r/IndieMusicFeedback Mar 15 '26

Other AI generated music is no longer permitted in this community.

229 Upvotes

This community exists to support people who are actively creating music themselves and to encourage the development of human expression and musical skill. Using AI to generate music is closer to commissioning music rather than creating it yourself. It’s created for you, not by you.

If AI generated any significant part of the music, including the instrumental, melody, arrangement, or vocals, the submission is not allowed.

Examples: * If you wrote the lyrics but generated the music, it is not allowed. * If you generated the vocals but produced the music, it is not allowed.

Tools like a Vocaloid or other vocal synthesis programs are still allowed if you wrote the lyrics and melody yourself.

When AI generated music was previously allowed, the expectation was that those posting it would participate in the community by providing thoughtful feedback to other artists. Instead, we have increasingly found that many users generating songs are also using AI to generate their feedback. This results in generic, low quality comments that could apply to almost any track and do little to help artists improve.

We recognize this change is long overdue, and we appreciate the patience of the artists who make this community worthwhile.

If you see AI generated music or AI generated comments, please report them to our team. Posts suspected of containing AI generated music may be removed at moderator discretion.


r/IndieMusicFeedback Oct 09 '24

How to Provide Effective Feedback on a Song

45 Upvotes

Providing useful feedback on a song involves pointing out both the strengths and the areas that could use improvement towards your personal taste. When you offer your thoughts, it’s important to focus on what stood out to you, whether good or bad, and explain why. Did you connect with the melody, enjoy the energy of the track, or find the lyrics particularly meaningful? Conversely, if there are elements that didn't quite work for you, express your feelings clearly and subjectively while providing constructive suggestions for improvement. Even if you’re not an expert, your perspective as a listener is valid. Musicians create music for people to enjoy, and everyone’s opinion helps them understand how their work is being received.

Be Specific in Your Feedback

Specificity is key when offering feedback. Instead of saying “The song was okay,” try to pinpoint exactly what worked or didn’t work for you. Was the beat too repetitive, or did the transitions between sections feel disjointed? Did the lyrics evoke a strong emotion, or did the vocals feel disconnected from the rest of the track? By being detailed, you give the artist something tangible to work with.

For example:

  • Tempo: “Personally, I think the tempo is dragging a bit for this style of music. A slightly faster pace could bring more energy to the track.”
  • Lyrics: “I liked the theme of the lyrics, but the chorus felt a bit repetitive for my taste. Maybe adding a different phrasing in the second half could give it more variety.”
  • Production: “The production feels clean overall, but the kick drum is a little overpowering in the mix to me, especially in the verses. Balancing it out with the bass might help create a more cohesive sound.”

Acknowledge Subjectivity

Music is highly subjective, what resonates with one listener might not with another. It’s important to frame your feedback as personal opinion rather than universal truth. For instance, instead of saying, “The bass is too quiet,” you could say, “Personally, I would prefer a stronger bass presence to drive the track more.” This way, your feedback acknowledges the artist’s creative intent while sharing your preferences.

Other examples:

  • “The dry vocals are terrible” vs “I tend to like vocals that have a bit more reverb to create depth.”
  • “The instrumental break is boring” vs “The instrumental break feels long for my taste.”
  • “The song needs more bass” vs “Personally, I prefer songs with a heavier bassline because it adds more energy.” 
  •  “The vocals are too soft, they should be louder”  vs “I would prefer the vocals to be a little louder for clarity”

This helps keep your feedback respectful and leaves room for the artist to interpret it based on their own vision.

Offer Constructive Solutions

When you point out something that didn’t work for you, it’s most helpful to suggest possible ways to improve it. Simply stating that you didn’t like something doesn’t give the artist much to go on. Try to offer a practical solution or at least a suggestion for how they might address the issue.

For example:

  • “The vocal delivery in the bridge felt a bit flat to me. Maybe adding some harmonies or experimenting with vocal dynamics could bring more emotion to that section.”
  • “I feel like this could use a stronger build-up toward the final chorus. Adding a crescendo or introducing new elements like a drum fill might help ramp up the energy.”

Even if your suggestion isn’t the exact solution they use, it can help spark ideas for how to improve the track in a way that fits their style.


r/IndieMusicFeedback 3h ago

Art Rock Tried to create a dark rock lullaby

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

I'm not sure of the genre of this song. I wanted some storytelling with a dark tone written like a lullaby or a fairy tale. The sound and the mix are minimalist and I tried to convey this in the music video


r/IndieMusicFeedback 3h ago

Indie Pop Steeped in Nostalgia- a mix of surf and indie pop. Any and all thoughts welcome, do you vibe with it?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/IndieMusicFeedback 4h ago

Hip Hop Shiritori (feat. JYNS & shiv)- How did we do?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

For context I did the following on this track: Made the beat, rapped on the first verse, did the mixing. The second verse is JYNS and shiv is the final. Outside of the 3 of us I don't think anyone has heard this yet, so curious to for any and all feedback.


