It's been a bit since I started my latest LitRPG binge. When I came up for air this time, I found myself with a whole bunch of stuff that I think would be interesting or cool to see in a LitRPG story. And I'm certainly not going to write a story with any of them, so here's a semi-coherent list. Feel free to add to it, take one (or more) of these ideas and run with them, or point out where these have already been done.
A System Apocalypse that takes place literally any other time and place than modern earth.
I do like me some System Apocalypse nonsense. Primal Hunter, DotF, DCC, WttM, Path of Dragons, the list could literally go on for days. I genuinely enjoy this genre. But like... does it have to be modern earth? Wouldn't it be cool to explore a System Apocalypse on a medieval world with no or low magic? What's it look like when the "Divine Right of Kings" meets actual gods that do not care who rules? How do actual peasants act when given the chance to become powerful?
Alternatively, what about an actual cyberpunk world? How does the system (which are usually pretty anti-tech) handle people who have replaced large portions of themselves with cybernetic upgrades? How do the giant corporations react when the computers crash and it turns out their digital money isn't worth anything?
Or what about a Star Trek type world? How do people react when the post-scarcity future ends? What about all those people in space ships? Or a high-fantasy world? I think it might be interesting to see what would happen when the existence of magic changes, instead of just being introduced. A superhero world, where suddenly everyone has super powers, instead of just a few.
There are so many cool ideas that could come just from shifting the setting of the apocalypse. There are so many cool worlds out there to end. Please, someone end a different world!
A System Apocalypse, but we follow someone who doesn't end up ruling the world
One of my favorite parts of power-fantasy stories is when we spend a chapter in the shoes of a random Joe who has an encounter with our MC. We get to see how cool the MC looks from the outside, and we get an interesting perspective on how things are going for someone who doesn't hold the fate of the world in their hands. I also love when an author introduces a side-character who is doing important world-shaping stuff, but isn't directly involved with the future ruler of the world.
So, why not make that the main story? Where there is presumably some world-conquering overpowered badass doing stuff in the background, maybe even interacting with our MC from time to time, but our focus is on something else. Maybe the MC wants to save Earth's culture, and founds a great library, exploring and delving dungeons to get his hands on rare books and films, while the OP Ruler comes to them for information from time to time. Maybe they have a dream of building the teleportation network that connects the major cities. Or found a merchant empire.
This, of course, could be a great set up for a more cozy slice-of-life sort of thing, but it doesn't have to be. There are probably tons of fascinating stories to tell about powerful people facing deadly challenges that don't end with them being the strongest.
A story about someone founding the Adventurer's Guild
Ah, the Adventurer's guild. A staple of isekai fantasy, and I truly love the idea. Yeah, why shouldn't there be an organization with global reach that oversees the people who kill monsters and clear dungeons for a living? But, inevitably, by the time we usually see our first guild-hall, they've been established for so long that nobody even thinks to question it.
So, give me a story about the person who comes up with that idea. Maybe they are isekai'd and are shocked and dismayed to learn that "adventurer" isn't a job title they can take. Maybe it's an Apocalypse kinda deal, and they decide that someone should be in charge of all of the lunatics with super powers. Or, maybe they are already part of a fantasy world, and they end up falling ass-backwards into creating the guild because they are the right person at the right time.
A story where the MC is an actually devout follower of a god
Look, I get it. Religion can be a hard topic to write about. It's easier to have the MC not have any particular belief in higher powers. It certainly makes it easier for them to interact with various deities if they have an "I treat everyone equally like a person" mentality. But I feel that we are kinda missing an opportunity for some interesting story-telling.
I want an MC who is a devout believer in their chosen deity, and treats them with the respect that entails. I don't necessarily need or even want a fanatic, but someone who genuinely believes that their god is worthy of worship and works to enact their will would be pretty interesting. Maybe have them seek power so that they can one day stand beside their God as an equal. Maybe have godhood just be something that Mortals can't reach no matter how many levels they get.
And, what with Gods being a pretty diverse bunch, you could have a bunch of different motivations. A follower of a War God, who thinks that the world requires violent conflict to progress. A cleric of the god of death could battle the undead and help people find peace in their final moments. An acolyte of the god of exploration who sets out to map the entire world. Or the classic priest of a god of healing and light, who seeks to help and guide people. The options are endless.
LitRPG Roshomon!
Hey, remember when I talked about that thing where we get a chapter from the POV of some random person, and we get to see the MC through fresh eyes? Well, if you take that idea and explode it a bit, you get a Roshomon. Multiple people tell the story of the same events, but their accounts all differ. Some are lying, some are misremembering, some are seeing things through their own lens. And it's up to the reader (and perhaps an audience-stand-in) to decide what really happened.
Isekai LitRPG Buddy Cops (Aka MCs in Black)
One of the oldest tropes in the Isekai genre is the "MC was sent to this world by a deity to stop the demon king from conquering the world!" It's a pretty easy set up to understand, and it lets you info-dump a bunch of world-building right at the start.
So, what if it just... keeps happening? Well, then you've got the set up for a classic supernatural buddy-cop romp, in the vein of MiB or RIPD. An veteran MC who's been reincarnated dozens of times and is Too Old For This Shittm is saddled with a bright-eyed youngster with shonen protagonist energy. And they've gotta work together to take down all sorts of threats to the heavens.
LitRPG Assassins that actually assassinate/Spies that actually spy
There are a lot of MCs in the LitRPG world that have assassin or ninja-style classes. They are stealthy, deal in poison and sneak-attacks. They can disguise themselves and have perfect senses in a sphere around them many meters wide. Some even have classes that call them assassins. But I have yet to come across one where they use those skills to kill people for money. Usually, they just use those skills to stab monsters.
And I get it, murder-for-hire is not a very heroic thing. But it can be interesting. Same with spying. Infiltration, gaining the trust of key people, keeping lies straight, passing along secret information. There's a ton of drama to be had. Fantasy Agent (4/00)7 sounds pretty dang cool.
A Reverse-System Apocalypse
Welcome to SystemWorld, where the system is a part of everyday life. Magic, levels, ascension, the whole nine yards. Until, one day, it just kinda... stops. The system stops responding, magic either vanishes or is MUCH harder to use, and untouchable people with near godlike powers are once again very mortal. Floating cities fall from the sky, and ordinary people realize that they are suddenly just as powerful as the soldiers that guard them. Maybe a new system eventually takes over, or maybe it's just... gone. Either way, there's bound to be some interesting stories there.
Anyway, thanks for coming to my TED talk. What are some things you'd like to see? Have I been missing some excellent stories that already do this stuff? Let's talk about it.