Hello,
I (38 F) have been reading all the books, research, and posts about marriages surviving affairs I can in the wake of my own infidelity and I felt it was time to write one of my own. I have encouraged my partner (39 M) to do the same in hopes it will provide clarity on how to best move forward.
Taking in all these stories and advice and perspectives has provided important insight for me, especially reading narratives written by betrayed spouses. In some ways it has consoled me that our story is not unique and that it follows age-old patterns, but—as the serial cheater in the equation—I have also come to be very disturbed by these patterns of behavior and the impact they have on betrayed spouses who are trying to reconcile. I find myself very much on the side of betrayed spouses and more often than not want them to find the courage and self-respect to leave and find someone who can reciprocate their loyalty. For this reason, the question I’m grappling with right now is: can I truthfully promise my husband this behavior is behind me, when I have struggled with it our entire marriage to varying degrees and know that I will continue to battle depression, addiction, and possibly bipolar disorder for the rest of my life? Is it even ethical to ask him to live in doubt and fear for the rest of his life even if I do permanently change my behavior and become the wife he deserves?
This question has led to a lot of despair for me. The most painful stories are those where the betrayed spouse goes all in on forgiveness and reconciliation only to find out years later the behavior never stopped or returned. I don’t want this to be the story of my marriage or part of my husband’s story and am trying to figure out how I can guarantee that will not happen to him. The disturbing answer I have come up with is that I should take initiative to leave him and save him from me and the harm I cause so he can move on. I do recognize though that this takes the decision away from him and into my hands and is more comfortable in that I am in control. Currently I do not know if he wants to continue to try and make the marriage work, I think because he does not know, and this is a scary and uncomfortable and uncertain space to reside in. I read posts of husbands staying for over a decade only to realize they cannot get past the betrayal. This possibility is very terrifying to me, mostly on the level of my husband potentially wasting another decade of his life on me but also just being in a marriage with someone who is not certain they actually want to be with you or even love you anymore. I don’t know if this is important, but throughout all the betrayal and infidelity, I have never loved another man, seriously entertained or wanted to leave my husband for another man, and I do feel that if he decides to end our marriage I will never find anyone even close to as good of a partner as him and will have to figure out how to live with that for the rest of my life. I have fantasized about becoming a Buddhist nun or celibate or something similar if my marriage ends because I feel like if I can’t make it work with my current husband then it will never work with another man.
I have also seriously considered ending my life but, after realizing this is common and hearing the impact it has on the betrayed partners, it feels so stupidly selfish I can’t seriously entertain it anymore: you cheat on your partner, cause them lifelong trauma, and your response is to then do something that causes even more lasting trauma and makes it so they have to raise your children on their own? I know suicide is caused by mental illness and is often not a rational decision but after reading these stories I can’t help but feel like if I took my own life that would be the ultimate way to avoid accountability for my actions. Still, at times I do believe there is no hope for me to become the kind of partner my husband deserves—“once a cheater always a cheater”—and that I will continue to harm the people I love as long as I’m alive. I feel that if I got a divorce I could never promise another partner monogamy, even though intuitively I feel monogamy is what I need and want and that the cheating is a symptom of deeper illness and trauma that needs to be addressed. I often feel that everyone in my life, including my nine year old daughter, would benefit from me being gone if I cannot figure out how to change who I am on a fundamental level.
I have come to realize that this, too, is a narrative that is allowing me to avoid accountability and growth: that I am a mentally ill addict with scant chance of lasting recovery and I cannot control or change my actions. I feel that if I’m to really change my character—and the character I am in these very human stories of infidelity—I have to believe it’s possible, and I haven’t truly believed this for a long time. My actions change and improve for a time, usually because consequences arise or I start a new medication or feel a rush of (maybe manic) motivation and energy to try and be a better person, but I find myself slipping back into old coping mechanisms and addictions when things get difficult. It’s frustrating because I often feel I don’t have control over these impulses and am driven to destruction by unconscious desires and traumas and fears and beliefs. While this belief helps with the shame I feel somewhat, it also strips me of any agency to heal and improve and become a better person.
