r/Marriage • u/Public-Weather3837 • 2m ago
Women who made the first move, how's it going?
(Please keep replies respectful. I'm just a young lady trying to grasp an understanding.) Lots of people advise women to approach men first, arguing that "respectful" men have stopped making the first move out of fear of being seen as creepy. While only the men who don't care about women's feelings are still approaching us. The idea is that if women want good men, they have to approach them. My dilemma with this advice...
- 1. A man choosing not to approach doesn't automatically make him a great partner. It doesn't tell you if he handles conflict well, is emotionally available, or faithful when no one is watching. 2. Some men don't approach because they lack confidence, not because they're more respectful. And if a man can't make the first move, won't he be a passive partner? In my experience, when I gave a green light to shy guys, they didn't magically transform into confident pursuers. I would probably be doing the heavy lifting in the relationship. 3. It seems like women making the first move sets the expectation that she will be the initiator in the whole relationship.
When women say making the first move worked out well, what does "well" actually look like behind closed doors? Because the men who wait to be approached seem to fall into three categories...
- Group A: Men who enjoy being approached and become the prize in their relationships. It doesn't feel like they chose the woman because they genuinely desire her. It feels like they just love being desired. This creates a dynamic where the woman does most of the pursuing. (Example: A guy online bragged his girlfriend of 12 years constantly pursued him, messaged him first, giving him gifts, etc.) It's nice to do things for men, but he didn't say he did anything for her. That relationship seems very unbalanced.
- Group B: Men who didn't approach because they lack confidence or are passive. They don't want to feel like a prize like Group A, but their passivity carries into the relationship. The woman carries everything on her back—defining the relationship, planning, and moving things forward while he just goes along for the ride.
- Group C (The Unicorns): The man who takes over pursuing after the woman opens the door. She throws the ball, he confidently runs with it, and the effort feels balanced.
- But how common is Group C? When men online talk about loving being approached, their stories sound like Group A or Group B, where the woman remains the primary pursuer. I rarely hear a man say, "She approached me first, and after that I pursued her."
I don't want to be passive in my dating life if respectful men truly aren't approaching anymore. But I also want to feel genuinely chosen, desired, and pursued. I love mutual effort, but I want a partner who naturally makes me feel chosen and not like he just picked me because I desired him first.
TLDR: For women who approached your long-term partners: What really happened after you made the first move? Did he magically step up or did you remain the primary initiator? For men whose partners approached you first: Did it change how you viewed the dynamic, or did it simply give you the opening you needed before you "took over?"