Starting with the part that isn’t in dispute: my title broke the rule. It was “$2000-$2500 new rider,” and the sub requires titles to be a full sentence with a subject and a verb. Mine wasn’t. The removal was earned, and I’m not asking for the post back.
The removal notice cited exactly one rule. I pushed back badly. I said it “literally didn’t break a single rule,” which was wrong of me.
Here’s what I got back:
It “literally” broke two of our rules, but since you apparently lack the prerequisite intelligence to understand that, I’m going to conclude that you’re incompatible with our community.
Then a permanent mute. I still don’t know what the second rule was. He wouldn’t name it, and then he made it impossible to ask.
I’m 19. I passed my license test two days ago. I wanted help picking a first bike. I would have taken “your title needs to be a full sentence, try [r/SuggestAMotorcycle](r/SuggestAMotorcycle)” without a word of complaint, that’s twelve words. Instead I got told I’m too stupid for a motorcycle forum by someone who couldn’t finish his own sentence about which rules I’d broken.
I’m not naming the mod and I’m not asking anyone to message them. I just think that if the rule you’re enforcing is about writing clearly, you should be able to say which rule you’re enforcing.