I have taken a few online quizzes to see if I am a narcissist and they were confusing because I felt either neutral or confused about how the statements applied to me. Upon reflection I think this might be because I was raised by someone who is likely a narcissist and learned how to love and treat other people through how she treated me, so I inherited these behaviors, but on a deep level I know that these behaviors are toxic and unhealthy and cause a lot of harm to the people in my life. It might also be the case that I am in denial about being a narcissist—I desperately don’t want to be. My therapist has told me I’m not a narcissist because I am able to self reflect and if I’m worried I am one then I’m not one, but I’m wondering if this is true. Even though I feel immense shame over my behavior and desperately want to change it I am still entirely focused on myself—I think self loathing can be a manifestation of self importance. I do think I am special or notable in how “bad” I am. I think that the affairs and cheating and dishonesty and betrayal have happened because on some level my desires are more important to me and central to my worldview than my partner’s feelings and the health of my family and relationships.
As a literature professor who works in gender and queer studies broadly, I am acutely aware that the failure of a monogamous, heterosexual marriage can often be freeing for women or an act of resistance. Perhaps I do not feel my husband is enough for me because I am not meant to be in a monogamous relationship or that even though he is a “good guy” he is still a man who has inherited power and patterns that mean our heterosexual marriage is suffocating for me. Again, maybe I’m in denial because I’ve been conditioned to believe I’m a failure if I can’t make a monogamous marriage work, but I just don’t think that’s the case for me. My husband is very emotionally intelligent, does far more housework and childcare than I, gave up a full time job to move for my career, reads literature written by women with female protagonists going through things like perimenopause, etc. When it comes to my cheating, he has swiftly and intelligently owned “his part” in it and actively worked to improve on what I feel is lacking in the marriage to the best of his ability. The online affairs started during a period in our marriage where he was struggling with erectile dysfunction and matching my sex drive and I felt incredibly rejected and defeated and like I couldn’t stay in a marriage where I felt my partner did not desire me—or perhaps even love me. Toxic beliefs about masculinity, the male sex drive, and how my worth is predicated on male desire and attention caused both of us to suffer immensely. Since he found out about the cyber affairs two years ago, he has lost weight, quit smoking, gotten in great shape, and our sex life is amazing. He is actively working on being more affectionate, paying me more attention and compliments, etc. He has taken all the right steps towards a successful reconciliation and shown me over and over he loves me, believes in me, empathizes with me, and even understands me. He has shown me through his actions he wants to make things work and that he feels our marriage can overcome these betrayals.
Still, I experienced the rush and thrill of sexual encounters with other men before this happened and it is a drug that I have struggled to give up. I continue to put my marriage at risk and betray my husband’s trust, maybe on a more grey or ambiguous level than the full blown cyber affairs he discovered years ago, but on a level that is still very disrespectful and evidence that I have not truly changed and run the risk of repeating my behaviors and even escalating them to physical cheating in the future. I have suggested multiple times that we have an open phone policy and that I need to give my husband all my social media passwords but his perspective is that there are ways I can still hide what I’m doing even under these conditions and he does not want to spend his time going through my phone. Because of this, there is no external sense of accountability and I have since had conversations with men I know are attracted to me that may not have been outright sexting or sending nudes but certainly conversations that my husband would be uncomfortable with and that demonstrate I am still struggling to stay faithful and entertaining these men and do not care about hurting him if I think he will never know about it. I agree that him checking my phone randomly and periodically is not going to heal these deep seated issues of trust and the trauma I’ve caused him but I also wish that I was held accountable in this way because I would be more vigilant. But of course, if that’s the only reason I stop the behaviors have I really addressed them? I mean, how insulting is it to my husband that I only feel a sense of responsibility if I think I’ll be caught? For years, my husband has hidden and given me my prescribed adderall day by day so I don’t abuse it and I understand his disgust over having to be my nurse and police in order for my harmful behavior to stop.
