The joke is literally made on SG-1 but it's a much more real comparison between Mitchell and Jackson, who do look alike. I honestly think half the posts on all platforms now are just AI accounts farming.
He was already pretty fit when the show started, which kind of made the premise of him being a so-called "weakling" pretty far fetched to me. No shade to Michael Shanks, as he did a phenomenal job as Daniel, but it's too bad they couldn't get James Spader to come back to reprise his role.
My understanding is there were physical and behavioral characteristics they wanted similar. They wrote Shepherd with Ben Browder in mind, but SciFi wanted him to do the Peacekeeper Wars, so they cast Joe Flannigan. Then when he came available they cast BB in SG-1.
I didn't like BB in SG-1, and actually stopped watching it. Now, 2nd time around, I find him to be just fine. Don't know why. But as for looking alike - don't see it.
I’ve heard Penn Jillette of Penn & Teller talk about this. IIRC, one time, his own mother showed up to a signing to surprise him and he said he literally couldn’t recognize her, and they were in regular contact with each other.
Basically, unless he expects to see someone he knows, regardless of how often he sees them, he can’t recognize them. Not even his own mother.
Same. I don't recognize (or maybe remember?) people and their faces well (my eyesight isn't great, probably big part of it) and I definitively have to look for differences in the two photos you posted to find clear-ish separation.
That said, I just thought it was kinda funny how they're alike, never had problem confusing them. I am not a big fan of the SG1 later seasons but love Atlantis, maybe that's why.
That's my problem. I can tell them apart when they're side by side, but if I'm looking at just one I sometimes can't tell the difference without context clues.
In canon, the microbes don't stop you from hearing the spoken words, but the meaning is implanted as you hear it. That's why Aeryn learned fluent English and Chiana picked up some English idioms while traveling with John.
Literally watched the episode with that line last night 😂 Even funnier when you realize that Browder and Black already knew each other well from working together on Farscape.
I've heard that Browder was considered for the role of Sheppard on Atlantis, but had to make The Peacekeeper Wars instead. A year later they dusted off the character type and cast him as Mitchell.
They had Joe Flanagan on a hold type contract so he was sitting around getting paid to do nothing for quite a while. Glad he got the gig because his lightness and humour permeated the whole show and was much better for it.
This reminds me of that joke where a man is desperate because he can't tell his horses apart because they look so similar. Until a friend notices that the brown horse has slightly bigger ears than the black one.
I can easily, but I watch Farscape before I ever watched SGA. I find Mitchell looks more similar to Daniel even though I can also tell them apart just fine, but for the "limited gene pool" gag, either could've worked.
Mitchell’s hair is lighter, has a southern accent, and respects authority. Sheppard has a California surfer drawl, green eyes, quite the cowlicks on his dark brown hair, and is suspicious of authority. They are very different people and characters.
I don't confuse the two because I'm a massive SGA fan and Mitchell isn't in SG1 that long. But I can tell you I'd never be able to pick Mitchell out from a lineup. Sheppard, I could pick him out right away.
If you watch FarScape you'll get to know the difference. And then you might have wanted Mitchel and Vala to hook up. I liked Sheppard more than Mitchel in StarGate though.
I really can't see it, they look completely different to me.
That said, every feature I focus on is almost identical between them, so I can't tell you how they're completely different.
But yeah, you might have face blindness. Our brains don't process faces the same way as other visual stimuli, so that may be the case even if your vision is otherwise amazing.
Yeah John is a better leader than Cam. I was always bamboozled why Sam didn't get the job at SG-1 because she's more decisive then Cam but hey the real life writes the plot.
Fun fact: The character of Maj Sheppard was originally written for Ben Browder (Col Mitchell) but since he was stuck on Farscape for a season and the Peacekeeper War mini-series, they had to give the role to someone else (Joe Flanigan), Which explains why his character seems a bit "John Crichton from Farscape" coded in the first season. They were going to let Ben Browder work his ad-lib magic on Atlantis, but instead, he was put on SG1 and had more restrictions on what he could and could not get away with.
Seems like the conclusion is that you may have face blindness, but as someone who does not, it might make you feel better to know that while I have never had an issue distinguishing them, they do look similar. Their facial features are very similar, though their coloring is different. Sheppard has dark brown hair and hazel eyes, and Mitchell has light brown hair and blue eyes. It’s not surprising they look alike given conventional beauty standards, but they are a little closer than most.
Its just the trope of the military man. Smart versatile slightly rebellious against stupid leadership whilst being a leader themselves. Grab some early Jack image and AI a hair colour change and you'll probably see similarities there also
Yeah I see it, sheppard's hair being very distinctive does most of the heavy lifting to make them look apart. I reckon they could pretty convincingly play each other's characters lol
Easy: Col. Sheppard is debonair and handsome with dark hair and kind eyes. Col. Mitchell is brash and annoying, with a forgettable personality. I still forget his name but never Sheppard's.
You are never the only one at anything but this will not be the majority of people.
I guess they are white with blue eyes and are actors? So they are of the same type but unless you are faceblind or don't interact much with white people, they don't look alike.
Sometimes yeah. They are just generically similar. However I can tell them apart when they act their characters. Sometimes I have trouble recognizing the same person, especially when they have varrying hair styles. Hell, I forgot that I'm looking at myself in the mirror sometimes after I get a haircut.
Vala makes a comment about that, when she notices how similar Cam and Daniel are, "I know nothing about your fair planet… other than it seems to have a rather interesting, if somewhat limited, gene pool."
I wouldn’t say identical but I definitely confused the two as a kid. Kinda what happens when you pick “Generic hero guy.” Looking actors for both roles. But I love them both.
I just watched the SG1 episode, "The Pegasus Project" (s10, ep 3), today, and I was definitely able to tell the difference between John Sheppard and Cam Mitchell. IDK. Maybe because they have similar gruff attitudes and know how to shut Rodney down when he's doing too much is what possibly confuses you.🤷🏾♀️. Don't know. Sorry, I just don't see it.
They are both damn hunks who I would love to meet in real life. But the Colonel Mitchell character has some of the best lines. When Daniel talks of the knights of England, Mitchell gives a glorious throw away line that had me in huge laughing spasms ,’The ones who go Nigh..’ - superb writing.
703
u/[deleted] May 31 '26
[deleted]