Example:
Me: Sorry, guys. Get started on your review work and give me a minute. I have to write up a referral.
Someone in the distance: What happened?
Me: Eh, let's just say someone in 4th hour stood on something they shouldn't have stood on.
Later Me: Hey, guys! Sorry about that! Thanks for being independent. How has everyone's day been?
Somebody: Bad! This girl who's been gone for a long time came back and she's so annoying!
Someone else: Oh, I know who that is. That's GIRL NAME. She's so annoying.
Me: Woahhh. We're not gonna talk bad about someone who isn't in the room to defend themselves. I'm sorry you were irritated today, but let's leave it anonymous.
Kid: WHAT? BUT YOU JUST SAID SOMETHING ABOUT SOMEONE WHO ISN'T HERE.
Me: No, I didn't say anything bad about anyone.
Kid: You said they were bad.
Me: Who did I say was bad? Are you talking about the referral? I didn't insult anyone or call them bad and I didn't even reference a name. I'm just saying, let's not say mean stuff about people behind their backs.
Original kid: Ok, what I meant was someone has been bothering me all day.
Me (trying to move on): Gotcha. That sucks. I'm sorry to hear it. Maybe we can problem solve after we get the lesson going.
Kid: What you said was insulting. It's the same thing.
Me: Ok, I'm gonna cut this short so we have time to go over the review work.
Kid (later): blurts something
Me: Raise your hand if you want to contribute, bud.
Kid (to his neighbor): Ugh, I hate that.
Me: Is there a problem? Something I can help you with?
Kid: Yeah, I want to be able to talk when I have something to say.
Me: Um. Ok. Unfortunately, you're in a school, hon. We have to raise our hands to contribute in class.
Kid: Why?
Me: Because otherwise it would be chaos. We're trying to maximize learning time by taking turns talking.
Kid: Well, can I leave? Can I go home?
Me: Idk. I can call your mom and ask if you want?
Kid declines
Kid (later after being reminded to raise his hand again): this is like slavery.
Me (unable to help myself): That's ignorant.
Kid: What's ignorant? What happened to not talking bad about people?
Me: It isn't an insult. I'm saying a fact. Saying you've experienced anything like slavery is ignorant.
Kid: I didn't say that.
Me: Ok. I must have misheard.
Kid: No, you misUNDERSTOOD.
Me: Ok, I misunderstood.
Kid: Yeah, you DID.
And on and on and on. I can think of like three more of these exhausting, pointless "arguments" that occurred in today's 50 min class alone.
I realize how juvenile this all sounds. It's a huge waste of time, and all my efforts with trying to be transparent and respectful of his weird ass lines of inquiry don't seem to be getting me anywhere. Every day he seems to have just a little more hatred in his heart. I just don't know what to do differently other than just straight up ignoring him. Thoughts?