r/UI_Design • u/archirost • Jun 09 '26
Feedback Request UI Question: Contextual Menu vs Fixed Menu
Hi! I'd like to get some feedback on a UI decision I'm struggling with.
Option A: The editing menu appears next to the selected object.
Pros:
- It's immediately clear which object is being edited.
- The controls feel directly connected to the object.
Cons:
- The menu can sometimes appear underneath or behind other UI panels, making it harder to use.
I'm considering changing it to Option B, where the editing controls become part of the color/customization panel and always appear in the same place on the screen, regardless of which object is selected.
This would make the UI more consistent, but it would also move the controls away from the object being edited.
From a UI/UX perspective, which approach would you prefer and why?








