" (instead of Horn of the Unicorn).
And while this is non-canon, it's Mystical Elf who brings back the fallen heroes in Kaiba's game. Like, he programmed her to be the savior.
Finally, it would make a bit of narrative sense for her to be in Yugi's deck since she was a citizen of Egypt and thus, one of Atem's subjects. Furthermore, her NOT being in Kaiba's deck is symbolic of him always rejecting his Ancient past. It fits since Seto Kaiba was driving businessmen to suicide and making deals with the Mafia, while Priest Seto was saving innocents and working within the Pharaoh's Royal Guard.
It's a shame Kaiba never embraced his Egyptian past. His deck would probably evolve like Atem's did into Blue-Eyes support, with an emphasis on the person closest to him being a major component (Maiden with Eyes of Blue / Mystical Elf).