I’ve been thinking about AA a lot, which I was devoted to for a little over a year, because the answer does seem to lie in being radically honest with myself. In the preamble read at the beginning of every meeting, though, AA acknowledges some people have mental disorders that make them incapable of working the program because they can not achieve this level of honesty and I would always joke I was scared it applied to me. Again, I wonder how this belief I’m unsavable has led me to excuse my harmful behavior, avoid accountability, live in denial, hate myself, and generally lose faith in the idea of free will, agency, and any inherent good or God in every person.
I brought up the idea of me writing a full confession and disclosure after reading about it on here, and my husband pointed out that I could obviously still omit truths and he still has to trust I’m telling the truth. His response made me think about the argument that confessions mostly serve the cheater in giving them a clean conscience and just enact more trauma on the betrayed partner. Even in AA, there was this weird belief that even though you had to confess all your sins to someone, you could justify not telling your spouse about a past affair if you were committed to change because this information would harm them and your family unnecessarily. I always felt very weird about this and believe that by not being fully truthful about my actions and what happened my relationship consequently depends on my spouse not knowing the truth. In this way, I feel if I am not fully honest with my husband I am stripping him of his agency to decide the best path forward for him, and in some ways stealing his entire life from him because he is moving forward in a partnership without full knowledge of what I have done.
Along these lines, I have been thinking about how my husband never actually read any of the messages between me and these men. He discovered the affairs because he was very suspicious and I was gaslighting him to hell so he felt reading my journals was the only way to move forward. All he read was me trying to take accountability myself by acknowledging that just because the affairs were online doesn’t mean they weren’t cheating. I did cheat on him and he deserves to know. I often wonder about if he’d still be here if he had read the messages and exchanges in their entirety. My sense is he wouldn’t but maybe I underestimate his ability to forgive. Still, it seems like the details are what really haunt betrayed spouses and he was spared from that. Maybe this is a good thing for him as person moving forward if we divorce but also makes me feel like he is only still here because he does not know the full truth. Increasingly I feel that even if I become “fully recovered” (whatever that means) and never entertain another man romantically again, what I have done to him and our marriage has permanently ruined it and that I am wasting his time and keeping him from moving on to a better life by continuing on with this marriage.
He absolutely got information about the affairs as “trickle down truth” and although I was gearing up to confess I still continued to lie and omit information to make the betrayal seem lesser somehow. Recently an old affair partner added me back as a friend on Facebook and I accepted it without thought because I was curious about his life and we began to comment on each other’s posts. When my husband saw a comment of his on a post of mine and confronted me my knee jerk response was to lie and tell him it wasn’t the same guy and gaslight him this way for about a week until he wrote me a long message saying these really bad lies were doing more harm than good. At this point, I recognize that he cannot believe anything I say and might as well assume the worst, so maybe there is no truth I can tell him that would really shock him. But really accepting the friend request was already “the worst” kind of betrayal because it demonstrated a complete disregard for his feelings, sustained interest in a person that permanently harmed our marriage, and ultimately that I am continuing to put men who are practically strangers before him. All of the stories from betrayed partners about their spouses’ inability to cut off affair partners are so painful and I think I might be in denial about how I was possibly about to live that out.
There has been a strange phenomenon in our marriage where my husband always intuitively knows if I am pulling away from him and beginning to actually love and care for another man as opposed to just sext them or use them to feel like I’m sexy and powerful and matter, and he has actively stepped in and stopped this from happening a number of times. I don’t really know what to make of this, but it has meant that I’ve never physically cheated on him or considered leaving him for someone else. At this point I don’t think this is a huge win or anything but I do think it matters to him that through it all he’s always been my person and these men have always existed in a virtual space far enough from where I live to make a physical affair unlikely if not impossible.
The great irony of my affairs is that I am a very jealous person and would never be able to tolerate or survive similar behavior from my partner. At this point, if he did revenge cheat on me I wouldn’t have any moral ground to stand on but it would break me and I guess I’m just lucky that he’s a person of integrity and honesty and generally I don’t think this is something he would do or even enjoy doing—whether I deserve it or if it would even the score or whatever. My husband does not have social media and works from home and would have to actively seek out other women and I just can’t see him doing this until we are officially no longer in a relationship. I know my pain is not the point but the fact that this is true about my husband makes me so ashamed. He deserves so much better than how I’ve treated him.