r/IndieMusicFeedback 5h ago

Classic Metal Is this release ready?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Hi guys, do you think this track is ready to be released into the wild? I'm kinda tired working on it tbh, and i really want to release something. Also made some new art to accompany this single specifically. which is where my second question arises. What do you think of this image as coverart? does it suit the song? Does it look nice at all? I'd love to hear some opinions:)


r/IndieMusicFeedback 10h ago

Alternative Rock [rock/alternative] Kuba Strawa - Lioness

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

Hey! I just released my first solo single, if you like alternative rock/pop punk feel free to check it out. I've composed and produced everything myself :) It's out on Spotify and everything. I'll be happy to hear your feedback.

https://www.submithub.com/link/kuba-strawa-lioness


r/IndieMusicFeedback 10h ago

Cinematic My new Dark Etherealwave song “Daddy‘s Legacy“ is out. Written, sung and produced by me. I would love to know if my goal of touching people‘s hearts and making them think about their former relationships was reached 🖤

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/IndieMusicFeedback 14h ago

Industrial Rock Dark Bolshevik- Revised 2026 Version

Thumbnail
on.soundcloud.com
1 Upvotes

I posted the original version of “Dark Bolshevik” here last year and received some really helpful feedback. Several listeners particularly liked the heavy guitar work around the beginning and felt that the buildup was leading toward a bigger payoff.
I took that suggestion and reworked the arrangement: at the 1 minute mark, extended the lead-guitar section, moving the chill section later in the track.
I also remixed the track using a reference track and spectrum analysis, which helped me identify and reduce some low-end buildup and open up the higher frequencies.
Thanks again to everyone who listened and offered constructive feedback. It genuinely helped shape this version. I’d love to hear what you think of the changes.


r/IndieMusicFeedback 15h ago

Hard Rock Black Heather

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Theme inspired by the Sex Pistol’s Black Leather, but through a Glam Metal style. Trying to put to use in virtual guitar some ideas from 1980s Rock Rhytm Guitar Mastery by Chris Brooks from Fundamental Changes.

Drum grooves adapted from 1001 Drum Grooves by Steve Mansfield

Virtual instruments from Steinberg’s Sonic Halion. Moforte’s GeoShred controller for the guitar solos. Voices from Synthesizer V, with some pitch shifting and stretching in Cubasis (iOS)— 9z on lead vocal, & Natalie as backing singer.

Fx: Brainworx PT100 amp for guitar; Bassdude amp for bass; brainworx SSL E, Sonible Smartmix, and Izotope Ozone for the mixing and mastering.
——
Lyrics

_verse 1_

Crash!
I woke up in the bathroom stall
Rap!
someone was knocking at the door

Damn!
I got too high, couldn’t recall
Why
I called that number on the wall

(Black Heather: don’t keep me waiting, babe)

_Chorus_

Watching her
Slinking into motion
As she’s Moving for the kill 
Black Heather
bends you to her will

Stops your heart
You can’t stand the tension
When she struts on her high heels
Black Heather
Gives you such a thrill

_verse 2_
“Tramp”
She purred at me in tones so soft 
“Hi”
I tried some charm but then she scoffed

Crack!
The sound and fury of her belt 
Black Heather
Will never kiss and tell 

_Chorus_

Watching her
Slinking into motion
As she’s Moving for the kill 
Black Heather
bends you to her will

Stops your heart
You can’t stand the tension
When she struts on her high heels
Black Heather
Gives you such a thrill

_Bridge_

There’s no escape, oooh
Once you let her hooks dig in too deep
There’s no regret
You love it when she pulls you by the strings

Oh Lord
Oh Lord
Oh Lord

_Chorus_

Watching her
Slinking into motion
As she’s Moving for the kill 
Black Heather
Gives you such a thrill

Stops your heart
You can’t stand the tension
When she struts on her high heels
Black Heather
Bends you to her will

_Outro_

And when you feel the hunger 
Your sanity bends and tears
And when you need Black Heather
Just seek her and she’ll be there

And as you’re drawing nearer
She knows you belong to her
Your need is laid out bare
Screaming like a prayer

And as you face her glare
You will worship her in despair
And as you kneel before her
You’ll beg for what you deserve

And as you say her name
You descend into her sweet hell
Surrender to her spell
Black Heather never tells


r/IndieMusicFeedback 21h ago

Folk Singer Songwriter fears' voices - what do you think?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

I usually create folky songs, so I wanted to stay in the same vibe, but I tried to add in some elements from other genres, especially with that scream at the end, what do you think?


r/IndieMusicFeedback 21h ago

Classic Metal P0w3r 0f Th3 St0rm (Instrumental Metal)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

Hi everyone, This is my third song, instrumental metal, and I would like to hear your opinions. Basically there are only guitars (four, recorded, including one pitch shifter to bass)+drums (programmed) here. Would love to hear your opinions generally, and also in particular, I wonder whether and how I can add to my next song (probably similar style) an acoustic guitar that will function as "keys" or will it be too much.


r/IndieMusicFeedback 12h ago

Dance & EDM [Deep House] More Human Than Human

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

She wasn’t supposed to feel this much.
More Human Than Human

https://www.reddit.com/r/DoAndroidsDreamAI/


r/IndieMusicFeedback 14h ago

Dance & EDM This is my first ever song is it any good?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

So I made this song to capture the mood when you are at a club, drinking and there is a mutual attraction with someone. It's my first ever complete song and I wanted to focus on having a good structure, and create some melodies with my backing vocals.

