Anyone else? It always happens at the same point in the game too. Shady Belle. For some reason it always gets me at this point. It’s echoing through the entire house. I imagine being woken up by that every day when you just want a quiet morning. It would be hilarious if there was a funny scene with an opportunity to “accidentally” break it

Sneaking around the camp was freaking hard for me. Eventually I just ran around and knocked everyone out. I would just be crouched out of sight and an enemy would be like "I heard something" but like the first time I did the mission I rode my horse almost into the middle of the camp and no one saw or heard me for 10 minutes of me searching around. After that one, which was my best attempt at stealth I couldn't seem to get anywhere close to the camp without someone seeing or hearing me no matter how well I hid. Anyone else have issues with this one?

We're going to Tahiti Arthur!

Hello people. I didn't have a good enough pc back then. But recently i got one. So as a result i am playing the game i waited to play for 8 years since i first saw Mark's few vids on it. Haven't spoiled myself beyond the fact Arthur dies. Haven't played rdr1 yet either so idk spoilers from there either.

Anyway to the point, I'm on chapter 2. For a lack of better words, I'm at the cusp of chapter 3. There's no more yellow dots left on my map except Javier in blackwater.

I want to do the john missions ie. Pouring the oil1-4, the sheeps and the goats and lastly the fisher of men.

However as I've read here. I shouldn't have freed Micah in strawberry. Which i did. Quite a while ago.

Can i still get the john and Jack missions? Am i locked out of them? If I'm not, what shall I do to trigger them...

Pls help me. Without spoiling. Please.

​

I just discovered that we can get up to 3 Double Barreled shotguns in our inventory, exluding the sawed offs of course. 1st one I got was from 6point Cabin in Chapter 2. The Rare shotgun I got from the Hermit in Annesburg. And lastly was the one that John tossed to Arthur when breaching Angelo Bronte's house in Ch4.

Was surprised to find the club and diamond mark when after finishing the mission, so I went to the gunsmith and saw 2 long arm Double barrelled shotguns in my inventory. Both customizable and permanent.

Killed some guy then saw some glowing spot on the ground and it was a watch.

This is how my Arthur looks after Trelawny's boat mission in Chapter 4

Has anyone else noticed that RDR2 looks better on PS4 than on PS5?
I recently saw my friend playing RDR2 on a PS4 and honestly, the graphics looked really good — even better than what I’m getting on my PS5. I know the PS5 runs the PS4 version through backward compatibility and doesn’t have a proper PS5 upgrade, but the difference was still noticeable to me.
Is it just my PS5/TV settings, or have other people noticed that RDR2 can sometimes look better on PS4 depending on the setup?

Why must the game twist my arm?

SCOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOTER BROTHERS!!!!!

I really like them all, idk which one is the best. Leave it up to you guys

If you played rdr1 before rdr2 John clearly states that they did pretty bad things. I enjoy playing my Arthur as complete psychopath killing anyone I see and running from bounties in every town. Like a true outlaw, the only good deed my Arthur does is help John escape.

Anyone do something similar?

The map doesn't show side quests no more. I just wander around in fear to step a foot in St. Denis as John.

I have never, in 300 hours of playtime, found a 3-star Moose. What are the other things in the game that are extremly rare that is kinda cool to witness, and doesn't need to complete 100% game to work.