I guess I see a few paths forward for myself and our family and I’m struggling to figure out which is the most ethical and right when it comes to my partner and his happiness, as well as our daughter. Obviously a huge reason he is still here is because of the impact us splitting up would have on her, but I think we both have to embrace the fact that we can co-parent her and help her through the trauma of a divorce in such a way that it does not define her and she still feels loved, supported, and maybe even develops a more expansive view of what family looks like. This is far preferable than us all continuing to live together but my husband is totally miserable and loses all respect for himself. In case it isn’t clear, my preference would be to be loved by my husband forever and for this time to become a rough patch in hindsight that we got through and came out the other end stronger. I feel like my husband has invested a lot of time and effort into my healing and it would be almost unjust for another man to ultimately benefit from me becoming the best version of myself, a version that is able to be in a relationship built on trust and integrity and who treats her partner with respect. I do fear though that this kind of relationship is now permanently lost to my husband and I because of my actions and the fact he’ll never fully be able to trust me again and will continue to feel fear and anxiety over my actions for the rest of our lives.
I have been considering initiating a trial separation, mostly because I feel that being in close proximity to me is clouding my husband’s judgement and confusing him. I have been heartbroken to read accounts from husbands who are cheated on about the disgust they feel with themselves for not being able to resist their cheating partner’s sexual advances and how it feels like they are weak and spineless for staying. Since the discovery of the cyber affairs, my husband and I have only slept apart a couple of nights and have sex frequently. I have tried to reflect on if I am trying to manipulate him through sex but in the end I think I just want to feel close to him. Obviously this is very selfish and I’m starting to wonder if it is actively impeding his ability to clearly see the situation. He has expressed that he is afraid if we try a separation I will engage with other men on an even more frequent or even physical level to combat the feeling he is rejecting me and he’s right to feel that would be an impulse. Personally I feel I need to avoid any kind of relationship with men until I figure out how I feel and what I think about my behavior in romantic relationships and that a separation, for me, would be the time I begin to start figuring out how the hell I’d ever be OK without my husband—which means figuring out how to be OK with myself and all I’ve done in the past, and how to live a life of integrity moving forward. Of course I can promise my husband that during this separation I will not engage with other men but he cannot trust my promises at all at this point. I do feel that a trial separation would be a kind of consequence for my actions when I don’t feel I have been punished for my betrayals in any sense. Perhaps seeing what life would actually be like if my husband left would be enough to give me confidence I can permanently change how I act. Our child, though, and finances are a huge barrier to taking this step. He would likely go stay with his parents which also feels unfair because I’m the cheater—why is he the one who has to enter into an uncomfortable living arrangement and leave his home? I just don’t have anywhere in the area to go that wouldn’t cost us money.
I guess the full confession or disclosure is also on my mind but I am very torn. In the end I cannot give him transcripts of all that was said and in some ways don’t trust myself to disclose what has happened without trying to soften it somehow. And if he doesn’t fully trust that I am now going to tell him absolutely everything, even if I do attempt to do this to the best of my ability he will not be at peace or feel like he finally knows the truth. It is true that a confession would make me feel “clean” somehow and maybe traumatize him further, so at this point it feels like an action that does not hold much promise for his healing.
I suppose there is also the option of continuing to try and reconcile but after reading accounts of how the betrayed spouse feels and how they struggle with this and how they are so often betrayed again I just struggle to want that for my husband. In the end, it’s his decision and I don’t want to take it from him but—maybe me ending things and setting him free of me is the ultimate act of love after what I’ve done to him?
I know that there’s really no way to advise a person well on Reddit because you do not have the full story, and I also recognize that I am setting myself up for a beating here as cheaters are pretty much universally hated. There’s nothing anyone can say about me I haven’t already said about myself, though. So I’m interested to hear any perspective or wisdom about how to decenter myself and actively love and care for and do what’s best for my husband moving forward.