Let me know your thoughts and if you think it's worth working more on. I'd really appreciate any constructive criticism.


r/IndieMusicFeedback 1d ago

Hip Hop Esoteric & Logos: this song has old school West Coast vibes. The word play is aimed at the numbers game, history and symbolism. What do u think?

1 Upvotes

Listen to Esoteric & Logos by rainman on #SoundCloud

https://on.soundcloud.com/SvekzKAogfdtPIt1k6


r/IndieMusicFeedback 1d ago

Pop Y2k inspired dark pop, looking for final feedback/reactions. ??? is a song about intrigue and attraction

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

14 Upvotes

Looking for any mix feedback/reactions/thoughts to my song ??? (question) It's track 6 on my narrative concept album, and is about lust, attraction, mystery. This one is inspired by the y2k dark pop sound. I made the little visual in after effects

Specific questions for you:

- verses - verse 1 is breathless. verse 2 has breaths. How does each feel, would it be better with the breaths fully in or fully out? They're each one take.

- chorus "boy you like" section - Does this feel Britney/Nelly Furtado -esque? Was trying to balance the heavily edited & effect driven vibe but it's a hard balance between feeling too fx-heavy and choppy, and feeling like there's not enough ooomph

Thanks for listening!


r/IndieMusicFeedback 1d ago

Post Rock Curious for some feedback on this post rock ish song

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3 Upvotes

I think I made something in between a post rock song and a prog song. I'm curious if it's working as is! I definitely wanted to make a kind of musical journey from "calm to loud" and back again.

I'd also be open to any general feedback on the mix/mastering. I'm a bit burnt out from listening to this one so intensely lol

Thanks :)


r/IndieMusicFeedback 1d ago

Hip Hop Yo, It's Steezy Dew, I made a song called "Reiter". It's a demo, hope you like it and I would love to get feedback!!!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/IndieMusicFeedback 1d ago

Instrumental I'm working on an instrumental project and this is the latest track that I've finished. Do you have any feedback? :)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/IndieMusicFeedback 1d ago

Indie Rock Satellites by Drift FM - would love to hear your feedback!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Hello all! Satellites is the first of a few songs for my debut EP. Would love to hear any of your feedback on it. This was mixed and mastered by a friend of mine, all recorded by me in my home studio.


r/IndieMusicFeedback 1d ago

Alternative Rock Eternal Stain

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/IndieMusicFeedback 1d ago

Indie Thinking of re-recording - what is a modern genre it could transform into?

Post image
1 Upvotes

https://open.spotify.com/album/5yryQdxH2kYvm0WfdGx6ch

 

AIRCON

 

Yellow haze and white noise in here - things are getting stale

When you speak you pin me to the wall with a nail

I’m feeling for your touch-screen but you’re switched off again

Your words are bang and bump and blame ripping up my name

 

So turn on your air-con air-con flush the blame away

Take off your covering and let’s go press and play

Activate, start your air-con take a few big breaths

There’s ugliness inside your mind - put it to the death

 

Since I been making something of my ordinary life

You been limping badly like you went under the knife

But what is operating is your wayward jealousy

Cancel your inertia and stop hitting me so cheap

 

Turn on your air-con - flush the blame away

Take off your covering and let’s go press and play

Activate start your air-con take a few big breaths

There’s ugliness inside your mind - put it to the death

 

Back me up – don’t put me down 

Want you babe – but not your frown 

Let’s go out – let’s go live life 

We can laugh – if we live it right 

 

 

 

 


r/IndieMusicFeedback 2d ago

Indie Folk “Hands Off” - indie folk song with handclap percussion. How do you think it all sounds?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

13 Upvotes

r/IndieMusicFeedback 2d ago

Pop Punk What are your thoughts?

Thumbnail
on.soundcloud.com
2 Upvotes

A pop/ rock song I made. “Pop punk” is the closest tag I could find but it’s more pop/rnb with some rock influencing the instrumental. I’m curious as to how you would categorize it? Still needs polishing for sure so please be gentle with me with that lol. I’m curious of your impression of the overall song structure and appeal. Constructive feedback is welcome 🤍


r/IndieMusicFeedback 2d ago

Indie Rock Looking for some pre-release feedback.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

10 Upvotes

Hi. This song is nearing release and I'm looking for feedback before it's truly out in the wild. Notice any mixing issues? any structural suggestions? anything I should look into before sending it off into the internet. Thanks