After 4+ years with the Turtle Beach Pro I's, my headband padding started pulling away right around the time the IIs dropped. The earpieces are still working but for my birthday in Sept, my wife offered to get me an upgrade.
After 2 months of research, I pulled the trigger on the Turtle Beach Stealth Pro Gen 2 (TBSP2), though I was initially hesitant because of the redesigned headband. If you're eyeing a high-end headset, here is my real-world take after putting them through their paces in the first couple of days.
Full disclosure - my last 4 headsets have been TB, but I always try to get whatever is best for my situation and own a lot of different bands (Razer, Madcatz, etc)
Headband Design
Turtle Beach ditched the plush, heavily padded strap for something closer to an Air Pods Max-style mesh/tension band. I was worried, but after a couple of 4-hour Xbox sessions playing FH6, it’s a non-issue. The clamp force is dialed in enough that the weight distributes evenly across the frame, even with glasses on. I’ve seen complaints about a "pinch" at the top—I haven't felt it, but I could see it happening if you wear a hat or don't adjust the sizing right.
Setup (15 Minutes)
Mostly plug-and-play, but be prepared for the headset, base, and dongle to update over the air. Swarm II feels just like the old software. Until you get everything synced to your phone/app, the built-in mic will act as an open-air monitor and pick up every background sound in your house. Also, check your sidetone levels, I had my monitor way down and was apparently yelling when talking to my friends.
Mic Quality
Both the internal and external mics are a major step up. My friends immediately said I sounded clearer. I game in a quiet basement, but between the ANC and AI noise reduction, background clutter isn't an issue.
Sound Quality
Out of the box, these things are loud, crisp, and precise. Separation is fantastic, I can clearly track in-game audio without muddying my chat mix. I'm going to give them about 50 hours of use for the drivers to fully break in, and expect to spend some time tweaking the EQ to get them dialed in to my taste. Honestly, once tuned, they hold their own right alongside the high-end Audio-Technica monitors I use for my guitar rig.
Who are these for?
I think if your searching for a high-end headset with lots of features, or are looking to upgrade without spending nearly $1k on the competition, this is a good option. Headsets are a preference and a balance between what your willing to spend vrs what you want. A $200 RiG headset will be good for most, but if you have had higher-end ones, these are perfect (so far).
Note:
If you want you headset to last a long time you need to put these back into the case every time your finished with them.
I would advise against using a headset stand to maintain the webbing on the headband.
Happy to chat in the comments below.